Re-evaluation of the Discovery of Nitrate and Nitrite Curing

17 July 2024
Eben van Tonder

Introduction

I have been looking into the origin of meat curing for many years, and over that time I have formed several working hypotheses. The first is that sal ammoniac (ammonium chloride) was used to cure meat before saltpetre (potassium nitrate). The second is that the use of nitrate salts in curing developed in and around the Turpan Depression in the far west of China. The third is that horse sweat was used to treat meat. It was used by horse peoples of Mongolia and Central Asia, and the Boers in South Africa treated their biltong with it for a time when they began their large scale venturing into the interior of Southern Africa.

I once thought that curing was discovered by accident, when seafarers stored meat in seawater. On that view, surface proteins were broken down into amino acids, the amino acids released ammonia, and bacteria oxidised the ammonia to nitrite, which cured the meat. My later work showed that this last step fails in strong salt, because the bacteria that oxidise ammonia are almost completely inhibited by it (Moussa and colleagues 2006). I was also never comfortable with the idea that people would have put bitter potassium nitrate on meat by chance. I have worked for some time on a curing mechanism based on L-arginine, and despite successes, repeating them and forging them into a commercial system remains difficult.

When we speak of saltpetre or sal ammoniac in antiquity, we cannot imagine the pure substances we know today. Salts were mixed with impurities and with other salts, and they were often wrongly classified altogether.

Here I present an alternative account of how curing came about. Much work remains, but the evidence is sufficient to suggest that it may be closer to the truth than what I previously thought.

An Alternative Picture of Ancient History

It seems to me that people in antiquity became highly skilled in managing human and animal excrement, both urine and dung. They understood its properties long before the first written records, and they incorporated it into their stores, their religion and their general cultural practices. They used it, or at least tried to use it, in everything from meat preservation to medicine.

Through careful observation, people saw a link between urine and the salt that came to be known as saltpetre (a nitrate salt), and between dung and sal ammoniac (ammonium chloride). They tried to work out what the link was, but mostly they did not concern themselves with the “why”. They were focused on the “how”. What began as a tentative practice developed into the making of nitrate salts from urine and dung, and of sal ammoniac from dung.

Dung and urine also entered the emerging systems of alchemy. Their presence there was so strong that even when people became better at making saltpetre and sal ammoniac, these two salts never displaced dung and urine from alchemy or from the religious practices that used them.

This picture emerged from the evidence I have considered over the last 20 years in trying to understand the origins of meat curing. I propose that people dug pits in the ground to store their meat, just as they placed meat in bodies of water to protect it from predators. Such pits were dug in clay soil that holds moisture. If urine, dung and possibly salt and water were added before the pit was covered, chemistry, bacteria and the meat’s own enzymes would have both cured the meat and fermented it.

The curing basins at Hallstatt, dated to the 13th and 12th centuries BCE, may stand in this tradition. They would represent the industrial scale application of practices that began on a small, private scale. Our later work on Hallstatt has refined how urine could have contributed. In the salted basins, the ammonia of urine would have remained as ammonium, which salt prevents from being oxidised to nitrite. Urine soaked earth, in which bacteria had already formed nitrate where salt was scarce, is therefore the more probable route (Van Tonder and Van Tonder-Berger 2026).

In the rest of this document, I bring together the matters I have considered over the last 20 years and the events that led me to this view.

Investigating the Use of Chicken or Goose Droppings in the Production of Ferrum Noricum

The study that caused me to re-evaluate my information came to me when Christa Berger from Austria asked me to help her evaluate the use of chicken or goose droppings in the production of Ferrum Noricum, the iron of the Roman province of Noricum. This work brought me close to thoughts I had about the use of excrement and urine in antiquity. There are legends of the use of poultry droppings in iron smelting. The only plausible reasons for using them would have been their carbon and nitrogen content. Charcoal would have been a much better source of carbon, and for nitrogen there would have been other options.

In earlier work on sal ammoniac, I came across references indicating that people were aware that the quality of dung for sal ammoniac depended on what the animals ate. They had no idea about nitrogen, but they knew the properties they were looking for and “calibrated” for them.

Aikin and Aikin (1807) discuss the use of animal dung for the production of sal ammoniac. They list other animal materials that could be used besides dung, namely horns, feathers, wool, soot, bones, blood and putrid urine. They make it clear that almost any part of an animal could serve, but they regard dung as the primary material.

