
Saltpeter: A Concise History and the Discovery of Dr. Ed Polenske
By Eben van Tonder
October 2016
Cape Town
Most Recent Research on Dr Polenske’s Paper: Eduard Polenske and the Scientific Discovery of Nitrite Formation in Meat Curing, 1891
In German: Eduard Polenske und die wissenschaftliche Entdeckung der Nitritbildung beim Pökeln von Fleisch, 1891

Overview
Saltpetre, which is potassium nitrate, was used to cure meat for centuries. Nitrate itself does not cure meat. Salt tolerant staphylococci in the meat and brine reduce nitrate to nitrite when little oxygen is present (Ras and colleagues 2017). Nitrite then forms nitric oxide by chemical reactions in the meat, and nitric oxide binds to myoglobin to give the cured colour (Honikel 2008). Modern curing uses nitrite directly, and this shortened the curing cycle considerably. I wanted to know how the composition of saltpetre was discovered, and who first reported the change of nitrate to nitrite in curing brines. This is the story.
Background
In 1876 Edward Smith described bacon as pork “preserved by salt and saltpeter” (Smith 1876, 64). Curing gives bacon its pinkish red colour and its flavour, and it lets the meat keep for a long time before it tastes “off”. Saltpetre was the curing agent.
Between the late 1800s and the middle of the 1900s, a typical mix for dry cured bacon was 10 pounds of salt, 3 pounds of brown sugar, 6 ounces of black pepper and 3 ounces of saltpetre. Curers used 10 pounds of this mixture per 100 pounds of meat (Notes 1 and 2).
Dr. Eduard Reinhold Polenske (3)
Below are the cover of the original journal, the title page and the first page of the actual article.



Dr. Eduard Polenske (1849 to 1911) was a chemist at the Imperial Health Office (Kaiserliches Gesundheitsamt) in Berlin. In 1891 he held the post of technical assistant (Technischer Hülfsarbeiter) in its chemical laboratory. He was born on 27 August 1849 in Ratzebuhr, in the district of Neustettin in Pomerania, to Samuel G. Polenski and Rosina Schultz. He married a woman named Möller, and he died in Berlin in 1911 (Ancestry, Polenske). The spelling of the surname varies (Note 3).
The Imperial Health Office was founded in Berlin in 1876. At first it was a division of the Reich Chancellery, and from 1879 it fell under the Reich Office of the Interior. In 1879 the Food Law (Nahrungsmittelgesetz) was passed, and the office was given the task of supporting its enforcement. In 1900 the Reich Health Council (Reichsgesundheitsrat) was established to assist the office (Hüntelmann 2008).
Polenske examined food preservatives extensively in the 1880s and 1890s, and one of his subjects was the preservatives used in meat and whether they were safe. In 1890 the Wichita Daily Eagle of Wichita, Kansas reported on a meeting of chemists at Speyer in Bavaria on 10 September 1888, where meat preservatives were discussed. The meeting concluded that boric acid as a food preservative was to be “regarded with caution” (The Wichita Daily Eagle 1890).
The report notes that Dr. E. Polenske examined 10 “commercial preservatives intended for meat.” “Three of the 10 contained sulphurous acid or sulphites; two contained borax, and five boric acid; one each contained alum, arsenious oxide, salycylicacid and free phosphoric acid; two contained glycerine, and two boroglycerine; three contained niter, and six common salt” (The Wichita Daily Eagle 1890). The niter was saltpetre.
The 1891 paper
In 1891 Polenske published “Ueber den Verlust, welchen das Rindfleisch an Nährwerth durch das Pökeln erleidet, sowie über die Veränderungen salpeterhaltiger Pökellaken” (On the loss of nutritional value which beef suffers through curing, and on the changes in curing brines containing saltpetre). It appeared in Arbeiten aus dem Kaiserlichen Gesundheitsamte, Volume 7, pages 471 to 474 (Note 4).
His aim was to establish how the brine affected the nutritional value of beef over storage periods of different length. He filled three vessels, each with a piece of beef and a brine of 6 kg water, 1.5 kg common salt, 15 g potassium nitrate and 120 g sugar. The vessels held 965 g, 1 035 g and 1 050 g of raw beef. He opened them after 3 weeks, 3 months and 6 months. The only reliable measures of nutritional value open to him were the nitrogen substance (Stickstoffsubstanz) and the phosphoric acid (Phosphorsäure) (Polenske 1891).
