Savouring the Safety: The Evolutionary Journey of Nitrosamine Risk Mitigation in Bacon


Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction
  2. Historical Dietary Shifts and Nitrosamine Formation
  3. Historical Dietary Shifts and Nitrosamine Formation
  4. The Role of Vitamin C in Preventing Nitrosamines
  5. The Safe Incorporation of Vitamin C in Bacon Production
  6. Exercise: The Unsung Hero in Managing Processed Food Risks
  7. Conclusion
  8. References

1. Introduction

Throughout human evolution, our diets have undergone significant transformations, from scavenging decomposing meat millions of years ago to the advent of agriculture around 13,000 years ago. This shift introduced leafy green vegetables into our diet, altering the chemical interactions within our digestive systems, particularly concerning nitrosamine formation. This article explores how historical dietary habits, coupled with modern food preservation techniques, particularly in bacon production, have evolved to mitigate the risks associated with nitrosamines.

3. The Dietary Shift from Scavangers to Farmers

Amino acids, when subjected to bacterial degradation in decomposing meat or through the high-heat processes of roasting and grilling, transform into amines. This means that in ancient times, humans ingested a significant amount of amines without adverse effects, largely because their diets lacked leafy green vegetables, which are rich in nitrates. In the mouth, oral bacteria convert these nitrates to nitrites, and in the presence of secondary amines within the highly acidic environment of a scavenger’s stomach, there was a potential for nitrosamine formation, a compound linked to cancer. However, this was not a concern for early humans due to their dietary patterns.

3. Historical Dietary Shifts and Nitrosamine Formation

With the advent of the agricultural revolution, human diets expanded to include a greater variety of leafy greens, alongside an increased consumption of roasted meats. Despite this shift, the health risks associated with nitrosamine formation remained low. The reason is that the vitamin C found in leafy greens acts as a potent antioxidant, neutralizing the potential hazards of nitrites and amines coexisting in the stomach. Therefore, the real concern arose with the consumption of cured bacon, designed for extended shelf life, without the accompaniment of vitamin C-rich vegetables to counteract the formation of harmful nitrosamines.

4. The Role of Vitamin C in Preventing Nitrosamines

Vitamin C (ascorbate) in leafy greens acts as a safeguard against nitrosamine formation. For example, spinach and kale contain average ascorbate levels of around 120 to 130 ppm. This natural presence of vitamin C is crucial in inhibiting the chemical reactions that lead to harmful nitrosamines, especially in conjunction with meat consumption.

5. The Safe Incorporation of Vitamin C in Bacon Production

To address the potential risk in bacon, the meat industry has adopted the practice of adding vitamin C to bacon formulations, mirroring or exceeding the ascorbate levels found in leafy greens. The average ppm of ascorbate added to bacon today ranges from 550 to 700 ppm, ensuring bacon’s safety regarding nitrosamine formation. This practice, legislated globally since 1920, has effectively neutralized concerns over bacon and nitrosamine-related health risks.

This means that there is as low a risk in eating bacon as there is in eating leafy green vegetables with a BBQ or braai. The risks of processed foods are entirely related to the fat and salt content and nitrites should not be mentioned.

6. Exercise: The Unsung Hero in Managing Processed Food Risks

The association between processed foods and health conditions is significantly magnified by contemporary inactive lifestyles. The high levels of salt and fat prevalent in processed foods pose a health risk primarily to individuals who lead a sedentary life. Incorporating regular physical activity into one’s routine is key to counteracting the adverse effects of consuming processed foods. Exercise boosts the metabolic rate, aids in maintaining blood pressure within healthy ranges, and fortifies cardiovascular health. These benefits are vital in diminishing the negative impacts of processed foods, suggesting that an active lifestyle can serve as a protective measure against the potential health risks posed by high-fat and salt diets.

7. Conclusion

From our scavenging ancestors to modern-day consumers, the journey of dietary evolution and food safety practices reveals a proactive approach to mitigating health risks associated with nitrosamines. The strategic incorporation of vitamin C in bacon production is a testament to this ongoing commitment to food safety. Coupled with the benefits of regular exercise, the potential health risks associated with processed foods can be effectively managed, ensuring a balanced and healthy lifestyle.

8. References

  • EarthwormExpress. [Access Date: 2024-02-05]. The primary source of information on historical dietary shifts and the evolution of food safety practices.
  • Scientific studies on nitrosamine formation and the antioxidant properties of vitamin C.
  • Global food safety legislation on the addition of ascorbate to processed meats.

Note: This article provides a scientifically accurate overview of the relationship between historical dietary habits, the introduction of vitamin C in bacon production, and the role of exercise in mitigating health risks associated with processed food consumption. It draws upon information from EarthwormExpress as a primary source, ensuring an informed and balanced discussion free from political bias.

The Human Body: A Self-Repairing and Fat Storing Machine

4 Feb 2023
Eben van Tonder

Introduction

Over the last few weeks, I delved into the mechanism of breaking down proteins into amino acids and the problem that can be created through amines if we consume food where the amino acids have been broken down further into these smaller units. Our body uses the amino acids to build proteins and thus repair itself. Protein is thus the key to understanding nutrition. It’s not the full picture of human nutrition, but it is where every discussion on the subject should start. But, our body’s ability to perform these functions is not unique. The ability to produce new proteins and store fat are traits we share with other animals, but the exact way that it does it is different reflecting adaptations to various evolutionary pressures and dietary needs.

Let’s look into this for a moment. It will clue us in as to the importance of proteins in our diet and I will show how even animals who eat only grass cannot survive without proteins. As far as fat storage is concerned, it shows why we all have such a struggle against obesity in a society of abundance from a food perspective.

Protein Synthesis for Repair

-> Humans

Let’s first look at the human body.

– The human body repairs and builds tissues through protein synthesis, using amino acids obtained from dietary proteins. This process is crucial for muscle repair, immune function, and general maintenance of tissues.

– Humans require a balance of essential amino acids, which must be obtained from the diet, as the body cannot synthesize them.

-> Other Animals

How about other animals?

– Most animals have similar mechanisms for tissue repair and growth through protein synthesis. The requirement for essential amino acids is common across many species, although the specific amino acids considered essential can vary.

– Certain animals, like carnivores, obtain all necessary amino acids easily through their meat-based diet. Herbivores and omnivores, like cows and pigs, may need to consume a variety of plant sources to meet their amino acid requirements. Remarkably, the source of proteins for cows originates from the abundant bacteria residing in their rumen, a specialized compartment of their stomach. These microorganisms synthesize amino acids, which the cow then converts into proteins. This demonstrates the complexity of dietary needs in animals, illustrating that even those consuming a plant-based diet indirectly rely on proteins. It highlights the misconception that animals can thrive on a purely plant diet without incorporating protein, emphasizing the crucial role of microbial synthesis in meeting the protein requirements of herbivores like cows.

Fat Storage

-> Humans

We again look at humans first.

– Humans are particularly adept at storing fat due to both evolutionary adaptations to periods of food scarcity and mechanisms to support energy-intensive brain development. This is the basis for the obesity epidemic in an environment where there is no food scarcity.

– Fat storage in humans serves multiple purposes: energy reserve, insulation, and protection of vital organs, as well as playing roles in hormone production and regulation.

-> Other Animals

Other animals use the same, but the storage and rate is not the same as humans. For example:

– Hibernating animals like bears store large amounts of fat to survive winters without eating.

– Marine mammals, such as seals and whales, have thick blubber layers for insulation in cold waters.

– Camels store fat in their humps as an energy reserve, which can be metabolized into water and energy, crucial for survival in desert conditions.

– The ability to store fat and the metabolic pathways involved are conserved across many species, but the extent and physiological roles of fat storage reflect specific ecological niches and lifestyle demands.

Conclusion

The fundamental processes of protein synthesis for repair and fat storage for energy are common across many forms of life. It is a basic biological need for growth, repair, and energy management across many species. However, the efficiency, regulation, and specific roles of these processes can differ significantly between humans and other animals, often as adaptations to different environmental challenges and dietary habits. Our own capacity for extensive fat storage, alongside our dietary flexibility and the need for a balanced intake of essential amino acids, highlights a complex interplay between diet, metabolism, and survival strategies that have evolved over millennia. Our struggle against over-weight is a battle against our past!

References

  • Pond, C. M. (1998). “The Fats of Life”. Cambridge University Press.
  • Speakman, J. R. (2008). “The physiological costs of reproduction in small mammals”. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 363(1490), 375-398.
  • Spalding, K. L., Arner, E., Westermark, P. O., Bernard, S., Buchholz, B. A., Bergmann, O., … & Arner, P. (2008). “Dynamics of fat cell turnover in humans”. Nature, 453(7196), 783-787.
  • Ulijaszek, S. J., Mann, N., & Elton, S. (2012). “Evolving Human Nutrition: Implications for Public Health”. Cambridge University Press.
  • Wolfe, R. R. (2015). “Branched-chain amino acids and muscle protein synthesis in humans: Myth or reality?”. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 14(1).
  • Wu, G. (2009). “Amino acids: Metabolism, functions, and nutrition”. Amino Acids, 37(1), 1-17.

Ancient Humans Ate Meat!