The New York Tribune of 31 January 1874, which I also quote in From Sea to Deserts. Sal Ammoniac Predating Saltpetre, shows how people selected dung for its properties. The dung of four footed animals that feed only on vegetables “is fit to burn for sal ammoniac only during the four first months of the year when they feed on fresh spring grass, which, in Egypt is a kind of trefoil or clover; for when they feed only on dry meat, it will not do. The dung of oxen, buffalo, sheep, goats, horses, and asses, are at the proper time as fit as the dung of camels for this purpose; it is said that even human dung is equal to any other.” In other words, the yield of sal ammoniac from dung depended on the diet of the animals, and dung from animals on fresh green pasture was preferred to dung from animals on dry fodder.

Diet affects the nitrogen content of dung, and drying concentrates it. Whether enriched poultry droppings could have contributed nitrogen to the hardening of iron in ancient smelting remains a hypothesis. It would need to be tested by analysing the droppings and by smelting experiments.

Joseph Needham on “Chicken Dung Alum”

An important clue came from Joseph Needham, the authoritative scholar of Chinese science. He describes a passage by Tao Hongjing (456 to 536 CE), the great Daoist physician and alchemist, in his 本草經集注 (Běncǎo jīng jízhù, Collected Commentaries on the Classic of Materia Medica). There, Tao denotes the rubbing of iron with a mixture of 雞屎礬 (jī shǐ fán, chicken dung alum), vinegar and copper as 鍍 (dù, plating). Needham adds that the 三十六水法 (Sānshíliù shuǐ fǎ, Thirty six Methods for Bringing Solids into Aqueous Solution) describes in detail how to prepare a solution for rubbing on iron to induce this reaction (Needham, Science and Civilisation in China, Volume 5, still to be checked for part and page).

The reaction Tao describes is the deposition of copper on iron from a solution of a copper salt. In China, chalcanthite, which is native copper sulphate, was known from early times to “transform iron into copper” in this way (Lung 1986). The name chicken dung alum appears to describe the appearance of a copper bearing mineral rather than actual droppings, and this must be checked against Needham’s discussion. The passage therefore probably does not show that bird droppings were used on iron.

Christa’s work nevertheless alerted me to the possible link between animal droppings and early smelting, and in particular to the hardening of blades. It made me realise how sophisticated the handling of dung and urine may have been by the Late Bronze and Early Iron Age. Her folklore sources came from many regions and periods, and in my years of looking into history such specific traditions have rarely proved completely without foundation.

Animal and Human Urine and Sweat

I first encountered a link between animal excrement and human culture at the cradle of horse domestication. Librado and colleagues (2021) sequenced 273 ancient horse genomes. They identified the Western Eurasian steppes, especially the lower Volga and Don region, as the homeland of modern domestic horses. From about 2000 BCE these horses expanded rapidly across Eurasia and replaced almost all other local populations. The earlier horses of Botai in Central Asia, about 3500 BCE, with evidence of bridling, milking and corralling, were not the ancestors of modern domestic horses (Librado and colleagues 2021). Within a few centuries, herders of the Volga and Don region had produced a horse population that spread across the continent.

The horses of the Caucasus were famous in antiquity. McCulloch (1854) wrote that “The horses of the Caucasus have been famous from very high antiquity, the Bechtag mountains having been formerly called Hippicon (ἱππικόν) from the number of these animals which were grazed upon its side (Ptolemy, v., 9). They are not less numerous in the present day and are among the very finest varieties of the species.”

I first researched this region because of its possible link with the curing traditions of Turpan. I reasoned that the people who domesticated the horse would have the longest history of “living with horses”, and that technology sets from antiquity might still survive among them. Growing up on the farm, we called horse sweat salpeter, and I was eager to investigate a link between Turpan and horses from a curing perspective.

Researchers collected accounts from people involved with horse husbandry in Mongolia and northern Kazakhstan in the recent past, and these accounts show the value placed on the urine and sweat of horses. It was reported that horse fat, excrement, bone, hair, liver, kidney and stomach are used in the treatment of many ailments, and that back problems were treated by wrapping the sufferer in a fresh horse skin. Horse sweat was said to cure gastric diseases, ulcers, typhoid fever, plague, fever and cancer of the gullet. Levine, who did the research, wrote, “The horse can move rapidly and easily long distances over hard ground, providing its owners with both mobility (riding, packing, traction) and nourishment (milk, meat, fat). Other products, such as bone, hoof, hair, hide, excrement, and even sweat, are also valued, for example, as fuel, raw materials for the fabrication of tools, utensils, musical instruments, and other objects, and for medicinal purposes.” (Levine, reference to be added)

The medicinal use of sweat and urine may have followed from their use on meat. The use of horse sweat, urine and excrement on meat is therefore not far fetched. When the Dutch arrived at the Cape, they recorded a ceremony in which elders of the Khoe urinated over young men, and in India people bathe in cow urine to this day. Such practices give us glimpses of the important place that bodily fluids held in human culture.