He recorded what the vessels looked like. The first brine was still light red, almost clear and easy to filter, whereas the second and third brines were yellower, cloudy and harder to filter. As the meat aged, its colour became steadily paler. By smell, he judged that even the meat in the last vessel had not putrefied. The meat gained between about 8 and 13 percent in weight. The muscle meat of the three samples contained between 11 and 12 percent sodium chloride, and this level was almost reached after only 3 weeks (Polenske 1891).
Polenske then calculated how much the brine had drawn out of the meat. The meat lost about 8, 10 and 14 percent of its nitrogen substance and between about 35 and 54 percent of its phosphoric acid. He wrote that these findings confirmed the known fact that cured meat is inferior (Minderwerthigkeit des Pökelfleisches) (Polenske 1891).
Nitrite and ammonia in the brine
Polenske also wanted to measure the potassium that the brine had leached from the meat. To do this, he needed to know how much potassium nitrate remained in the brine, which meant measuring its nitric acid. The attempt failed, because in control trials repeated at intervals of several days, the volume of nitric oxide gas obtained from the brine kept falling. He concluded that the nitric acid was progressively decomposing, and he confirmed this by detecting nitrous acid and ammonia in the brine (Polenske 1891).
Polenske’s speculation
He then wrote the sentence for which the paper is known. In the original German of 1891 it reads:
“Die wohl durch Mikroorganismen herbeigeführte Reduktion der Salpetersäure zu salpetriger Säure und Ammoniak gab Veranlassung, zu erforschen, bis zu welchem Grade Letztere sich in den Pökellaken anzuhäufen vermögen. Zumal die gleichen Zersetzungsprodukte auch in dem Pökelfleische gefunden wurden, durfte dieser Gegenstand, die scharfe Verurtheilung des, diese Substanzen enthaltenden Trinkwassers ins Auge fassend, vom hygienischen Standpunkte aus betrachtet, beachtenswerth erscheinen” (Polenske 1891, 473).
In English: “The reduction of nitric acid to nitrous acid and ammonia, probably brought about by microorganisms, gave occasion to investigate to what degree the latter can accumulate in curing brines. Since the same decomposition products were also found in the cured meat, and bearing in mind the sharp condemnation of drinking water containing these substances, this subject seemed worthy of attention from the hygienic standpoint” (Polenske 1891, 473, translated by Eben van Tonder).
This is everything the paper says about the cause. Polenske attributes the reduction to microorganisms in a single subordinate clause, and he qualifies it with “wohl”, meaning probably. He therefore put his speculation in writing, in the paper itself. It rested on the microbiology of his day, and it was correct. Bacteria in the brine and meat reduce the nitrate of saltpetre to nitrite, and the organisms responsible in cured meat are mainly salt tolerant staphylococci (Ras and colleagues 2017). Polenske studied the products as a question of hygiene, because nitrite and ammonia in drinking water were at that time regarded as signs of contamination.
Further analyses
Polenske found that the ammonia and nitrous acid in the brines rose with age, but that their sum stayed far below the theoretical figures. He explained this by the fact that freshly made brines, which were neutral, gradually became alkaline because of free ammonia, which slowly escaped (Polenske 1891).
He extended the analysis to brines from Berlin butcher shops. These were a brine that had been in contact with its first charge of meat for 3 days, brines with a second and a last charge of meat, and a brine that had lain on a ham for 5 months, together with the muscle and fat of that ham. He also analysed American corned beef of the Lion Brand from Chicago, which still contained 0.26 g of saltpetre per 100 g. All of these samples contained nitrous acid and, in most cases, ammonia (Polenske 1891).
His methods were current for his time. He determined nitrogen by the method of Kjeldahl and nitric acid by the method of Schulze and Tiemann. Before the nitrogen determination, he destroyed the nitric acid with ferrous sulphate and hydrochloric acid following Warrington. He measured nitrous acid colorimetrically with metaphenylenediamine, after finding that zinc iodide starch gave misleading violet tones. He determined ammonia by distillation with sodium carbonate and found that the distillate contained only ammonia and no amines. A cold method after Schlösing gave the same figures (Polenske 1891) (Note 5).