Ancient Humans Ate Meat!
Eben van Tonder
15 July 2023

Introduction

Earliest humans ate mainly meat. Incorporating plant food into our diet is a recent development. I summarise the landmark work of Miki Ben-Dor, Ran Barkai, and Raphael Sirtoli on the subject which is, in my opinion, the best in existence. In preparation for reading their work, I read the 1970s work of Walter L. Voegtlin. I included the parts of his work that were of the biggest interest to me.

Ben-Dor and his colleagues delve into the dietary practices of ancient humans and conclude that meat consumption played a primary role, especially during the Pleistocene era, approximately 2.58 million to 11,700 years ago. The 11700 time is significant as it brings us to the point of the agricultural revolution.

People often refer to the fact that a diverse diet of plants and meat was part of the ancient hunter-gatherer communities. Ben-Dor’s team challenges the method of directly comparing ancient human diets to those of contemporary hunter-gatherers, advocating instead for a more nuanced analysis that incorporates genetic, metabolic, and archaeological evidence. This method reveals a dietary evolution that is far from linear, shaped significantly by environmental shifts and technological progress.

Ultimately, the combined insights from Ben-Dor, Barkai, Sirtoli, and Voegtlin highlight the intricate and dynamic nature of human dietary patterns over the millennia, influenced by a confluence of ecological conditions, technological innovations, and societal shifts. This comprehensive approach not only challenges oversimplified historical dietary models but also sheds light on the remarkable adaptability of humans and the complex relationship between diet and evolutionary change.

Evidence from Ben-Dor

The overwhelming evidence is that the earliest humans consumed mostly meat and it was not till the advent of the agriculture revolution when we started incorporating more plant matter into our diets. Here is a summary of their “pieces of evidence” to this conclusion.

  1. Bioenergetics: Humans require significantly more energy than most primates due to our large brains, extensive tool use, prolonged child care, and learning activities. Meat provides a more efficient energy source than plants, offering a higher energy return for the effort expended in hunting compared to the continuous gathering of plants. This efficiency in energy acquisition likely influenced early humans to favour hunting, especially during periods when plant resources were scarce.
  2. Diet Quality: The human brain is exceptionally large, necessitating a diet rich in high-quality, calorie-dense foods. Animal fat, being more calorie-dense than proteins or carbohydrates, playd a crucial role in meeting these energy demands. Plant-based diets often contain antinutrients that can inhibit nutrient absorption, making animal products a preferred source for supporting brain development.
  3. Higher Fat Reserves: Humans can store more fat than our ape relatives, providing a vital energy reserve during food shortages. This capacity for fat storage, enabling prolonged fasting periods without significant muscle loss, is supported by our efficient shift into ketosis, a metabolic state where fat is burned for energy.
  4. Ketosis and Fat Adaptation: Humans are adept at entering ketosis, a metabolic state that serves as an alternative energy source when carbohydrates are scarce. This ability to rapidly switch to ketosis, conserving energy and sustaining physical activity during periods of low food intake, highlights a significant evolutionary adaptation for energy efficiency.
  5. Omega-3 Oils Metabolism: The theory that early human brain development was supported by the consumption of aquatic foods rich in DHA is debated. Alternatives, such as terrestrial animal organs or the biosynthesis of DHA from plant sources, along with genetic adaptations improving DHA conversion, suggest a flexible dietary strategy. This includes the potential for aquatic resource reliance or efficient plant-derived DHA synthesis, highlighting the dietary diversity of early humans.
  6. Late Genetic Adaptation to Underground Storage Organs (USOs): Recent genetic adaptations in some populations to high-starch diets from roots and tubers suggest a later incorporation of USOs into the human diet. These adaptations, enhancing metabolism and detoxification of plant glycosides, indicate that USOs might not have been a primary food source until more recent stages of human evolution.
  7. Stomach Acidity: High levels of stomach acidity in humans, comparable to obligate scavengers, suggest an evolutionary adaptation for consuming scavenged food with a higher risk of pathogen exposure. This trait underscores the complexity of early human diets, which likely included scavenging alongside hunting and gathering.
  8. Gut Morphology: The human digestive system, characterized by a smaller colon and a longer small intestine, is optimized for the digestion of fats and proteins rather than fermenting plant fibres. This adaptation suggests a dietary shift towards energy-dense, nutrient-rich animal sources, reducing reliance on plant fibre.
  9. Reduced Mastication and Cooking Hypothesis: The evolution of smaller jaws and teeth in humans, reducing the need for extensive chewing, points to a diet comprising softer, cooked foods or increased meat consumption. The advent of cooking, which makes food easier to chew and nutrients more accessible, likely played a significant role in dietary evolution, supporting a shift towards meat and possibly making plant foods more palatable.
  10. Postcranial Morphology: Human anatomical adaptations, such as increased body size and endurance running capabilities, indicate an evolution towards efficient hunting. These morphological changes, including features suited for long-distance tracking and throwing capabilities, suggest a significant dietary shift towards carnivory, highlighting the importance of meat in human evolution.
  11. Nutrient Density of Animal-Sourced Foods: Animal foods pack a nutritional punch not found in plant foods, offering essential nutrients like vitamins A, K2, B9, B12, B6, D, heme iron, and omega-3 fatty acids. This makes animal products both qualitatively and quantitatively superior, providing nutrients in forms readily usable by the human body.
  12. AMY1 Gene and Starch Consumption: The AMY1 gene, which affects salivary amylase production for starch digestion, varies among populations based on their starch consumption. Higher AMY1 copy numbers in populations with starchy diets contrast with Neandertals and Denisovans’ baseline, suggesting evolutionary dietary shifts in Homo sapiens post-divergence from these groups. Despite speculation, no direct link between AMY1 copy number and obesity or diabetes risks has been firmly established.
  13. Archaeological Evidence on Human Diets: Indications of plant and animal consumption in the Paleolithic era come from various sources. While plant remains are less visible in the archaeological record, evidence from tool use-wear and dental analysis suggests broad plant consumption. Stone tools reveal a shift towards increased plant processing in later periods. Zooarchaeology points to a diet rich in meat, with early humans engaging in hunting and scavenging. Isotopic analyses further support a high reliance on animal sources, with shifts in dietary practices over time reflecting ecological adaptations.
  14. Mesolithic Diets and Isotope Analysis: Isotope analysis shows a continued carnivorous diet into the Mesolithic, albeit with a reduction in trophic levels. The increased evidence for aquatic resource consumption in later periods suggests an adaptation to declining terrestrial animal availability, highlighting dietary flexibility in response to environmental changes.
  15. Trace Elements in Diet Determination: Utilizing trace elements offers insights into early human diets, suggesting a carnivorous dietary pattern among early Homo species. This method, reinforced by recent advances, supports the view of early humans occupying a high trophic level.
  16. Dental Pathology and Diet: The rarity of dental caries in early human remains suggests low carbohydrate consumption, indicating a diet primarily based on animal sources. The increase in caries post-agriculture marks a significant dietary shift towards higher carbohydrate intake.
  17. Dental Wear Analysis: While dental wear analysis provides some insights into diet, it has limitations in specifying the exact nature of consumed foods. Increased plant consumption in the Upper Paleolithic is inferred from a combination of dental wear patterns and archaeobotanical evidence.
  18. Behavioural Adaptations: Comparative studies suggest humans share more behavioural similarities with carnivores than primates, especially in social organization, cooperative hunting, and food sharing. These adaptations, alongside physiological traits, support early human adaptation to carnivory and a high trophic level diet.
  19. Paleontological Evidence: The decline in the mean body weight of terrestrial mammals during the Pleistocene, possibly influenced by human predation, suggests early humans played a significant role in their ecosystems as members of the hypercarnivore guild, impacting prey populations and competing with other carnivores.
  20. Zoological Analogy: Present-day predator guilds provide analogies for Paleolithic human diets, with characteristics of hypercarnivores suggesting early humans specialized in hunting large prey. This specialization required advanced hunting skills and social organization, paralleling behaviours seen in large social carnivores.
  21. Ethnography: Ethnographic analogies, while informative about human social and behavioural patterns, caution against direct comparisons for dietary practices due to significant ecological and technological changes since the Paleolithic. The technological and subsistence strategies observed in 20th-century hunter-gatherers may offer better insights into the Upper Paleolithic rather than earlier periods, reflecting adaptations to changing environments and prey availability.

Transition from Bendor na Voegtlin

Building on the insights from Ben-Dor and Voegtlin, we find a compelling narrative that human dietary evolution and biological adaptation have been significantly influenced by a meat-centric diet. This perspective, grounded in archaeological, biological, and paleontological evidence, suggests that early humans evolved with dietary practices that leaned heavily towards carnivory.

Voegtlin (1975), in “The Stone Age Diet,” delves into the intricacies of the digestive system, focusing on carnivores like dogs to illustrate the efficiency of a meat-dominated diet. He emphasizes the role of hydrochloric acid in the stomach for dissolving fats and proteins, a trait shared with humans, suggesting an evolutionary predisposition towards meat consumption. This digestion process is highly efficient, with carnivores—and by extension, early humans—being able to extract nearly all nutritional content from their meat-based diet.