Sweat consists mainly of salts, chiefly sodium chloride, with small amounts of lactate, urea and nitrate. Bacteria on the skin reduce the nitrate of human sweat to nitrite (Weller and colleagues 1996), and horse sweat may behave similarly. The amounts are small, so a horse would have to sweat profusely for sweat to contribute to a cure.

Riders of the steppes are said to have hung strips of meat over the necks of their horses or placed them under the saddle. The old Boer frontiersmen in South Africa used the same technique, hanging meat around the necks of their horses when they were out hunting or tracking. Meat under a saddle would also have been softened.

People of antiquity held that living things contained a “vital” principle, so that all fluids from the living were regarded as powerful. They would have noticed that urine could change the colour of meat from dull brown to pink and help it keep. They would also have noticed that sweat had a similar effect, if one could gather enough of it, and that a galloping horse produces copious sweat.

The Value of Excrement

On human faeces, Speth (2017) did such excellent work that I quote him at length. “Prehistoric pits filled with human faeces (coprolites) have been found in a number of dry caves in the Great Basin of the western United States. David Thomas (1985: 380–381) discusses these so-called ‘latrines’ at length, noting that in at least some cases such deliberate faecal accumulations occur together with caches of equipment that had clearly been stored in the caves in anticipation of future use. To Thomas, the placement of the latrines side-by-side with other cached items suggests that the faeces had also been stored there, presumably as food reserves for future use. . .” (Speth 2017)

“Arctic groups provide additional insights into forager attitudes toward excrement, and show no evidence, at least in these contexts, that faeces necessarily elicited feelings of disgust, whether through direct contact or by indirect contamination of other items or foods.” (Speth 2017)

“The use of ptarmigan droppings appears to be limited to a few groups of Eskimos. According to Mathiassen…, ‘Ptarmigan excrement is chewed together with walrus meat into a porridgy mass which is stirred up in blubber.’” (Speth 2017)

“Similarly, the Netsilik Eskimos are said by Birket-Smith…to have used ‘ptarmigan excrement mixed with blubber and chewed meat’.” (Eidlitz 1969: 88, quoted by Speth 2017)

The Hadza of Tanzania provide another example of people handling faeces freely. “Baobab seed is also a good protein source with adequate levels of five out of eight essential amino acids…. The Hadza chew young seeds; but when mature, the seeds are cracked individually with a stone or pounded into a coarse flour…. Baboons, which have teeth well shaped for seed cracking…can not break the mature seeds and pass them unbroken. Hadza women collect baobab seeds from baboon dung piles, wash them, and prepare them in the normal manner….” (Schoeninger and colleagues 2001: 182, quoted by Speth 2017)

Throughout much of Southwest and South Asia, the manure of cattle, sheep and other livestock is gathered, kneaded into dung cakes, dried and stored in and around the house. There it serves as fuel for cooking and warmth, as a component of household architecture and at times as medicine. Speth (2017) quotes Freed and Freed (1978: 80 to 81) from northern India. “Only the dung of the zebu cow was used to plaster the stove and the kitchen area…. For fuel, dung was moulded into relatively flat round cakes which were dried in the sun. Each family had a special place where dung cakes were made and stored…. The women of a family…daily carried dung dropped by the family cattle to this place. Families who owned no cattle collected dung from the village lanes and the grazing area. Traditionally, such dung was available to everyone and it was collected by most families. One important duty of a young daughter was to go early every morning through the village lanes to mark dung that fell from cattle when they were driven to the pond or to the grazing area and later to collect it…One morning we watched a woman from an 11-person family making dung cakes…. She mixed the dung with small pieces of mustard stalks, kneaded it, and formed it into cakes of two sizes which she spread on the ground to dry. In the course of the morning, she made about 24 large cakes and 103 small ones.”

From Iran, Speth (2017) quotes Ardakani and Emadi (2004: 13). “In Iran, manure is an especially valued and carefully treated commodity. Rural and urban communities use it to fertilize the soil, produce energy (burning), eradicate pests and plant diseases, and make bricks and plaster walls. In some cases, it is also used to treat human illness…. For example, the dung of newly born foals mixed with the milk of lactating donkeys is used in some villages to treat whooping cough…. Iranian villagers…utilize animal manure and bird droppings as a source of energy. In some rural areas animal manure is still used to generate heat and women believe that the best fire for baking bread is one made from animal droppings because it produces more uniformly baked and thoroughly toasted bread.”