The first statement of its kind in meat science
Before 1891 saltpetre was regarded as the curing agent. Butchers and writers assumed that the nitrate they added was the substance acting on the meat. Polenske’s analysis showed that this was not the case. In the brine and in the meat, the saltpetre did not stay nitrate. It was transformed into another nitrogen species, nitrous acid, together with ammonia, and Polenske attributed the change to microorganisms. When Lehmann and Kisskalt showed in 1899 that nitrite produces the red colour of cured meat (Lehmann 1899, Kisskalt 1899), his finding gained its full weight. Nitrate was not the curing agent. It was the raw material from which bacteria made the curing agent. This reversed the understanding of curing as it had stood for centuries, and it opened the way to curing with nitrite directly.
Polenske’s 1891 paper is the earliest published work in the meat literature to report nitrite in curing brine and cured meat made with nitrate alone, and the earliest to attribute its formation to microorganisms. Microbiologists had attributed the reduction of nitrate to bacteria in soil and water from the 1870s (Payne 1986). However, the earlier literature of meat curing has no statement applying this to curing brines. Later authors in meat science name Polenske as the source of this finding. The American Meat Science Association’s fact sheet on alternative curing notes that it is not clear from published literature when meat processors discovered that in fact nitrite, and not nitrate was responsible for successful meat curing. It then credits Polenske, writing that experiments in the late 1800s demonstrated that nitrate in the cure was converted to nitrite by nitrate-reducing bacteria, since nitrite was found in cured meat and in the curing pickle when only nitrate was initially added to the cure solution (Polenske, 1891). The same fact sheet places the next step after him, stating that in a separate experiment, Lehman (1899) and Kisskalt (1899) both concluded that the typical color of cured meats was attributed to nitrite and not nitrate. The reviews of curing history by Binkerd and Kolari (1975), Pegg and Shahidi (2000) and Honikel (2008) also begin the scientific account of nitrite in curing with Polenske (still to be checked for exact wording and page). meatscience
Polenske and the microbiology of his time
Polenske’s speculation followed from research that was well established by 1891. In 1877 Jean Jacques Théophile Schloesing (1824 to 1919) and Charles Achille Müntz (1846 to 1917) showed that nitrification, the formation of nitrate in soil and sewage, is the work of living organisms. In the early 1880s Ulysse Gayon and Gabriel Dupetit introduced the term denitrification, and in 1886 they isolated two strains of denitrifying bacteria in pure culture. Their interest, like that in nitrification, was agricultural (Payne 1986).
W. J. Payne of the Department of Microbiology, University of Georgia, traced this history in his review, Centenary of the Isolation of Denitrifying Bacteria (Payne 1986). Polenske cites Schlösing and Warrington for his analytical methods, and both men had worked on nitrification in soil. He knew this field, and he was the first to apply it to the curing brine.
From Polenske to nitrite curing
After Lehmann and Kisskalt, John Scott Haldane identified the pigment of cured meat in 1901 as a compound of nitric oxide and haemoglobin (Haldane 1901). In the decades that followed, industry learned to add nitrite to curing brines directly. Curing then took hours or days instead of weeks. On a farm, long curing is a small problem, but a commercial plant would otherwise have to hold large stocks of bacon still in cure.
I asked the South African meat scientist Dr. Francois Mellette for his comment on the design of the experiment. He observed that “the way the experiment was set up meant it was not possible for Dr. Polenske to determine if the nitrites were released from the proteins. He did the chemical analysis on the cover brine and the meat at the end of the period” (private correspondence with Dr. Mellette, 2017). Each vessel was analysed only once, when it was opened, so the paper gives three points in time and no continuous record.
Dr. Mellette also pointed to products made with salt alone. He explained that “the protein that are broken down yields NH3/NH4 and free PO4 from ATP/ADP and IMP. Traditional Spanish and certain Italian products made with salt only, also cures” (private correspondence with Dr. Mellette, 2017) (Note 6). The research of the last two decades gives a different explanation for the colour of these products. The stable red colour of Parma ham, which is made without nitrate or nitrite, comes from zinc protoporphyrin, which forms in the meat over months of ageing (Wakamatsu and colleagues 2004). Ammonia formed from proteins is not converted to nitrite in salted meat, because salt strongly inhibits the bacteria that oxidise ammonia (Moussa and colleagues 2006). In Polenske’s brines, the nitrite therefore came from the reduction of nitrate, as he proposed.
Unlocking the Secrets of Saltpetre
We are now so far removed from the time of saltpetre curing that it helps to look briefly at what saltpetre was and how its composition was worked out. I relied on a few authoritative works, and I quote freely from Richard P. Aulie’s review, “Boussingault and the Nitrogen Cycle”, published in the Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, Volume 114, Number 6, in 1970. Aulie traces the discovery of the nitrogen cycle through the work of the French chemist Boussingault, and I recommend his article to readers.