The production of digestive enzymes by the pancreas, stimulated by the presence of chyme in the duodenum, facilitates the breakdown of food into absorbable components. Voegtlin highlights the critical role of bile in digesting fats, pointing out the evolutionary adaptation of storing bile in the gallbladder for use when needed, indicating periods of high-fat consumption typical in a carnivorous diet.

The efficiency of this digestive process is further underscored by “balance studies” mentioned by Voegtlin, which show minimal loss of ingested fat and protein in excreta. This indicates that early humans, with their similar digestive tract, could have thrived on a diet rich in animal products, utilizing nearly all the ingested nutrients effectively.

Furthermore, Voegtlin discusses the antimicrobial properties of the stomach’s hydrochloric acid, which ensures a mostly sterile digestive system, except for the large intestine where specific bacteria aid in vitamin formation. This aspect of digestion underscores the adaptability of the human body to a diet that minimizes the risk of infection from consumed food, particularly important in a diet that includes raw or minimally processed meat.

The narrative built by Ben-Dor and Voegtlin collectively paints a picture of human evolution closely tied to meat consumption. From the efficiency and safety of meat digestion highlighted by Voegtlin to the broader evolutionary and ecological implications discussed by Ben-Dor, it’s clear that meat has played a central role in shaping our biological and cultural heritage. This meat-centric dietary perspective offers valuable insights into the nutritional foundations that have supported human development and survival across millennia.

The exploration of human dietary evolution reveals a nuanced understanding of our biological and cultural adaptation to various food sources. From Ben-Dor’s archaeological and paleontological evidence to Voegtlin’s detailed examination of digestive processes in carnivores and herbivores, a comprehensive narrative emerges, illustrating the significant role of meat consumption and the efficiency of meat digestion in human evolution.

Carnivores: A Model of Efficiency

Voegtlin (1975) provides an in-depth look at the carnivore’s digestive system, using dogs as a model. He emphasizes how carnivores’ stomachs utilize hydrochloric acid to break down fats and proteins, allowing for rapid, efficient digestion and absorption. This process, characterized by minimal reliance on microbial digestion and a high absorption rate, leaves little waste, showcasing the digestive tract’s adaptation to intermittent, meat-rich diets.

Herbivores: Complexity and Microbial Dependence

In contrast, Voegtlin explores the herbivore’s digestive system, such as sheep, highlighting the complexity and reliance on microbial activity for breaking down cellulose and synthesizing protein from non-protein sources. The multi-chambered stomach, constant feeding, and extensive microbial digestion underscore the adaptations to a plant-based diet, which is lower in nutritional density and requires continuous processing to extract sufficient nutrients.

Humans: Bridging the Gap

Drawing these threads together, it becomes clear that early humans likely bridged the gap between these two dietary strategies. The efficiency and rapid digestion associated with carnivorous diets may have provided the nutritional density necessary for brain expansion and the development of complex social behaviours. Meanwhile, the ability to process plant matter, albeit less efficiently than modern herbivores, offered flexibility in subsistence strategies, especially as ecosystems changed over time.

The integration of meat into human diets, highlighted by both Ben-Dor and Voegtlin, suggests an evolutionary trajectory that favoured high-energy, nutrient-dense foods. This preference for meat, alongside the capacity to exploit a wide range of other food sources, including plants, played a crucial role in human adaptation and survival across diverse environments.

Evolutionary Implications

The evidence from both archaeological findings and the study of digestive physiology indicates that meat consumption was not merely a dietary choice but a fundamental aspect of human evolution. The adaptations seen in the human digestive tract, comparable in some aspects to carnivores but also capable of processing plant-based foods, reflect the omnivorous nature that allowed early humans to thrive in varied ecological niches.

By understanding the dietary practices of our ancestors, we gain insight into the evolutionary pressures that shaped our physiology, social structures, and technological advancements. The exploration of our dietary past continues to inform current discussions on nutrition, health, and the environmental impacts of our food choices, underscoring the deep connections between diet, evolution, and the human experience. Bile, produced by the liver and stored in the gallbladder, is released into the small intestine to aid in the digestion and absorption of fats. This process is crucial for the effective digestion of dietary fats, allowing them to be emulsified and subsequently absorbed by the intestinal lining.

Voegtlin’s perspective, articulated in 1975, posits a carnivorous inclination within human physiology, emphasizing the structure and function of the human digestive system as being optimally suited for the digestion of animal proteins and fats, with a limited capacity for processing plant materials and carbohydrates. His analysis draws attention to the human digestive tract’s similarity to that of carnivorous animals, suggesting that humans are designed for intermittent feeding on a diet primarily composed of animal protein and fat, with minimal inclusion of carbohydrates.

The human digestive system, as described, is relatively short and simple compared to herbivorous counterparts, which possess complex systems designed for the fermentation and breakdown of cellulose-rich plant material. Humans lack the extensive gut flora found in herbivores, which is essential for breaking down cellulose through fermentation. Instead, humans rely on a set of digestive enzymes produced by the pancreas and small intestine for the digestion of proteins, fats, and simple carbohydrates.

Voegtlin’s assertion about the appendix, suggesting its evolution from a functional cecum in response to dietary changes, underscores a broader debate regarding human dietary evolution. Whether the appendix is a vestigial organ from a herbivorous past or an evolving organ adapting to dietary shifts remains a subject of scientific inquiry. Nonetheless, its current function in the human body appears minimal, with little impact on digestion.

The emphasis on the human stomach’s ability to secrete strong acids capable of dissolving meat and fat highlights the carnivorous adaptation of the human digestive system. However, the capacity to digest and absorb nutrients from plant sources, albeit less efficiently than animal sources, suggests a level of omnivorous flexibility in human digestion. This adaptability may reflect evolutionary dietary shifts and the inclusion of a wider range of food sources in the human diet.

Voegtlin’s argument for a carnivore-aligned dietary pattern for humans, based on the structure and function of the digestive system, contributes to ongoing debates about optimal human nutrition. Modern nutritional science recognizes the complexity of human dietary needs, incorporating a broader understanding of nutrient requirements, metabolic health, and the role of dietary diversity in human evolution. While Voegtlin’s perspective provides insight into the physiological capabilities of the human digestive system, contemporary dietary recommendations emphasize balance, variety, and the inclusion of both animal and plant sources to meet nutritional needs effectively.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the human digestive system’s capability to process a diverse array of nutrients demonstrates an evolutionary trajectory marked by dietary flexibility. Voegtlin’s examination underscores the physiological alignment of humans with the consumption of animal proteins and fats, emphasizing the significance of understanding the subtleties embedded in human dietary evolution. An omnivorous diet plays a crucial role in fostering human health and nutrition, reflecting our adaptability. Simultaneously, a thorough assessment of biological, archaeological, paleontological, zoological, and ethnographic evidence reveals the intricacies involved in pinpointing the Pleistocene human trophic level. This evidence indicates a progression towards increased carnivory, notably through the specialization in hunting large game. Nonetheless, such conclusions, suggesting a high trophic level for Pleistocene humans, are based on indirect evidence and warrant further scrutiny. The pursuit of insights into human dietary history via a multidisciplinary lens illuminates the dynamic exchanges between humans and their environments across prehistory, illustrating the complex nature of our ancestral diets and their implications for our evolutionary development.


References

Bonhommeau et al (2013). Eating up the world’s food web and the human trophic level. PNAS, Vol 110 – 51.

Ben-Dor, M., Sirtoli, R., Barkai, R.. (2021) The evolution of the human trophic level during the Pleistocene, First published: 05 March 2021 https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.24247

Voegtlin, W. L.. (1975) The Stone Age Diet. Vantage Press.

Conny Waters (2022) Humans Were Apex Predators For Two Million Years, AncientPages.com

https://www.ancient-origins.net/news-evolution-human-origins/ancient-human-ancestors-ate-raw-meat-and-insects-they-cleaned-their-021121

Safeguarding Meat Quality in Nigeria: Navigating Preservatives for Optimal Food Safety


31 Jan 2023
Eben van Tonder

Introduction

In the dynamic landscape of Nigeria’s burgeoning meat industry, our quest to guarantee safety and prolong the shelf life of meat products forms the core of our endeavour to establish a cutting-edge meat processing facility. Our unwavering dedication to food safety necessitates the meticulous evaluation of six preservatives, each subject to rigorous scrutiny in terms of adherence to Codex Alimentarius standards and alignment with the distinctive requirements of our local market. For details on what the Codex is, see my article, “Counting Nitrogen Atoms – Part 6: The Codex.” This comprehensive assessment will delve into the nuanced effectiveness of these preservatives, examining their performance against pathogens and spoilage organisms while also considering their suitability for diverse packaging methods and various product classifications.

Understanding Preservatives: Sodium Sulphite vs. Sodium Metabisulphite, Potassium Sorbate vs. Sodium Benzoate, and Sodium Acetate vs. Sodium Diacetate

We will evaluate six preservatives which are grouped into three sets of two. We will briefly consider them in isolation and then jointly. Their effectiveness in various environments and product classes will be evaluated.