From China, Speth (2017) quotes Fortune (1847: 314 to 315) on night soil. “For crops in a vigorous growing state no kind of manure is so eagerly sought after as night soil; and every traveller in China has remarked the large cisterns or earthen tubs which are placed in the most conspicuous and convenient situation for the reception of this kind of manure. What would be considered an intolerable nuisance in every civilised town in Europe, is here looked upon by all classes, rich and poor, with the utmost complacency; and I am convinced that nothing would astonish a Chinaman more, than hearing anyone complain of the stench which is continually rising from these manure tanks…. In England, it is generally supposed that the Chinese carry the night soil and urine to these tanks, and leave it there to undergo fermentation before they apply it to the land. This, however, is not the case; at least, not generally. In the fertile agricultural districts in the north, I have observed that the greater part of this stimulant is used in a fresh state, being of course sufficiently diluted with water before it is applied to the crops.”

Speth (2017) adds, “Another favourite in the list of supposed ‘core’ universal disgust elicitors—urine—is also effectively demolished by the cross-cultural ethnographic record and, as in the case of putrid meat, the damning evidence again comes from the Inuit. Urine was their principal ‘soap’!” He quotes Curtis (1930: 43). “Urine…is collected from the containers in the men’s house only (since that of women is believed to be unclean), to be stored in tubs for at least two days before using. Women…first bathe in urine, followed by a rinsing in either salt or fresh water. Both sexes frequently wash hands and faces in urine, and rinse with water; for urine, coming into contact with the body oils, acts as soap in removing grease and other impurities. The men, when about to take a sweat-bath…gather in the men’s house. There the floorboards are removed and a roaring fire built in the pit…. The participants, soon drenched with perspiration, bathe themselves with urine from the central pot….”

The Chemical Basis for Using Urine and Dung on Meat

From urea to ammonia

Urine carries excess water, salts and the products of metabolism out of the body. Its main nitrogen compound is urea, which the liver forms to dispose of excess nitrogen. Once urine is excreted, bacteria with urease hydrolyse the urea to ammonia and carbon dioxide.

CO(NH₂)₂ + H₂O → 2 NH₃ + CO₂

In stored urine, the urea is used up within a few days, and the pH rises to about 9 (Udert and colleagues 2003). This gives stale urine its smell, and the free ammonia at this pH inactivates many microorganisms.

From ammonia to nitrate

Two groups of nitrifying bacteria oxidise ammonia, first to nitrite and then to nitrate. This process is called nitrification, and it requires oxygen and little salt. Moussa and colleagues (2006) found that 40 g of chloride per litre reduced the activity of both groups by about 95 percent. On salted meat or in brine, nitrification is therefore almost completely blocked. Where salt is scarce and air is present, as in soil, on a stable floor or in a heap of dung, nitrifying bacteria convert the nitrogen of urine into nitrate over months to years.

From nitrate to the cured colour

In the meat, salt tolerant staphylococci reduce nitrate to nitrite when little oxygen is present (Ras and colleagues 2017). Nitrite forms nitric oxide in the meat by chemical reactions, and nitric oxide binds to myoglobin to form nitrosomyoglobin, the red pigment of raw cured meat (Honikel 2008). Urine could therefore have cured meat most effectively after its nitrogen had been converted to nitrate in earth.

Ammonia in meat

In meat itself, ammonia behaves differently from ammonia in stored urine. Meat is slightly acid, and at its pH almost all ammonia is present as the ammonium ion. At pH 6 and 8 °C, less than 0.1 percent of the total ammonia is free ammonia (Emerson and colleagues 1975). Ammonium does not evaporate, and it is not antimicrobial in the way that free ammonia is.

Alchemy

Urine was also valued in alchemy and traditional medicine for its chemical properties, including its ammonia. In Chinese alchemy, urine was used together with other materials for its transforming properties. In European alchemy, human and animal excrement, urine included, were considered potent ingredients because they reacted and transformed readily.

The Discovery of Sal Ammoniac and Saltpetre

I propose that people in early antiquity had few means of refining salts, which were full of contaminants and mixed with other salts. It is more likely that people first used bodily excrement in domestic settings, such as the curing of meat and washing. They may then have recognised in saltpetre effects similar to those of urine and begun to use it. Their experience with urine would have shown them what to expect of saltpetre and so guided its early refinement.

I therefore now turn to saltpetre and sal ammoniac. Dung became the main source of sal ammoniac, whereas nitrate salts formed mainly from urine and dung in earth. Both substances also occur naturally. I propose that people sought them in order to obtain, from other materials, the same effects they knew from urine.

Sal Ammoniac

I propose that ammonium salts were used for curing before saltpetre became widely available for medical and military uses. German and Austrian cookbooks from before 1600 speak of curing with salt alone and use vegetable dyes to bolster colour. I will argue that Germans and Austrians would also have known sal ammoniac as a curing salt, but that it fell out of common use, probably because of its effect on taste.