Uses and sources
For a long time, people did not know what saltpetre was made of, only what it could do. It was used in explosives, in meat curing, as a fertiliser, to cool beverages and, by the late 1800s, as a medicine for blood pressure. From the late Middle Ages, nations competed for saltpetre because it was the key ingredient of gunpowder.
The largest supply came from India, where potassium nitrate formed in the soil, and the English and Dutch East India Companies traded it in large quantities. Later, vast deposits of sodium nitrate were found in the Atacama Desert of Chile and Peru, and the salt became known as Chile saltpetre. On the coast of the Atacama, the Chinchorro people practised artificial mummification from about 5000 BCE (Arriaza 1995). Whether the nitrate salts of the region played a part in their methods of preserving bodies or meat is a possibility I consider in The Chinchorro Mummies of Atacama Desert.
I believe that saltpetre technology may have spread across Asia, India and into Europe from the Turpan Hami Basin in Xinjiang, in the far west of China, east of the Tarim Basin and the Taklimakan Desert. The nitrate deposits of the Turpan Hami Basin are estimated at about 2.5 billion tonnes, comparable in scale to the nitrate deposits of the Atacama (Qin and colleagues 2012, figure still to be checked). The region lies on the Silk Road. In the first millennium CE, the oases of Turpan and the Tarim were home to the Tocharians, who spoke Indo European languages. I discuss this further in The Tarim Mummies of China.
In India a large saltpetre industry developed in the north, near the border with Nepal, especially in Bihar around its capital Patna, as well as in West Bengal and Uttar Pradesh (Salkind 2006, 519). There, bacteria in the soil around villages formed nitrate from the urine and dung of people and animals. The monsoon rains soaked the ground, and in the dry season capillary action drew the nitrate salts to the surface, where people scraped them up and refined them. The Indian industry may have developed from a search for salts like the natural saltpetre of Turpan.
In China, a large saltpetre production site about a thousand years old was reported in 2003, in a network of caves in the Laojun Mountains of Sichuan Province (still to be checked). Meat curing in China is likewise strongest in the west and south of the country, and its development may have followed a similar course to that in India.
Saltpetre in China and Europe
China developed a strong tradition of curing meat, and Chinese alchemists were refining saltpetre, 消石 (xiāoshí, dissolving stone), well before it was known in Europe (Needham 1986). In Europe the general use of saltpetre in meat curing belongs to the early modern period (still to be checked). Europeans could not tell whether saltpetre occurred naturally or had to be nourished or cultivated. In fact both were true. It was found naturally, and it was also made in specially prepared earth.
In Germany the making of saltpetre became a regulated craft. In the villages of Württemberg, ducal ordinances from 1554 to 1747 gave licensed saltpetre boilers the right to dig in barns, stables and threshing floors, and the production was a right of the sovereign (Schahl 1969). Wherever Europeans obtained saltpetre, they struggled to remove its impurities, which gave inconsistent results in meat curing, in fertilising fields and in the quality of gunpowder. I discuss the place of the Turpan basin in the spread of saltpetre technology in my article Salt. 7000 Years of Meat Curing.
People could not explain its power, yet its uses were universal. Around 160 BCE, Cato the Elder described the curing of hams with salt (Cato, De Agri Cultura 162). The Chinese and the Italians used saltpetre to make gunpowder. There is a record of gunpowder in India as early as 1300 CE, probably introduced by the Mongols. Saltpetre was used since antiquity as a medicine and as a fertiliser (Cressy 2013, 12). From the 1500s, saltpetre was used in Asia and Europe to cool beverages and to ice foods (Reasbeck). Some held that it contained the spiritus mundi, the “nitrous universal spirit” that could unlock the nature of the universe (Cressy 2013, 12).
How writers saw saltpetre
Writers of the early modern period regarded saltpetre with awe, and Cressy (2013) collected their statements. The Elizabethan writer Peter Whitehorne wrote of saltpetre, “I cannot tell how to be resolved, to say what thing properly it is except it seemeth it hath the sovereignty and quality of every element.” Cressy describes how followers of Paracelsus (1493 to 1541), the founder of toxicology, regarded saltpetre as a mythical as well as chemical substance, with occult as well as material connections. They saw in it “a vital generative principle”, “a notable mystery the which, albeit it be taken from the earth, yet it may lift up our eyes to heaven” (Cressy 2013, 12).