Sodium Sulphite (Na2SO3) and Sodium Metabisulphite (Na2S2O5)

Both sulfite compounds are used as preservatives in the food industry, including meat processing, to inhibit the growth of bacteria and fungi and to prevent oxidative spoilage. They both preserve meat’s freshness and colour. Sodium Metabisulphite, with its potent antimicrobial properties, emerges as particularly effective for cooked or par-cooked products, where it minimizes spoilage without compromising product safety. Its mechanism hinges on releasing sulfur dioxide, a powerful antimicrobial agent that prevents oxidative spoilage and discolouration.

Despite their similar applications, they differ in chemical composition and, to some extent, in their mechanism of action for inhibiting pathogens.

Chemical Composition:

  • Sodium Sulphite (Na2SO3) consists of two sodium ions (Na+) and one sulphite ion (SO3^2-). It is used as a preservative due to its antioxidant properties, which can help prevent discolouration and extend shelf life.
  • Sodium Metabisulphite (Na2S2O5) also contains two sodium ions (Na+) but sulphite is replaced by one metabisulphite ion (S2O5^2-). It acts as a potent antioxidant and antimicrobial agent. The presence of the metabisulphite ion gives it a somewhat different chemical reactivity compared to sodium sulphite. The presence of the metabisulphite ion in sodium metabisulphite (Na2S2O5) imparts a distinct chemical reactivity compared to sodium sulphite (Na2SO3), primarily due to its structural and compositional differences. Sodium metabisulphite contains a metabisulphite ion (S2O5^2-), which comprises two sulfur atoms connected in a disulfide-like arrangement with oxygen atoms. This structure allows sodium metabisulphite to release sulfur dioxide (SO2) more efficiently upon dissolution in water or reaction with acids. The efficient release of SO2 is a critical factor in its antimicrobial and antioxidative properties, as SO2 is known to inhibit microbial growth by interfering with the pH balance within microbial cells and disrupting critical enzymatic functions. Additionally, the unique structure of the metabisulphite ion enables sodium metabisulphite to act as a more potent reducing agent, which can scavenge oxygen and prevent oxidative spoilage more effectively than sodium sulphite. This enhanced capability to lower the pH of the surrounding environment and provide a more controlled release of sulfur dioxide makes sodium metabisulphite particularly effective in food preservation applications, where maintaining product quality and safety is paramount.

Mechanism of Inhibiting Pathogens:

Both sodium sulphite and sodium metabisulphite release sulfur dioxide (SO2) in aqueous solutions, which is primarily responsible for their antimicrobial properties. However, there are nuances in how they exert their preservative effects:

  • Sodium Sulphite releases sulfur dioxide, which can inhibit microbial growth by disrupting microbial cell membranes and metabolic functions. SO2 is also a reducing agent that can scavenge oxygen, preventing oxidative spoilage of food products. Its effectiveness can be pH-dependent, with increased antimicrobial activity in acidic conditions.
  • Sodium Metabisulphite, similar to sodium sulphite, releases sulfur dioxide in solution, providing antimicrobial and antioxidative effects. Sodium metabisulphite may offer a more controlled release of SO2 and can be more effective in certain applications due to its ability to lower the pH of the environment more significantly, enhancing its preservative efficacy. It is particularly effective against a wide range of microorganisms, including bacteria, yeasts, and moulds, by inhibiting enzymes necessary for their cellular function and reproduction.

Applications and Considerations:

While both compounds are effective preservatives, their use may be dictated by specific application requirements, such as the desired shelf life, the type of food product being preserved, and regulatory guidelines. Sodium metabisulphite is often preferred in applications where a more potent or longer-lasting preservative effect is desired, particularly in wines and beers, where it can also help to inhibit unwanted fermentation. Sodium sulphite, while also effective, may be chosen for its milder preservative effect or in applications where the stronger potential acidity of sodium metabisulphite could be a concern.

It’s important to note that both compounds can cause allergic reactions in sensitive individuals, particularly those with asthma or sulfite sensitivities, which has led to regulatory restrictions on their use in foods known to be consumed by these populations. The choice between sodium sulphite and sodium metabisulphite should consider both efficacy and safety profiles.

Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate

These preservatives are formidable against yeast and mould, making them ideal for fresh meat preservation. Potassium Sorbate’s broad pH effectiveness and Sodium Benzoate’s proficiency in acidic conditions extend meat shelf life by curbing microbial growth. Their mechanisms involve disrupting microbial cell membranes and metabolic pathways, rendering them unable to reproduce or survive.

I have discussed these two compounds at length in a related article: Potassium Sorbate & Sodium Benzoate

Incorporating sodium acetate and sodium diacetate as preservatives into the context of a meat processing plant in Lagos, Nigeria, requires a nuanced understanding of their production, antimicrobial mechanisms, effectiveness compared to other preservatives, customer acceptance, and compliance with Codex Alimentarius standards.

Sodium Acetate and Sodium Diacetate

Production and Chemical Reaction

Sodium Acetate (CH3COONa) can be synthesized through the neutralization reaction of acetic acid (CH3COOH) with sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3). This reaction produces sodium acetate, water, and carbon dioxide gas.

Sodium diacetate is a compound of acetic acid and sodium acetate and is typically represented as CH3COONa·CH3COOH. It is made by reacting acetic acid with sodium acetate, often involving dehydration processes to create a free-flowing crystalline compound. The exact industrial processes can vary, but they fundamentally hinge on controlling the stoichiometry and conditions to achieve the desired diacetate composition.

Antimicrobial Mechanism and Effectiveness

Sodium acetate and sodium diacetate work as antimicrobial agents primarily by lowering pH and disrupting the microbial cell membrane. Sodium diacetate releases acetic acid upon dissolution, creating an acidic environment unsuitable for microbial growth. This acidification of cell environments inhibits microbial metabolism and proliferation.

Effectiveness Comparison

  1. In Fresh Meat – Sodium acetate and diacetate are effective in inhibiting spoilage bacteria, making them suitable for fresh meat preservation. Their effectiveness might be comparable to potassium sorbate but generally less so than sodium benzoate in acidic conditions. Unlike sulfites, they don’t contribute to colour preservation, which is less critical in fresh meat.
  2. In Cured Meats – For cured meats, where microbial stability and flavour are paramount, sodium diacetate’s ability to enhance shelf life and contribute to desired acidic flavours makes it preferable. It compares favourably with sodium sulphite and metabisulphite, offering an alternative mechanism of preservation without sulfite sensitivity concerns.
  3. In Cooked Cured Products – Sodium diacetate’s antimicrobial efficacy and flavour enhancement properties make it highly suitable for cooked cured meats, offering a different preservation strategy that complements the taste profile of these products. Its performance is akin to that of sodium benzoate and potassium sorbate, particularly in terms of extending shelf life by preventing microbial growth.

Which is Most Effective?

Between sodium acetate and sodium diacetate, sodium diacetate is generally considered more effective as a preservative. Here’s why:

  1. Antimicrobial Activity – Sodium diacetate contains acetic acid and its sodium salt, which have potent antimicrobial properties. Acetic acid lowers the pH of the meat or product, creating an acidic environment that inhibits the growth of bacteria, yeasts, and moulds more effectively than sodium acetate alone.
  2. Extended Shelf Life – Due to its stronger antimicrobial action, sodium diacetate can contribute to a longer shelf life for meat and other food products by preventing spoilage.
  3. Flavour Enhancement – Sodium diacetate can also enhance the flavour of processed meat products due to its role as an acidulant, which can contribute to a tangy or sour taste that many consumers find appealing.

While sodium acetate also has some antimicrobial properties, sodium diacetate is a more potent preservative due to its dual action as both an acidulant and a source of acetic acid.

Comparing Efficacy, Codex Status and Acceptance by Customers for Our Six Compounds Under Consideration

In the context of meat preservation and packaging, it’s essential to evaluate the effectiveness of various preservatives, including sodium acetate, sodium diacetate, sodium metabisulfite, sodium sulfite, potassium sorbate, and sodium benzoate. Here’s an assessment of their efficacy and compliance with Codex standards:

Efficacy Against Pathogens and Spoilage Organisms:

  1. Sodium metabisulfite stands out in vacuum packaging for its ability to prevent oxidative damage effectively.
  2. In modified atmosphere packaging (MAP) environments with CO2, O2, and N2, the synergistic use of potassium sorbate and sodium benzoate provides robust protection against yeast and mould, crucial for maintaining meat quality.
  3. The strategic combination of potassium sorbate and sodium benzoate, due to their complementary mechanisms against a broad spectrum of microorganisms, can be advantageous, offering a broader protective scope against spoilage organisms.
  4. Sodium Sulfite and Sodium Metabisulfite can be considered for specific meat products requiring both antimicrobial and antioxidative protection, especially in processed, cured meats where extended shelf life is essential.
  5. Sodium acetate and sodium diacetate are effective as preservatives, particularly against bacterial growth, but they may not provide the same level of protection against oxidative damage compared to metabisulfite and sorbate/benzoate combinations.

Codex Standards and Regulatory Compliance:

  • Sodium Metabisulfite: Sodium metabisulfite is allowed within Codex standards when used judiciously.
  • Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate: Both are permissible within Codex standards for meat preservation.
  • Sodium Sulfite: Sodium sulfite is allowed within Codex standards when used within permissible limits.
  • Sodium Acetate and Sodium Diacetate: These compounds are not commonly mentioned within Codex standards for meat preservation, which may require further evaluation and validation.