I have found references to sal ammoniac in Chinese, Persian and Arabic sources of the first millennium CE, and it was widely traded along the Silk Road. Egypt produced it from the soot of burned dung, and it was mined in Central Asia. When I cured meat with sal ammoniac, the meat developed a stable reddish pink colour that did not turn brown, and in my trial it kept better than meat cured with sodium nitrite. Whether ammonium itself formed nitrite on the meat, or whether nitrate or nitrite present as impurities produced the colour, remains to be tested. A cure with ammonium chloride labelled with nitrogen 15 would decide the question.

Natural Sal Ammoniac

Sal ammoniac occurs naturally and is also made by people. Turpan is an oasis in the far west of China, in the Turpan Depression, whose lowest point lies about 154 m below sea level, the lowest in China. The region is extremely dry. I propose that Turpan may be one of the few places on earth where sal ammoniac and sodium nitrate occur side by side in quantity, sal ammoniac in the surrounding mountains and nitrate salts on the floor of the basin.

Chinese sources record that sal ammoniac, 硇砂 (náoshā, sal ammoniac), came into China from Turpan, Kucha, Tibet and Samarkand, and through Samarkand it was traded along the Silk Road towards the Mediterranean (Laufer 1919). This makes an appealing case for sal ammoniac as an early curing salt. I also see a possible link between Turpan and Salzburg, with its salt mines, which leads me to speculate that sal ammoniac was traded into the heart of Western Europe, into what became Austria.

It was in exploring this link that I met Christa Berger, who now collaborates widely with me on EarthwormExpress. Her knowledge of the meat industry comes first hand, from her family’s own farm. She has explored the link between Turpan and Austria in great detail, and I will set this out in a separate article.

Around Turpan and Kucha, sal ammoniac forms where hot gases escape from the ground, at vents that early writers described as volcanic. The crystals form directly from the vapour without passing through a liquid phase, a process known as sublimation. Sal ammoniac is highly soluble, and rain dissolves the crystals.

The sal ammoniac was gathered at openings in the mountainsides and traded across Asia, into India and towards Europe. I speculate that traders may have used nitrate salts from the basin floor to extend or substitute for sal ammoniac. Sal ammoniac attracts water and loses its crystal form on long journeys, and once that happened, the two salts would have looked alike. Mining sal ammoniac was seasonal, dangerous and difficult, and supply was limited. The Chinese writer Yao Yuan-Chin, quoted by Needham (1959), states that not much sal ammoniac could be obtained at Kucha and Turpan. Limited supply would have provided an incentive for such substitution.

I suspect that observing these natural deposits, and the deposits left where people burned dung as fuel, led people to recognise a common principle and to work out how to make sal ammoniac from dung.

Sal ammoniac consists of two ions, ammonium and chloride. On meat, ammonium could be oxidised to nitrite only where salt was low and air was present. On a salted cure, its colour may therefore have come from accompanying nitrate or nitrite, or from routes that remain to be tested.

Sal ammoniac was also mined from the earth. Ancient Chinese names for it include “red gravel” and “essence of the white sea”. There were mines in Sogdiana. Muslim traders carried it through Khorasan towards China, and Kucha still yielded sal ammoniac at the beginning of the 1900s. Old sources mention white and red varieties. Laufer (1919) quotes a classical description of the mines near Samarkand. “The mines of sal ammoniac are in the mountains, where there is a certain cavern, from which a vapour issues, appearing by day like smoke, and by night like fire. Over the spot whence the vapour issues, they have erected a house the doors and windows of which are plastered over by clay that none of the vapour can escape. On the upper part of this house the copperas rest. When the doors are to be opened, a swiftly-running man is chosen, who, having his body covered over with clay, opens the door; takes as much as he can from the copperas, and runs off; if he should delay he should be burnt. This vapour comes forth in different places, from time to time; when it ceases to issue from one place, they dig in another until it appears, and then they erect that kind of house over it; if they did not erect this house, the vapour would burn, or evaporate away.” According to Laufer (1919), the Tibetans received this salt from India, as an old Tibetan name for it, “Indian salt”, shows, and it was also gathered at volcanic springs in Tibet and Sichuan. Similar vapours rise from the smoking mountains of Turpan.

Ammonium Chloride Made by People

Like saltpetre, sal ammoniac occurs naturally and is also made by people. From what they saw in nature, and what they observed in confined spaces and around kilns where dung was used as fuel, people learned to make it themselves. The name ammonia derives from the Egyptian god Amun, whose Greek form is Ammon. The Romans called the salt found near the temple of Ammon at the Siwa Oasis in the western desert of Egypt sal ammoniacum, “salt of Ammon” (Myers 2007). In the Middle Ages, ammonia was made by distilling animal dung, hooves and horns (Myers 2007).