From the 1400s to the late 1800s, writers probed the properties of this compound. Saltpetre was said to encompass the “miraculum mundi”, the “materia universalis”, through which “our very lives and spirits were preserved”. Its threefold nature evoked “that incomprehensible mystery of … the divine trinity”, in the words of Thomas Tymme’s translation (1605) of the Paracelsian Joseph Duchesne. Francis Bacon, Lord Chancellor and Privy Councillor under James I, described saltpetre as the energising “spirit of the earth” (Cressy 2013, 14).
The first natural philosophers
From the middle of the 1600s, European writers began to make important observations about saltpetre, though they had little experimental basis. Some of their conclusions were speculation, but they proved remarkably accurate. In 1658 Johann Rudolph Glauber (1604 to 1670) detected saltpetre in plants, animals and soil and speculated on the relationships between them. He did few experiments on plants, but he proposed that saltpetre nourished them. He called it “the Universal Menstruum”, and he wrote that “every pure Sand destitute of all fatness is quickly so fatted . . . we affirm that the Salt-Petre was of necessity in the Herbs, & Grass, afore the Beasts feeding on them ….” (Aulie 1970, 440).
In 1676 Edme Mariotte (1620 to 1684) speculated about the role of the atmosphere in plant nutrition, again without experimental basis. He wrote that “these volatile salts, etc., are mixed in the air with aqueous vapors, etc., and fall again with the rain formed with these vapors onto the surface of the ground. There they penetrate together as far as the roots of plants, where they enter with some particles of soil…” (Aulie 1970, 440).
From the earliest times, saltpetre was studied together with fertilisers and explosives. With the work of John Woodward (1665 to 1728) of the Royal College of Physicians, speculation on saltpetre and fertilisers gave way in England to a more practical approach to agriculture. French chemists, Boussingault among them, took up rigorous research on the subject.
Another French chemist, Louis Lémery (1677 to 1743), “showed for the first time that saltpeter is of organic origin and that it cannot be considered a mineral. In his 1717 paper, ‘On the Origin of Nitre,’ he described its slow production in the superficial layers of the soil. He also recognized the reciprocal relationships that characterize plants, animals, and the soil, while denying the previous ‘nitro-aerial matter’” (Aulie 1970).
The English and the French had different reasons for their interest. England gained access to the saltpetre of India, which reduced the national need to understand and manufacture it. France had no such supply and had to find better ways of producing saltpetre to meet the demands of its large army. In 1775 Antoine Lavoisier took charge of the new French gunpowder administration, the Régie des poudres, and improved saltpetre production (Mauskopf 1995).
Nitrogen identified
The practical English approach to fertilisers formed the background to the work of the French chemist Jean Baptiste Joseph Dieudonné Boussingault, who died on 11 May 1887 (his birth year is given as 1801 or 1802 in different sources). Boussingault became one of the most important researchers on nitrogen, and he is credited with laying the foundation for the discovery of the nitrogen cycle (Aulie 1970).
The next milestone was the identification of “nitrogen as a gas in the atmosphere, and as a constituent of both animal and plant tissues”. English and French chemistry together achieved this in the last quarter of the eighteenth century (Aulie 1970).
“By 1772 the English pneumatic chemists had isolated ‘mephitic air,’ but they had not yet established its elemental nature. The French quickly saw the importance of the English gas studies and, beginning with Antoine Laurent Lavoisier (1743–1794), rapidly incorporated them into their own work. They invented the names azote and nitrogene for the new gas, established its elemental nature, determined its quantitative percentages in nitric acid, ammonia, and saltpeter, and began to detect les azotates de potasse in many plants, all before the close of the eighteenth century” (Aulie 1970).
Potassium, nitrogen and oxygen were thus identified as the elements of saltpetre, although the exact ratio of atoms remained uncertain. Scientists, Boussingault in particular, worked out the value of nitrogen in plant and animal nutrition. That work prepared the ground on which others later discovered the role of microorganisms in fixing nitrogen and in transforming nitrate.
Boussingault and nitrate
A key question was where the nitrogen of plants came from. One possible source, still studied with great interest, was the nitrogen of the atmosphere. Another and more obvious one, given the long and well documented use of saltpetre, was nitrate.