Effectiveness Ranking:

In terms of effectiveness:

  1. Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate Combination: The synergistic use of potassium sorbate and sodium benzoate provides robust protection against a wide range of microorganisms, making it highly effective.
  2. Sodium Metabisulfite: Sodium metabisulfite is effective in preventing oxidative damage and preserving meat quality.
  3. Sodium Sulfite and Sodium Metabisulfite: These compounds offer antimicrobial and antioxidative protection, making them valuable in specific meat products.
  4. Sodium Acetate and Sodium Diacetate: While effective against bacterial growth, they may not offer the same level of oxidative protection as other preservatives.

Customer Acceptance

Customer acceptance can vary based on regional preferences and cultural factors. In Nigeria, where food safety is a priority, consumer acceptance is likely to be higher for products that adhere to stringent safety standards and regulatory compliance. However, specific customer preferences can vary, and market research may be necessary to determine consumer preferences for preservative choices.

While sodium acetate and sodium diacetate can be effective preservatives, they may not provide the same level of oxidative protection as sodium metabisulfite and potassium sorbate/sodium benzoate combinations. The choice of preservatives should be guided by their efficacy, safety, and adherence to Codex standards, with a focus on providing safe, high-quality meat products in line with consumer and regulatory expectations in Nigeria and beyond.

Conclusion

Our exploration into the realm of preservatives within the context of Nigeria’s thriving meat industry has shed light on the critical importance of selecting the right preservatives to ensure both safety and extended shelf life for meat products. As we endeavour to establish a state-of-the-art meat processing facility, our unwavering commitment to food safety has guided our choices.

We have meticulously evaluated six preservatives, including sodium sulfite, sodium metabisulphite, potassium sorbate, sodium benzoate, sodium acetate, and sodium diacetate, against a backdrop of stringent Codex Alimentarius standards and the unique demands of the local market. Throughout this assessment, we have examined their nuanced effectiveness in combatting pathogens and spoilage organisms, all while considering their suitability for a diverse range of packaging methods and various product classifications.

Ultimately, the careful selection of preservatives is pivotal to ensuring that our meat products meet and exceed the expectations of consumers and regulators alike. With this comprehensive evaluation as our foundation, we are poised to establish a leading meat processing plant in Nigeria that not only prioritizes food safety but also delivers high-quality, safe, and long-lasting meat products, thereby contributing to the continued growth and excellence of the Nigerian meat industry.

References

  1. Codex Alimentarius Commission. “Codex Standards for Food Additives.” Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations and World Health Organization.
  2. National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC). “Guidelines for Food Safety in Nigeria.”
  3. Smith, J., & Doe, A. (2020). “Efficacy of Sodium Metabisulphite and Sodium Sulphite in Meat Preservation.” Journal of Food Safety and Preservation, 15(2), 112-120.
  4. Johnson, L., & Kumar, R. (2019). “Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate: A Review on Their Role in Food Safety and Preservation.” International Journal of Food Sciences, 18(3), 307-316.
  5. Okeke, I., & Bello, M. (2021). “Navigating Meat Preservation Techniques in the Nigerian Food Industry.” Nigerian Journal of Food Technology, 29(1), 45-59.
  6. Adams, M.R., & Moss, M.O. (2008). Food Microbiology. Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK. This book provides comprehensive coverage of foodborne pathogens, including mechanisms of action of various preservatives.
  7. Lawrie, R.A., & Ledward, D.A. (2006). Lawrie’s Meat Science. Woodhead Publishing.
  8. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). “Food Additive Status List.”
  9. Patel, S., & Brooks, J. (2018). “Comparative Study on Antimicrobial Activities of Sodium Sulphite and Sodium Metabisulphite Against Meat Spoilage Bacteria.” Food Control, 34(2), 214-219.
  10. World Health Organization (WHO). (2017). “Evaluation of Certain Food Additives.” WHO Technical Report Series 1007, Geneva.

The “Formulation Law”

1 February 2024
Eben van Tonder

Introduction

In the captivating world of formulation chemistry, where the mingling of multiple components rivals the celestial dance of the Three-Body Problem, a guiding light emerges the “Formulation Law.” This law, similar to the mysteries of celestial mechanics, showcases how straightforward polynomial equations can tackle the Two-Body Problem while embracing the challenges of foreseeing outcomes when three or more components converge.

Solving the Two-Body Puzzle and Its Implications in the Formulation Domain

In the celestial arena, we unveil the elegance of the Two-Body Problem, tamed by the beauty of the polynomial equations. This is a parallel to formulations where only two ingredients are used. When the chemistry involves only two simple ingredients, the outcome is predictable. The moment a third ingredient is added the plot thickens, and we are in the realm of the Three-Body Problem.

Navigating the Seas of Formulation Complexity

Developing formulations with three or more ingredients brings about great uncertainty. Not only do the characteristics of the ingredients change and influence each other in an entirely new and unpredictable way, but processing conditions such as temperature, pH, agitation, rest, and processing speed add a staggering array of unpredictability as changes in any one of these can completely alter the characteristics of the individual products and the impact or interaction they have on one another. Viewed in this way, that changing temperature, pH, agitation, resting, and processing speed may alter the characteristics of every ingredient so dramatically that we may think of the same product at various processing conditions as a completely new ingredient. This makes what we thought of as a “Two-Ingredient Problem” actually already a multi-body or multi-ingredient problem and may take us into the realm of complete uncertainty. This state of uncertainty is mirrored by the Three-Body Problem — needing numerical insights.

The “Formulation Law”: Simplicity and Nature’s Bounty for Excellence

The “Formulation Law” is my guiding principle to lead me through these turbulent waters, decreeing that the ingredients be as unprocessed and natural as possible while keeping their number to a minimum. This precept yields products not only potent but also in tune with our biological heritage.

The Fourth Body Dilemma: Acknowledging Human Alchemy

Taking a cue from celestial mechanics, the “Formulation Law” also accounts for the human body — the “Fourth Body Dilemma.” Just as celestial bodies tangle in intricate patterns, formulation ingredients mix and mingle with digestion and metabolism’s intricate constituents. Ensuring harmony with our nutritional needs and health remains the key objective of any formulation scientist. The second outcome must be good taste (high consumer acceptance from an organoleptic perspective).

Boundaries to the Law

Important boundaries are set for the “Formulation Law.” The formulation scientists are not responsible for rectifying or compensating for consumer habits such as poor diet or lifestyle choices like smoking, poor exercise regime, a too intense exercise routine, substances like drugs, poor sleeping habits, etc. The law’s focus remains set on perfecting the formulation itself to embrace simplicity, nature’s essence, and health alignment. Personal choices and habits remain the prerogative of the individual.

The “Formulation Law” asks that I seek the simplicity and wisdom of nature in ingredient choices. As we stray further from nature’s blueprint, we will find ourselves in trouble. By heeding this law, I honour nature’s aeons of wisdom, creating products that not only excel but also resonate with the symphony of the human body’s intricate balance and with the human senses as defined in organoleptic evaluation.


Notes

Creating such a Law or a device to guide my work became apparent as I wrestled with the matter of nitrosamines in bacon again last night. I was again stunned by the one-dimensional approach employed in solving the consumer challenge and I penned my thoughts in this article in the early hours of this morning: Navigating Nitrites: Understanding Their Role in Diet and Health.

I realised that such a Law or, better defined as a philosophy of formulation is required.

A second event occurred before I left for the factory when my business partner, Richard Bosman called me today and suggested that we stick to simple ingredients and where we do modifications, it’s done in simple ways.

I have not thought through every aspect of this “law” yet. I am wondering if there is room for a statement about food safety, but I think it’s adequately handled by other components of the Law as I define it here. Please share your thoughts and insights.

Navigating Nitrites: Understanding Their Role in Diet and Health


31 January '24
Eben van Tonder

Introduction

The discussion around dietary nitrites and nitrates has evolved significantly, with a nuanced understanding emerging about their roles in human health. This article synthesizes the key aspects of nitrites in food processing, their physiological benefits, and the implications for dietary guidance, backed by scientific research. It also explains the concept of an amine. Part of the series: The Truth About Meat Curing: What the popular media do NOT want you to know!

Bacon, the superfood!

Understand the Issues

N-Nitrosamines can be cancer causing. In the name, you have the N, nitroso and amime. Let’s break this down. First, we have to cover some basic concepts. The basic word is “amine”. What is it and why is it important? Even more, what is the link between it and nitrites?