The New York Tribune of 31 January 1874 wrote, “For centuries sal ammoniac was imported from Egypt where it is sublimed from camels’ dung.” On Friday, 18 August 1786, the Pennsylvania Packet described the making of sal ammoniac in Egypt as follows. “Sal Ammoniac is made from soot arising from the burnet dung of four-footed animals that feed only on vegetables. But the dung of these animals is fit to burn for sal ammoniac only during the four first months of the year when they feed on fresh spring grass, which, in Egypt is a kind of trefoil or clover; for when they feed only on dry meat, it will not do. The dung of oxen, buffalo, sheep, goats, horses, and asses, are at the proper time as fit as the dung of camels for this purpose; it is said that even human dung is equal to any other.”

The soot from the burned dung was put into glass vessels, and these were placed in an oven or kiln that was heated by degrees and finally fired strongly for three successive nights and days. Smoke appeared first, and shortly after, the salt appeared, sticking to the glass and gradually covering the whole opening. The glasses were then broken, and the salt was taken out in the state and form in which it was sent to Europe. At that time, Egypt was one of the major suppliers of sal ammoniac to Europe.

Saltpetre

From urine and dung, people progressed to saltpetre as a source of the curing power of nitrogen. In this section I want to show the mystery that surrounded saltpetre, and how recent the discoveries about saltpetre and sal ammoniac are.

People in many parts of the world knew salts that turned meat reddish pink and helped it keep. According to Binkerd and Kolari (1975), the reddening effect of saltpetre was known in late Roman times, and they conclude that preservation, rather than colour, drove its early use.

People could not tell whether saltpetre occurred naturally or had to be nourished or cultivated. They wondered how to remove its impurities, and nobody could explain its power. Saltpetre had many uses. It was used to cure meat, as the essential ingredient of gunpowder, as fertiliser and medicine, for cooling beverages and in glass making.

The Chinese and the Italians used saltpetre to make gunpowder. There is a record of gunpowder in India as early as 1300 CE, probably introduced by the Mongols.

From the 1500s, saltpetre was used in Asia and Europe to cool beverages and to ice foods. When saltpetre dissolves in water, the process absorbs heat from the water, and the temperature of the water falls.

These elevated views of saltpetre in the Middle Ages and the early modern period show, in my mind, reverence not so much for saltpetre itself as for what it achieved. I list some of these statements, drawn from Cressy (2013), in which the same nature found in urine is celebrated.

The Elizabethan writer Peter Whitehorne wrote in the 1500s of saltpetre, “I cannot tell how to be resolved, to say what thing properly it is except it seemeth it hath the sovereignty and quality of every element.” Cressy (2013) describes how followers of Paracelsus (1493 to 1541), the founder of toxicology, regarded saltpetre as a mythical as well as chemical substance with occult as well as material connections. They saw in it “a vital generative principle”, “a notable mystery the which, albeit it be taken from the earth, yet it may lift up our eyes to heaven”.

From the 1400s to the late 1800s, writers probed the properties of this compound. Saltpetre was said to encompass the “miraculum mundi”, the “material universalis”, through which “our very lives and spirits were preserved”. Its threefold nature evoked “that incomprehensible mystery of … the divine trinity”, in the words of Thomas Tymme’s translation (1605) of the Paracelsian Joseph Duchesne.

Francis Bacon, Lord Chancellor and Privy Councillor under James I, described saltpetre as the energising “spirit of the earth”. Robert Boyle, who experimented on saltpetre, found it “the most catholic of salts, a most puzzling concrete, vegetable, animal, and even mineral, both acid and alkaline, and partly fixed and partly volatile. The knowledge of it may be very conducive to the discovery of several other bodies and to the improvement of diverse parts of natural philosophy.”

In India, saltpetre was obtained from the earth, and thousands of small villages were engaged in its production. It grew like fungus on the walls of cellars and around latrines, and it seemed to occur wherever urine and dung accumulated, as in bat caves.

In Germany, the making of saltpetre became a regulated craft. In the villages of Württemberg, the ducal ordinances of 1554 to 1747 gave licensed saltpetre boilers the right to dig in barns, stables and threshing floors, and the manufacture was a right of the sovereign (Schahl 1969). The peasants knew that their stable earth was valuable, that it needed air and dryness and that it fed their fields. The ordinances complain that they covered their floors to stop the saltpetre growing and carted the earth of old walls to their fields (Schahl 1969).

Lazarus Ercker (1530 to 1594), chief master of the mines under Emperor Rudolf II in Bohemia, gave one of the most detailed accounts of the making of saltpetre in his Beschreibung allerfürnemisten mineralischen Ertzt unnd Berckwercksarten, first published in Prague in 1574 and again in Frankfurt in 1580. An English translation by John Pettus appeared in 1683.