In 1855 Boussingault turned to nitrates as a source of plant nitrogen, and this led him to ask how they form in the soil. He asked “if nitrates and ammonium salts are interchangeable in the soil, and which is the more efficacious; is one or the other actually the form in which nitrogen is absorbed by plants? Furthermore, did nitrates act essentially like alkali salts because of their sodium or potassium content, or like ammoniacal salts?” (Aulie 1970).
“Beginning with Boussingault in 1855, various workers attempted to settle these questions with the view of determining how plants get their nitrogen. These essentially chemical attempts continued until the late 1870’s, when the modern biochemical interpretation began to emerge. Kuhlmann thought that nitrates were formed by the oxidation of ammonia in the soil. As a corollary to this view, he also maintained that the utility of nitrates was due to their deoxidation into ammonium compounds in the soil. Noting the constant association of organic materials with nitrification, although, to be sure, missing the importance of microorganisms, he went on to assert that putrid fermentation was a necessary condition for this nitrification” (Aulie 1970).
“In the spring and summer of 1855, Boussingault examined this hypothesis by investigating the influence of potassium on Helianthus argophyllus, or the sunflower. He wished first to test whether putrescible organic material in the soil was absolutely indispensable for the absorption of the nitrogen of nitrates, and second, to determine whether there was a prior transformation into ammonium compounds” (Aulie 1970).
“The first part of this hypothesis was easy to test, which he did, by using an artificial soil free of all organic materials. In his first experiment, he reported to the Académie that his sunflowers flourished in a soil composed of calcined sand and ash, when watered with a solution containing 1.11 grams of potassium nitrate” (Aulie 1970).
“He showed that all the nitrogen could be accounted for by the potassium nitrate. Although Boussingault could not then test for the nitrate ‘ion,’ the contemporary ideas of ‘equivalents’ allowed him to determine the relative proportions of nitrogen and potassium both in the soil and in his experimental plants. At the time he began his nitrate work, there was still confusion about the number of atoms that would combine to make a compound. But chemical equivalents were directly measurable, and this concept Boussingault readily used to good advantage, as did many chemists of his day. Dictionaries and texts gave the composition of potassium nitrate as KO,AzO5.146” (Aulie 1970).
Boussingault reasoned that he could compare the ratio of alkali to nitrogen in his plants with the known value for nitre, and so judge whether the nitre had been transformed in the soil before the plants took it up. His data showed that potassium nitrate acted even in the absence of decomposing organic material. Whether the nitrogen entered as nitrate or as ammonia depended on the ratio of potassium to nitrogen (Aulie 1970).
“Boussingault considered his figures close enough to warrant the conclusion that potassium nitrate was absorbed as such by each equivalent of potassium, at least in this experiment, without prior transformation in the soil. Transformation into an ammonium salt prior to absorption would have resulted presumably in different analytical results, owing to the escape of volatile ammonia. His control plant languished in the absence of potassium nitrate; a slight increase in nitrogen he attributed to a visible cryptogamic contamination” (Aulie 1970).
“From the beginning of his career, Boussingault was aware that nitrogen was far from the only useful element in plant nutrition. As early as 1841 he was ‘certain that many calcium and mineral salts are indispensable for the development of plants.’ His work on nitrates in the late 1850’s was an experimental confirmation of his earlier views. Having demonstrated qualitatively in 1855 with Helianthus the pronounced growth that results with a regimen of potassium nitrate, Boussingault in 1857 then went on to demonstrate the quantitative effects produced in this plant by both mineral and nitrogen components of fertilizer on the elaboration of organic materials” (Aulie 1970).
Saltpetre, the role of nitrogen in the nutrition of plants, animals and people, the nitrogen cycle, and nitrifying and denitrifying bacteria are closely connected fields. Together they span chemistry, biochemistry, bacteriology, nutrition, medicine and meat science. Even today, some mechanisms of nitrate as a fertiliser and as a curing agent are not fully understood.
From Magendie to Polenske
Polenske measured the nutritional value of cured beef by its nitrogen content, and this way of judging food goes back to work by Magendie and Boussingault.
“François Magendie (1783–1855) reported in a classic study in 1816 that dogs could not survive on a diet of non-nitrogenous food alone. He wrote that ‘It would be of fundamental importance in the history of nutrition, if the source could be determined of the nitrogen which is found in such great abundance in the animal body.’” This study gave Boussingault “the clue on which he promptly acted in his first research work. This clue was the identification of nitrogen as an important ingredient in animal diet” (Aulie 1970). By 1891, nitrogen had become a standard measure of the nutritional value of meat, and Polenske determined it by the method of Kjeldahl. The nitrogen substance that the brine drew from the meat led him to judge cured meat inferior to fresh meat (Polenske 1891).