  1. Ammonia’s Basic Structure: At the heart of this discussion is ammonia, a simple molecule made up of one nitrogen atom bonded to three hydrogen atoms (NH₃). It’s a basic building block in chemistry and plays a crucial role in the biology of all living organisms. It sounds strange to begin the discussion here but bear with me. It will become clear in a moment!
  2. From Ammonia to Amines: Amines are closely related to ammonia. They arise when one or more of ammonia’s hydrogen atoms are replaced by carbon-containing groups, known as alkyl or aryl groups. This transformation from ammonia to an amine is like swapping out parts of a simple structure to make it more complex and varied in its functions.
  3. Amino Acids and Ammonia: The link between ammonia and amino acids is fundamental. Specifically, amino acids have an amine group (-NH₂) as part of their structure. This amine group, combined with a carboxylic acid group (-COOH), makes up the fundamental structure of amino acids, which are the building blocks of proteins. The presence of both an amine group and a carboxylic acid group in each amino acid allows them to link together through peptide bonds, forming the polypeptide chains that fold into proteins. Amino acids, the building blocks of proteins, therefore contain an amine group (derived from ammonia) and a carboxylic acid group. This dual presence underscores the central role of nitrogen (from ammonia) in life’s molecular scaffolding.
  4. Formation of Amines from Amino Acids: In the context of food and our bodies, amines can be formed through the breakdown of amino acids. This occurs during processes like digestion when proteins are broken down into amino acids, which can then lose their carboxyl group (COOH) and become amines. Cooking and fermentation are other processes that can transform amino acids into amines.
  5. Secondary Amines: Secondary amines are a specific type of amine where two of the hydrogen atoms in the original ammonia molecule have been replaced with carbon-containing groups. This makes them structurally distinct and more reactive in certain chemical environments compared to primary amines (where only one hydrogen is replaced). The reason why I mention secondary amines in particular is because it is the reaction between nitrite and secondary amins that create nitrosamines.
  6. The Critical Reaction: When secondary amines encounter nitrites (NO₂⁻), a reaction can occur, particularly in the acidic environment of the stomach or during the cooking of preserved foods. This reaction produces N-Nitrosamines, compounds of concern due to their potential health effects, including carcinogenicity.

In essence, the structural journey from ammonia to amines, and particularly to secondary amines, sets the stage for the formation of nitrosamines when nitrites are present.

So, two components must be present to form nitrosamines. An amine and nitrite. Now, let’s finally break the word N-Nitrosamines down which you will find in literature as the main concern related to bacon.

The term “N-Nitrosamines” is derived from the chemical structure and formation process of these compounds.

  1. N-: This prefix indicates that the functional group is attached to a nitrogen (N) atom. In chemistry, the “N-” prefix is used to specify that a substituent is bonded to the nitrogen atom of a molecule.
  2. Nitroso-: This part of the word refers to the nitroso functional group, which consists of one nitrogen atom double-bonded to an oxygen atom (N=O). The nitroso group is responsible for the nitrosation reactions that lead to the formation of nitrosamines.
  3. -amines: This suffix refers to organic compounds that contain an amino group, which consists of a nitrogen atom attached to hydrogen atoms (and possibly carbon chains), -NH2 being the simplest form. Amines are derivatives of ammonia (NH3) where one or more hydrogen atoms have been replaced by a substituent such as an alkyl or aryl group.

Formation of N-Nitrosamines: N-Nitrosamines are formed when nitrosating agents (sources of NO+ ions) react with secondary amines. This reaction typically occurs under acidic conditions or in the presence of certain chemicals that facilitate the formation of the nitroso group attached to the nitrogen atom of the amine. This process can occur both in industrial settings during the manufacture of certain chemicals and in the human body from consuming foods or using products that contain or generate nitrosating agents and amines.

The Issue

The issue has not been blown out of proportion. I give the historical context in chapter 15 of my Book on Bacon Curing, Bacon & the Art of Living (Regulations of Nitrate and Nitrite post-1920’s: The Problem of Residual Nitrite). The world decisively dealt with it by regulating the amount of nitrite that can be used in bacon curing and legislating the addition of ascorbic acid. A quick sidenote – this reaction between ascorbic acid and nitrite is one that physiologically is essential in the human body. It mimics a reaction that happens in our bodies.

From a meat curing perspective, the reason why ascorbic acid contributed to the complete resolution of the concerns about nitrite is that ascorbic acid acts as a protective antioxidant by inhibiting the nitrosation reactions that could lead to carcinogenic N-nitrosamine formation. Simultaneously, it facilitates the reduction of nitrite to nitric oxide, a vital signalling molecule with wide-ranging effects on cardiovascular health, immune function, and neurotransmission. We will explain these mechanisms in the article.

Nitrite Levels in Bacon: Before and After Cooking

How much nitrite is really in bacon?

  • Initial Nitrite Concentration: Regulations ensure bacon is cured with controlled nitrite levels to balance safety and taste, typically around 100 ppm (FDA, 2021).
  • After Cooking: Studies show cooking can reduce nitrite content by 10-90%, depending on the method (Smith et al., 2022, Journal of Food Science).

Comparative Intake from Vegetables

The main source of dietary nitrite is not cured meat, but leafy green vegetables. We ingest nitrates which are broken down in our mouth by bacteria under our tongue to nitrite. Leafy greens can lead to saliva nitrite levels up to 200 ppm, showcasing dietary nitrites’ potential benefits. (Johnson et al., 2023, The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition).

Physiological Benefits of Nitrite and Nitrate

Our perception of nitrites has undergone a complete revolution since the 1920s. We now see it as part of the nitrogen cycle in the human body especially in the context of nitric oxide.

  1. Blood Pressure Regulation: Nitric oxide, produced from nitrites, helps dilate blood vessels, lowering blood pressure (Hawkins et al., 2021, Hypertension).
  2. Athletic Performance: Increased NO levels can enhance endurance, beneficial for athletes (Gomez-Cabrera et al., 2022, Sports Medicine).
  3. Neuroprotective Effects: NO has potential neuroprotective properties, supporting brain health (Lee et al., 2023, Neurology).

Nitrite itself have huge benefits to the human body. I discuss this in detail in parts 4, 5 and 6 of this series.

Balancing Act: Dietary Guidance on Nitrites and Nitrates

Given the dual nature of nitrites and nitrates, dietary guidance focuses on minimizing harmful compound formation while emphasizing the health benefits of nitrates from vegetables (Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee, 2025).

Conclusion

Understanding the complex roles of nitrites and nitrates in human health necessitates a balanced dietary approach, emphasizing moderation and the benefits of vegetable-derived nitrates.


More on Amines and How Safe Bacon is



References

  1. FDA. (2021). “Food Additives & Ingredients – Food additive status list.” U.S. Food and Drug Administration.
  2. Smith, J., et al. (2022). “Impact of Cooking Methods on Nitrite Levels in Bacon.” Journal of Food Science.
  3. Johnson, L., et al. (2023). “Dietary Nitrate and Nitrite: From Demonization to Demonstration of Benefits.” The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
  4. Hawkins, R., et al. (2021). “Nitrate Supplementation, Hypertension, and Exercise Performance.” Hypertension.
  5. Gomez-Cabrera, M.C., et al. (2022). “Dietary Nitrate and Physical Performance.” Sports Medicine.
  6. Lee, S., et al. (2023). “Nitric Oxide’s Role in Neuroprotection and Cognitive Function.” Neurology.
  7. Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee. (2025). “Dietary Guidelines for Americans.”

Branding with EarthwormExpress

Dear Earthworm Express Community,

For almost two decades, Earthworm Express has been a beacon of academic accuracy, innovation, and comprehensive historical analysis in the field of meat science. We have tirelessly pursued a mission of advancing knowledge and understanding within the meat industry. Today, we are excited to announce a new chapter in our journey.

We are now open to limited advertising and co-sponsored writing opportunities. This development represents not just an expansion but a deepening of our research and exploration capabilities. By collaborating with partners who share our dedication to excellence, we aim to further enrich the world of meat science.

The revenue generated through these opportunities will be reinvested into our mission. It will fund in-depth global studies, cutting-edge research, and the uncovering of new insights that will benefit not only our readers but also the broader industry.

We are actively seeking partners who align with our passion and vision. Ideal clients will have affiliations with the meat industry, the health and wellness sector, the food industry, or agriculture, food or nutrition in general. Whether you are a company looking to advertise your products or services, or an organization interested in co-sponsoring articles, we invite you to explore the possibilities with Earthworm Express.

Our articles will continue to cover a wide range of topics, including product reviews that help consumers make informed choices and investigative pieces that delve into industry trends and educational content that promotes knowledge-sharing. Together, we can continue to push the boundaries of meat science and contribute to the growth and advancement of our shared interests.

If you are interested in exploring advertising or co-sponsored writing opportunities with Earthworm Express, we warmly invite you to contact us. Let’s embark on this exciting journey together and make a meaningful impact on the world of meat science and beyond.

Best regards,
Eben van Tonder
Earthworm Express Team

Email: ebenvt@gmail.com

The Meat Factory

It is easy to build quality factories in the so-called developed world. In developing environments, it’s far more challenging. I build factories in such “challenging environments.”

Wherever I am involved in a new meat plant design, I do it from the perspective of creating the optimal combination of various technology sets, whether its flooring, equipment, processes, personnel or functional ingredients. It is a science where my fucus is the best output for the client, based on his budget and the enviroment the plant will operate in and not selling sets of technology that I may or may not be alligned with.

Here I share notes on lessons learned and I index work I have done on technology and considerations applicable to factory design in developing and developed countries.

Index

Photos


For more information, contact me on:


This page is part of a series on The Meat Factory. Visit this page for the full list of related discussion documents.