Despite the Renaissance and great advances in the natural sciences, people could still appreciate saltpetre only by what it did, without understanding how it worked.

In the late 1770s, a teacher of chemistry wrote, “We are much in the dark as to the origin and generation” of saltpetre, though he knew it to be “found among earth and stone that have been impregnated by animal and vegetable juices susceptible of purification and have long been exposed to air. . . . It is the product of the elements deposited in the bosom of the earth, and may not be improperly called the universal and unspecific mercury” (quoted by Cressy 2013).

Vannoccio Biringuccio published De la pirotechnia in Venice in 1540. Its account of saltpetre reached English readers through Whitehorne, who relayed Biringuccio’s methods.

In warm countries with seasonal rains, ammonia from the decay of nitrogenous materials is washed into the soil and oxidised by bacteria to nitrate. In India, saltpetre was leached from the ground as the sheets of water left by monsoon flooding evaporated. A crust of saltpetre and other mineral salts spread across the ground and could be dug up and refined into potassium nitrate.

Saltpetre was also made by people. In England, saltpetremen harvested saltpetre earth and extracted it from nitre enriched soil. They scoured the countryside and dug wherever the ground could have been impregnated with the urine and dung of animals and people.

Whitehorne said that saltpetre “is a mixture of many substances, gotten out of fire and water of dry and dirty ground.” It could sometimes be found as an efflorescence or “flower that grows out of new walls, in cellars, or of that ground that is found loose within tombs or desolate caves where rain can not come in.” Saltpetre could also be nourished, or encouraged to grow, by adding “the dung of beasts” to the earth. A distinction was made between natural saltpetre, which only needed to be scraped from walls, and artificial saltpetre, which required digging and refinement. According to Whitehorne, relaying Biringuccio, the two kinds “partook of the very same virtue”.

From the 17th century, the English East India Company imported large quantities of saltpetre from India, where it occurred naturally and was efficiently produced. Saltpetre was also an important commodity of the Dutch East India Company, which established the trading post at the southern tip of Africa that later became Cape Town.

The breakthrough in understanding its composition came from Antoine Lavoisier, who showed in 1776 and 1777 that nitric acid contains oxygen. Saltpetre followed in the footsteps of the way urine and excrement had been viewed for probably many thousands of years.

The Priority of Urea

The chemistry of urine held a special place in the rise of organic chemistry. Carl Wilhelm Scheele described uric acid in 1776 from urinary stones, and urine was studied intensively as a source of new substances.

In 1828 Friedrich Wöhler converted ammonium cyanate into urea, an organic compound found in urine (Wöhler 1828). Wöhler’s synthesis of urea is often cited as the turning point in the overthrow of vitalism, the theory that organic compounds could only be produced by living organisms. Uric acid itself was first synthesised in 1882 by Johann Horbaczewski, who heated glycine with urea (Horbaczewski 1882).

Throughout antiquity and into the early 19th century, urine was regarded as a valuable diagnostic and therapeutic substance. That one of its components became a landmark of synthetic chemistry reflects the attention that urine received. It supports my thesis that urine held a central place in practical knowledge for a very long time.

Conclusion

My research into the origins of meat curing suggests that ancient peoples were highly adept at using human and animal excrement, urine and dung, in applications ranging from meat preservation to medicine. They integrated these substances into their cultural, religious and practical daily lives.

Through observation and experiment, people found the relationship between urine and saltpetre, a nitrate salt, and between dung and sal ammoniac, ammonium chloride. They did not understand the chemistry, but they learned to make nitrate salts and sal ammoniac from excrement. These practices entered alchemy, where dung and urine remained important even after more refined salts became available.

The chemistry now clarifies how urine could have contributed to curing. Its ammonia does not become nitrite on salted meat, but in earth with little salt, bacteria convert the nitrogen of urine and dung into nitrate. Salt tolerant staphylococci then reduce that nitrate to nitrite in the meat. Urine soaked earth and the salts made from it are therefore the most probable route from excrement to the cured colour.

This brings me back to the curing basins at Hallstatt, dated to the 13th and 12th centuries BCE. Christa Berger alerted me to them, and so began one of the most productive scientific collaborations of my life. The basins may represent the industrial scale application of practices that began on a small and private scale. As I continue to piece together the historical and scientific evidence, I am convinced that the management of urine and dung played a central part in the development of meat curing.

Supporting Evidence and Further Work

A Newspaper’s Record and Old Chemistry Textbooks References on Use of Urine and Dung in Antiquity

The Hallstatt Curing Method

The Nitrate Source of the Hallstatt Cure

The Role of Animal Droppings and Pattern Welding in Ancient Sword Making. A Blend of Art and Science

The Role of Urine as a Filtration System for Amanita Muscaria and Other Uses Across Eurasia

References

Aikin, A. and Aikin, C. R. (1807). A Dictionary of Chemistry and Mineralogy, with an Account of the Processes Employed in Many of the Most Important Chemical Manufactures. London. John and Arthur Arch, and William Phillips.