Conclusion
Lavoisier and his contemporaries discovered what saltpetre is made of. In the 1870s and 1880s, Schloesing, Müntz, Gayon, Dupetit and others showed that microorganisms form nitrate in soil and reduce it again. Polenske was the first to apply this knowledge to meat curing. In 1891 he reported that the nitric acid of saltpetre in curing brines was reduced to nitrous acid and ammonia, and he wrote that this reduction was “probably brought about by microorganisms”. He found the same products in the cured meat. His speculation was correct. Once Lehmann and Kisskalt had shown that nitrite produces the cured colour, his finding meant that nitrate was not the curing agent but the source of it. Haldane then identified the pigment. This sequence led to the use of nitrite in modern meat curing.
By the second half of the 1800s, Indian saltpetre was widely used in brine mixes around the world. An American newspaper gave a popular brine of fifteen pounds of salt, two and a half ounces of crude East Indian saltpetre and ten gallons of water, with molasses (quantity still to be checked). The meat was immersed in this brine and cured for forty to forty five days before it was smoked (Shenango Valley News, Greenville, Pennsylvania, 26 January 1883, page 3).
Butchers are observant people. I am convinced that some of them were aware that nitrate changed to nitrite in old brines, and that nitrite probably did the curing, before Polenske published and before nitrite was identified as the curing agent in the last decade of the 19th century. Through the ages, many butchers knew the chemical reactions of their trade well and followed closely the science of meat and blood. Polenske’s paper stands at the start of the scientific study of nitrite in cured meat.
Fact Check
We strive for accuracy and fairness. If you see something that does not look right, contact us at ebenvt@gmail.com.
(c) Eben van Tonder
Notes
The notes below give sources and the details behind figures in the text.
(1) In 1951 the United States Department of Agriculture published a survey of the brine mixes farmers most commonly used to cure bacon (Dunker and Hankins 1951, 6). It dates from the middle of the 20th century, but I include it because curing formulations changed slowly. The survey was carried out among farmers, who tend to keep to established methods.
(2) How salty was this bacon? The recipe was 10 lb (4.54 kg) salt, 3 lb (1.36 kg) brown sugar, 6 ounces (170 g) black pepper and 3 ounces (85 g) saltpetre, applied at 10 pounds (4.54 kg) of mixture per 100 pounds (45.36 kg) of meat. The mixture weighs 6.15 kg, of which salt is 74 percent. The 4.54 kg of mixture applied to 45.36 kg of meat therefore contains 3.35 kg of salt, which is about 74 g of salt per kg of meat. Not all of the salt was absorbed. Even so, compared with the target of about 25 g of salt per kg of final product that we used in 2016, this bacon would have been very salty despite the sugar. It would have needed soaking in water before it was eaten.
(3) The surname is spelled both Polenski and Polenske. His father’s name was spelled Polenski.
(4) Polenske, E. (1891). Ueber den Verlust, welchen das Rindfleisch an Nährwerth durch das Pökeln erleidet, sowie über die Veränderungen salpeterhaltiger Pökellaken. Arbeiten aus dem Kaiserlichen Gesundheitsamte, 7, 471 to 474. Berlin, Springer. http://books.google.co.za/books?id=R_YAAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA471
(5) Polenske measured nitrite colorimetrically with metaphenylenediamine, a reagent for nitrite introduced by Peter Griess in 1878. Griess had described the diazotisation reaction on which such tests rest in 1858. In 1879 he introduced the combination of sulphanilic acid and alpha naphthylamine in dilute acid, which became the basis of the Griess test for nitrite. According to Schaus (1956, 528), Griess reported a positive nitrite reaction with human saliva and consistently negative reactions with freshly voided urine from healthy individuals (still to be checked against Griess).
(6) Dr. Mellette added that “The typical aroma, texture and taste of these products are denatured and deaminated protein skeletons, and some oxidised fat (some of which are very pleasant and called in German ‘genuss saeure’, ‘enjoyable’ acids, or food acids” (private correspondence with Dr. Mellette, 2017).
My Complete Work on Nitrites
References
American Meat Science Association. Alternative Curing. Pork Information Gateway fact sheet. https://meatscience.org/docs/default-source/publications-resources/updated-resources/alternative-curing.pdf
Arriaza, B. T. (1995). Beyond Death. The Chinchorro Mummies of Ancient Chile. Washington. Smithsonian Institution Press.