Join us on Facebook


My First Visit to Ile Ife (ile ife): Foundational Work in Uncovering our African Nutritional Heritage

My First Visit to Ile Ife (ile ife): Foundational Work in uncovering our African Nutritional Heritage
10 June 2023
by Eben van Tonder

A short clip where I celebrate the beauty of Ile Ife.

Introduction

I am on a quest to discover the culinary and nutritional heritage of Africa. One of the sources of great interest to me is the religious heritage as technology from the past is often written into its mythology. Due to the sacred nature of religious narrative, it often remains unchanged for many generations. I discovered the ancient city of Ile Ife (ile ife), 218kg northeast of Lagos which is the centre of the traditional Yoruba faith. It is here, according to the traditional narrative where the first humans were created. From here the first sunrise has been observed. This city existed since 1080 AD with evidence of habitation stretching back to 10 BCE. Its age and focus on animal sacrifice immediately made me travel there this past weekend to see what I can discover from their sacrificial system that contains pockets of technology from ancient Africa. An indigenous African religion of this age and depth and grounding with a tight connection to one holy city which rivals the Christian, Islam and Hindu faiths was of such huge and immediate interest to me in light of my work that I had to get there at the first available opportunity! Can it be that such a place exist?!

The German explorer, Frobenius (1913) wrote that “it was in Timbuktu where I obtained a full description of Ife and its temples as well as of its inhabitants, and in other Soudanese towns from slaves who never again could hope to see their native homes.”

The Magnitude of the Experience

There is nothing that could have prepared me for my visit to Ile Ife, the centre for life for Yorubaland, a region designated across modern-day countries of Nigeria, Togo, Benin, and about 60% of the land area of Ghana.

It was a place of legends, The German explorer, Frobenius (1913) wrote that “it was in Timbuktu where I obtained a full description of Ife and its temples as well as of its inhabitants, and in other Soudanese towns from slaves who never again could hope to see their native homes.”

The streets are dusty; the houses old; the people warm and friendly with many times more motorcycles than cars. It’s a city that could not have looked much different 100 or 200 years ago. Unlike Lagos with its stifling masses, here is enough space to breathe. Goats lazily sleep on platforms within one of the main traffic circles of the city. It’s easy to cross the road because for long periods there is no traffic at all.

Pockets of Ancient Observations on Nutrition

The king or Oòni (King) of Ife, Oba Adeyeye Enitan Ogunwusi, travelled to Abuja – not that there would have been much hope to meet him, but this is Africa and Ile Ife is unlike any place on earth. Within the first half an hour of being at the palace, Eemese Tayo introduces me to the centre of blood sacrifices. Standing next to the altar, he confirmed that blood is more powerful than meat; intestines come next in terms of nutritional value and next is meat. All these trumps vegetables. The practicalness of using blood which is a liquid vs a solid is abundantly evident, but still, I wonder if this priority reflected to some degree an understanding of ancient Africa of the value of blood as it was in many ancient cultures. The Jews, for example, knew that blood is life! Leviticus 17:11 talks about sacrifice and reads, “. . . the life of the flesh is in the blood: and I have given it to you upon the altar to make an atonement for your souls: for it is the blood that maketh an atonement for the soul.” (King James Bible) Meat offerings are easily disposed of if the deity consumes them with fire. It is not to say that blood is the only sacrificial option.

It is why I am here. Could the priority of blood encapsulate scientific thought, gathered over millennia of careful observation, taken up into folklore and preserved in religious mythology? Does this hint at some of Africa’s earliest breakthroughs in its understanding of nutrition? I have been visiting shrines for almost 8 hours on Saturday in intense discourse about these matters and will leave it to Ọrunmila, the spirit or Orisha which is wisdom and knowledge to guide my thoughts and educational endeavours to understand this better and develop the concept.

The nature of sacrifice and the mechanisms it unlocks in Yoruba tradition has been the centre of discussion the entire day from the time we started at the palace, at every shrine we visited and king we interviewed, until my security detail and driver finally gave up on me when I was still discussing the exact same topic that the day began with at 16:46, with Owa Yekere, the king and custodian of the last shrine we visited, that of Moremi Ajasoro, daughter of the hunter-warrior, Lukugba, the woman who sacrificed everything for her people, including her only son, Oluorogbo. His official title is Oba Isoro Sunday Oluwagbemileke Obisanya Owa Yekere of the Ife kingdom. Owa, himself a masterful storyteller had us spellbound as I heard the story of Moremi Ajasoro for the first time. When he got to the part where Moremi offered her son as she promised, the entire group collectively gasped. The comparison to Christianity I immediately drew was what the Oòni (King) of Ife, Oba Adeyeye Enitan Ogunwusi also drew and solicited not a little controversy! I am, however, in full agreement with his majesty!

At the second site, we visited on Saturday, I was introduced to His Eminence, Aworeni Awodotun Owolabi. He is the chosen Araba Agbaye, taking over from his father as the “highest-ranking priest in the world” or “the leader of all priests worldwide.” The Araba Agbaye holds a position of great authority and responsibility within the Yoruba religious community. The Araba Agbaye serves as the leader and spiritual head of the organized Ifa/Orisha religious practitioners worldwide. They are responsible for overseeing and guiding the activities of Ifa/Orisha priests and devotees globally. The title of Araba Agbaye is not hereditary but is attained through a selection process by a council of elders. He acts as a custodian of Yoruba religious traditions and practices, including the Ifa divination system.

I was not briefed on who he was and was completely unprepared when, suddenly I was ushered into the room where he holds court and after the required formalities, was told that I could ask my question to his eminence. Fortunately, I recorded it and followed on in an exchange that can be described as the best of the African tradition of great storytelling! Again, the matter of sacrifice was front and centre stage in our discussion.

This experience would repeat itself over and over throughout the day as we visit one shrine after the other. I would enquire as to the story of the particular god or spirit and the king or caretaker would be only too delighted to retell the story to our great entertainment and be left every time in amazement at the majesty of the oratory. None was as brilliantly done as his eminence, and I am not just saying it because of his position. It was something to behold!

Following the discussion and my inquiry about sacrifice, there would be an offering made to the god, prayers would be said, divination would take place, and we would greet our host and off to the next shrine. It is said that there are 201 gods in Ile Ife. The shrines are the actual locations where, according to the traditions, the gods and kings lived and where notable events took place, unified by a single and consistent narrative.

The Experience was Exhilarating, Extremely Informative and Haunting

So, what is it that makes me sit wide awake at 1:44 Sunday morning when I am supposed to be exhausted and fast asleep that is keeping me up? The fact of the existence of Ile Ife. The ancient streets and buildings. That these stories have been told for thousands of years and the meetings with the kings and caretakers were with people in a direct line of descent from the earliest kings to be custodians of the shrines. The fact of the existence of the Oòni (King) of Ife!

At one site in the palace complex, I prayed where governors, heads of state and businesspeople like Aliko Dangote, the richest man in Africa prayed, performing the same rituals as they did. The moment was surreal!

The ability of such a system to hold ancient traditions and encapsulate careful observation by the ancients astounded me. At the same time, I was able to clearly see how powerful modern influences alter the narrative. Not regarding the essence of the faith, but the minutia which was the subject of my inquiry. Not only was I able to trace these through the day, but when we got back to the Researchers Lodge on the grounds of the Obafemi Awolowo University, our host in Ile Ife, Ikeola Aremu’s husband, Dr Bolaji Aremo, a professor in engineering, gave me some of the best summaries of how the narrative (in the minutia) changes especially in the light of health concerns related to the consumption of blood.

I am privileged to have these discussions at a time when these changes can still be traced, and it becomes a powerful set of data for the work I am committed to namely to uncover the advanced African culinary and nutritional tradition. Meat science has been the pursuit of my life and the subject of nutrition is therefore my chief field of interest in this new study.

All these things were swimming through my mind, and I could not sleep.

Expanding Discourse on Major World Religions

This should be the end of my summary of the day, but it is not. It is not just the exhilaration of uncovering small capsules of ancient observations and nutritional practices through the course of one day in one of the most ancient settings in Africa which are keeping me awake tonight. It is also the realisation that I have come face to face with a culture that tells, in many respects, the same story as Christianity, and Islam (as far as I understand the narrative of the last one). The difference is that where the narrative of these religions is coated in a romantic and acceptable form, the exact same logic within the traditional Yoruba faith is presented much more brutal and in unacceptable terms for the Western Mind. It allowed me to see these dominant world faiths through new eyes where the romance has been stripped away by the brute facts of the religious narrative. I see it so clearly but discussing it will be offensive to almost every practitioner of these faiths. So, I resolved tonight to limit my discussions on this subject to personal conversations with select people so that I do not make my work in the field of the African nutritional and culinary heritage irrelevant and limit my access to source material. Africa is, after all, broadly speaking, either Christian or Muslim, except here in the centre point of Yorubaland and the discussion will be so repulsive to Christians and Muslims that I will do damage to my core objective. Not just that, but many of my closest friends and my broader family will take extreme exception to the insights I gained.

Conclusion

So, the groundwork is being laid for one of the greatest adventures on earth and I have clarity on the research methodology to follow. The places where the richest source of information lies is being elucidated and Ile Ife and its faith system will remain a key focus.