Binkerd, E. F. and Kolari, O. E. (1975). The history and use of nitrate and nitrite in the curing of meat. Food and Cosmetics Toxicology, 13, 655 to 661.

Cressy, D. (2013). Saltpeter. The Mother of Gunpowder. Oxford. Oxford University Press.

Emerson, K., Russo, R. C., Lund, R. E. and Thurston, R. V. (1975). Aqueous ammonia equilibrium calculations. Effect of pH and temperature. Journal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada, 32, 2379 to 2383. https://doi.org/10.1139/f75-274

Ercker, L. (1574). Beschreibung allerfürnemisten mineralischen Ertzt unnd Berckwercksarten. Prag. Second edition, Frankfurt 1580.

Honikel, K. O. (2008). The use and control of nitrate and nitrite for the processing of meat products. Meat Science, 78, 68 to 76.

Horbaczewski, J. (1882). Synthese der Harnsäure. Monatshefte für Chemie, 3 (still to be checked for pages).

Laufer, B. (1919). Sino-Iranica. Chinese Contributions to the History of Civilization in Ancient Iran. Field Museum of Natural History, Anthropological Series, 15(3). Chicago.

Librado, P., Khan, N., Fages, A. and colleagues (2021). The origins and spread of domestic horses from the Western Eurasian steppes. Nature, 598, 634 to 640. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-04018-9

Lung, T. N. (1986). The history of copper cementation on iron. The world’s first hydrometallurgical process from medieval China. Hydrometallurgy, 17, 113 to 129.

McCulloch, J. R. (1854). A Dictionary, Geographical, Statistical, and Historical, of the Various Countries, Places, and Principal Natural Objects in the World. London. Longman.

Moussa, M. S., Sumanasekera, D. U., Ibrahim, S. H., Lubberding, H. J., Hooijmans, C. M., Gijzen, H. J. and van Loosdrecht, M. C. M. (2006). Long term effects of salt on activity, population structure and floc characteristics in enriched bacterial cultures of nitrifiers. Water Research, 40, 1377 to 1388. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2006.01.029

Myers, R. L. (2007). The 100 Most Important Chemical Compounds. A Reference Guide. Westport. Greenwood Press.

Needham, J. Science and Civilisation in China, Volume 5, Chemistry and Chemical Technology. Cambridge. Cambridge University Press (part and page still to be checked).

Needham, J. (1959). Science and Civilisation in China, Volume 3, Mathematics and the Sciences of the Heavens and the Earth. Cambridge. Cambridge University Press.

Ras, G., Zuliani, V., Derkx, P., Seibert, T. M., Leroy, S. and Talon, R. (2017). Evidence for nitric oxide synthase activity in Staphylococcus xylosus mediating nitrosoheme formation. Frontiers in Microbiology, 8, 598. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2017.00598

Schahl, A. (1969). Der Salpetersieder im altwürttembergischen Dorf. Württembergisches Jahrbuch für Volkskunde.

Speth, J. D. (2017). Putrid meat and fish in the Eurasian Middle and Upper Paleolithic. Are we missing a key part of Neanderthal and modern human diet? PaleoAnthropology, 2017, 44 to 72.

Udert, K. M., Larsen, T. A., Biebow, M. and Gujer, W. (2003). Urea hydrolysis and precipitation dynamics in a urine collecting system. Water Research, 37, 2571 to 2582. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0043-1354(03)00065-4

Van Tonder, E. and Van Tonder-Berger, C. (2026). The Nitrate Source of the Hallstatt Cure. Discussion Paper. EarthwormExpress. https://earthwormexpress.com/salt-salz-sul-%e7%9b%90-yan-sol-%ce%b1%ce%bb%ce%b1%cf%83-usawoti-%d9%85%d9%84%d8%ad-letsoai-sel-sal-%d9%86%d9%85%da%a9-muoi-%e9%b9%bd-sout-%e5%a1%a9-shio-%ec%86%8c/the-origin-of-salted-pork-traditions-hallstatt-the-bronze-age-pork-industry-and-the-formation-of-the-european-curing-tradition/the-nitrate-source-of-the-hallstatt-cure-2/

Weller, R., Pattullo, S., Smith, L., Golden, M., Ormerod, A. and Benjamin, N. (1996). Nitric oxide is generated on the skin surface by reduction of sweat nitrate. Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 107, 327 to 331.

Wöhler, F. (1828). Ueber künstliche Bildung des Harnstoffs. Annalen der Physik und Chemie, 88, 253 to 256.