Aulie, R. P. (1970). Boussingault and the nitrogen cycle. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 114(6), 435 to 479.
Binkerd, E. F. and Kolari, O. E. (1975). The history and use of nitrate and nitrite in the curing of meat. Food and Cosmetics Toxicology, 13(6), 655 to 661. https://doi.org/10.1016/0015-6264(75)90157-1
Cato, M. Porcius. De Agri Cultura. Around 160 BCE.
Cressy, D. (2013). Saltpeter. The Mother of Gunpowder. Oxford. Oxford University Press.
Dunker, C. F. and Hankins, O. G. (1951). A Survey of Farm Curing Methods. Circular 894. United States Department of Agriculture.
Haldane, J. (1901). The red colour of salted meat. Journal of Hygiene, 1, 115 to 122.
Honikel, K. O. (2008). The use and control of nitrate and nitrite for the processing of meat products. Meat Science, 78, 68 to 76.
Hüntelmann, A. C. (2008). Hygiene im Namen des Staates. Das Reichsgesundheitsamt 1876 bis 1933. Göttingen. Wallstein.
Kisskalt, K. (1899). Beiträge zur Kenntnis der Ursachen des Rotwerdens des Fleisches beim Kochen, nebst einigen Versuchen über die Wirkung der schwefligen Säure auf die Fleischfarbe. Archiv für Hygiene, 35, 11 to 18.
Lehmann, K. B. (1899). Über das Haemorrhodin. Ein neues weitverbreitetes Blutfarbstoffderivat. Sitzungsberichte der Physikalisch-Medicinischen Gesellschaft zu Würzburg, 4, 57 to 61 (still to be checked).
Mauskopf, S. H. (1995). Lavoisier and the improvement of gunpowder production. Revue d’histoire des sciences, 48, 95 to 121.
Moussa, M. S., Sumanasekera, D. U., Ibrahim, S. H., Lubberding, H. J., Hooijmans, C. M., Gijzen, H. J. and van Loosdrecht, M. C. M. (2006). Long term effects of salt on activity, population structure and floc characteristics in enriched bacterial cultures of nitrifiers. Water Research, 40, 1377 to 1388.
Needham, J. (1986). Science and Civilisation in China, Volume 5, Part 7, Military Technology. The Gunpowder Epic. Cambridge. Cambridge University Press.
Payne, W. J. (1986). Centenary of the isolation of denitrifying bacteria. ASM News, 52, 627 to 629.
Pegg, R. B. and Shahidi, F. (2000). Nitrite Curing of Meat. The N Nitrosamine Problem and Nitrite Alternatives. Trumbull. Food and Nutrition Press.
Polenske, E. (1891). Ueber den Verlust, welchen das Rindfleisch an Nährwerth durch das Pökeln erleidet, sowie über die Veränderungen salpeterhaltiger Pökellaken. Arbeiten aus dem Kaiserlichen Gesundheitsamte, 7, 471 to 474.
Qin, Y., Li, Y., Liu, F. and colleagues (2012). Science China Earth Sciences, 55, 213. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11430-011-4358-z
Ras, G., Zuliani, V., Derkx, P., Seibert, T. M., Leroy, S. and Talon, R. (2017). Evidence for nitric oxide synthase activity in Staphylococcus xylosus mediating nitrosoheme formation. Frontiers in Microbiology, 8, 598.
Reasbeck, M. (Lady Avelyn Wexcombe of Great Bedwyn, Barony of Skraeling Althing). Reviving the Use of Saltpetre for Refrigeration. A Period Technique.
Salkind, N. J. (ed.) (2006). Encyclopedia of Human Development. Thousand Oaks. Sage Publications.
Schahl, A. (1969). Der Salpetersieder im altwürttembergischen Dorf. Württembergisches Jahrbuch für Volkskunde.
Schaus, R. (1956). Griess’ nitrite test in diagnosis of urinary infection. Journal of the American Medical Association, 161, 528 to 529.
Shenango Valley News (Greenville, Pennsylvania), 26 January 1883, page 3.
Smith, E. (1876). Foods. New York. D. Appleton and Company.
The Wichita Daily Eagle (Wichita, Kansas), 3 September 1890, page 5.
Wakamatsu, J., Nishimura, T. and Hattori, A. (2004). A Zn-porphyrin complex contributes to bright red colour in Parma ham. Meat Science, 67, 95 to 100.