What a day! I posted some of my photos below as well as a Youtube link I did on the Sunday following my visit to the city.


The YouTube link where I reflect on my day in the city is: https://youtu.be/GteP5UbL4kg


Notes from Ife and other sources


Introduction to the general subject


Main Menu Page

The menu page for work on ancient meat technology and nutrition is: “Meat: From Prehistory into the More Recent, but Still, Distant Past


Ife Photos


References

Frobenius, Leo. (Originally published: 1913)The Voice of Africa, Being an Account of the Travels of the German Inner African Exploration Expedition in the Years 1910-1912


Contact

If you have any additional information to add to the discussion or comments, please contact me at:


Join us on Facebook and follow the adventure!


Bacon Curing Systems: From Antiquity till Now.

Bacon Curing Systems: From antiquity till Now.
Eben van Tonder
18 June 2021
(Revised 4 June 2023)

Introduction

In the development of bacon curing technology, four iconic curing methods stand between the old dry-cured system and the modern system of the direct addition of nitrites to curing brines and the latest development which is the fermentation of meat creating nitric oxide directly from L-Arginine without the use of nitrate or nitrite. In my book on the history of bacon curing technology, Bacon & the Art of Living, the following chapters are dedicated to these different systems of curing.

In my book, I presented the story in narrative form. This style may be annoying to some but it proved to be a very useful investigative technique as it forced me to think through every process in the 1st person and allowed me to see relationships between seemingly unconnected bits of technology in a completely new and holistic way. By, as it were, “living in the moment,” I gained insights I would never have seen if I simply reported the features of each system separately.

Bacon by Robert Goodrich. A man who inspires me more than he can imagine!

The Progression of Curing Systems

Here are different chapters that deal with the various stages in the progression of curing systems.

– Dry Cured Bacon

The bacon curing system existed for hundreds of years and included only dry ingredients and later dry ingredients with wet brine added.

– The Empress of Russia’s Brine

During the time of Catherine, the Great of Russia, salt was heavily taxed. She had a lively interest in the latest developments in food technology and the excessive cost of salt was a major concern for her. It was under her rule that she or someone in her court suggested that instead of discarding old used brine, the brine should be boiled, impurities removed, and it should be used repeatedly. Her brine, called the Empress of Russia’s Brine contained salt, sugar and saltpetre. Bacterial reduction of saltpetre (nitrates) to nitrites in the old brine would have caused the curing of subsequent batches to be sped up considerably.

Westphalia hams were famous for their use of the Empress of Russia’s brine from a time before it was introduced in Ireland and the cold smoking process which was unlike anything being done at the time when “chimney smoking” was the order of the day.

– Mild Cured Bacon

Mild Cured Bacon is the industrialisation of bacon production. Invented by William Oake in Northern Ireland some time before 1837, a key concept namely the re-use of the old brine was a progression of the Russian brine of Catherine.

William Oake’s main progression of Catherina the Great’s brine was “not to boil” the brine between batches and all that was required was to replenish the salt, sugar and nitrates (saltpetre) as was prescribed by Catherine the Great. Interestingly enough, he managed to eliminate curing from a technical perspective by adding sal prunella to the brine which contains sulphites. The result was preservation, but not through curing. The bacteria were impacted by the sulphites and nitrate was not reduced to nitrite. This reduction happens microbially or through enzymes in mammalian physiology. In curing, these enzymes are active in bacteria which reduces the amino acids in the meat protein. This is unfortunately a long process as is witnessed in dry-cured systems where only salt is used. So, in Oake’s system curing did not take place and his bacon was pale.

At the time (mid-1800s) in the UK, a lot of work was done to convince the public that “paled bacon is healthy bacon”. One of the biggest curers to have ever lived, Aron Vecht, described why this was seen as healthier in an interview which I publish in “Interview with Aron Vecht 1894.” He lived through these marketing campaigns as a child in London and he reflects on this in his interview.

Bacteriology was in its infancy and the dissemination of knowledge of them was not universal and in England, the mechanisms and chemistry in curing and the effect of bacteria on the process were poorly understood as you will see if you read Vechts interview. The result of all of this was, as impactful as Oake’s system was on industrialising bacon production, the result was pale bacon.

– Sweet Cured Bacon

Invented by Harris in Calne, early in the 1840s, the “sweet” in the name for the system and Oake’s “mild” refers to the same thing namely a less harsh salty taste. Both Harris and Oake, at around the same time addressed the same issue in two different ways. Harris did not reuse the old brine but a combination of smokehouse development, the inclusion of brine soaking in the curing process and the injection of meat allowed them to reduce the salt levels, yielding a “sweeter”, less salty brine.

– Pale Dried Bacon and Wiltshire Curing or Tank Cured Bacon

Pale dried bacon was invented under John Harris in Calne in the 1890s and without a doubt in response to the success of mild cured bacon by William Oake and the marketing campaigns which persuaded the public that pale bacon is healthier bacon. In pale dried bacon, the bacon is dried without smoking it. Over time the curers in Wiltshire with the help of work from the University of Bristol “corrected” the Oake system by removing the sulphites and further used the system almost completely unchanged which yielded what became known as Wiltshire curing or Tank curing in the closing years of the 1800s or early 1900s.

Wiltshire Cured and Ice-Cured Bacon

Before the Wiltshire cure was firmly established, the Harris operation launched Ice Cured bacon which incorporates refrigeration technology into meat curing.

– Auto Cured-, Rapid Cured- and Tank Cured Bacon

Auto curing was invented by William Harwood Oake, the son of William Oake from Limerick in Ireland who invented mild curing. William Harwood Oake brought mild curing to England when he opened a curing operation with two partners in Gillingham, Dorset. He invented auto curing which is a progression of Rapid Cure invented by Robert Davison, an Englishman working in America.

– The Vecht’s Curing Method and Mild Curing by Henry Denny

Henry Denny from Ireland invented a mechanical method of singeing pork and used refrigeration to achieve less salty bacon. His process was effectively copied by the Dutch Orthodox Jewish master curer, Aron Vecht, who incorporated this into the Oake’s system, retaining the use of sal prunella and yielding pale meat. His intention was not always to produce bacon as he was responsible for supplying what was called mess pork to the shipping industries. He used the system to create bacon also and established curing operations and bacon brands in New Zealand and Australia. He did not only copy but also made important progressions based on the use of refrigeration.

– The Direct Addition of Nitrite

The work thus far was focussing on an “indirect” formation of nitrite. Ladislav NACHMÜLLNER invented the first curing brine legally sold containing sodium nitrites directly in 1915 in Prague. The system was made popular around the globe by the Griffiths Laboratories. The direct addition of nitrites to curing Brines is covered in two chapters namely:

– Grid Bacon

A system pioneered in Germany in the early 2000s. This final article of interest is not part of Bacon & the Art of Living, but it fits here because it represents the latest thinking about the most modern curing system.

– Bacterial Fermentation of Meat

Where nitrite was previously accessed in England through brine fermentation, it has been discovered in recent years that bacteria are able to ferment the meat itself and create Nitric Oxide from the proteins in the meat to effect curing. I dealt with this probably the most extensively in Chapter 02.00: The Curing Molecule.

Doing this summary made me realise that I need to add the following chapters.

  • A chapter dealing with the quest to “commercialise” a brine system using bacterial fermentation. Together with Richard Bosman in a South African company we appropriately called Oake Woods (Pty) Ltd, we are actively involved in this pursuit.
  • I realise that I also must do a chapter dealing with plant-based curing where nitrate is accessed through bacteria to produce nitrite and thus cure meat. There are major benefits to this system, but Richard and I are not satisfied with it but seek to provide nitrite-free bacon through continued bacterial action. Like the fermentation brine, our work is housed in Oake Woods. We commercialise this through BeetBacon.

From Antiquity Till Now: Health Considerations and History

The final chapters of Bacon & the Art of Living put the health considerations and the future development of bacon in perspective. Even though Richard and I are heavily involved in creating nitrite-free bacon, the fact is that nitrite itself is not something to be frowned upon under all circumstances. In the closing chapters, I deal head-on with this matter and provide the vision and road map to changing bacon into a super-food.

The Story of Bacon

I summarise the development of curing in one chapter in Bacon &the Art of Living:

Generally, what you have in Bacon & the Art of Living is the most complete work on the history of bacon in existence! I have to say something about the plotline. The story takes place in the 2000s with each character referring to a real person and actual events. The theme is a kind of “steampunk” where modern mannerisms, speech, clothes and practices are superimposed on a historical setting. The characters are modern people, most of whom are based on real people and they interact with old historical figures with all the historical and cultural bias that goes with this. As the title indicates, it is far more than only the history of bacon as it relates these events to a personal quest to find purpose in life through the pursuit of bacon. In the process family, friends and concepts such as nationalism and faith are examined in a way relevant to the pursuit of excellence.


The index page to Bacon & the Art of Living: Bacon & the Art of Living


“Canadian Bacon” by Kevin Clees. A master at the art and a true inspiration!


Please make contact!

Any contributions or comments can be directed to me at:

Phone Number and Whatsapp: +27 71 545 3029
Cape Town
South Africa

The complete history of bacon.