By Eben van Tonder, 10 August 2025

Introduction to Dr. Eduard Polenske and His Seminal Work
Dr. Eduard Polenske (1849 to 1911) was a German chemist at the Imperial Health Office (Kaiserliches Gesundheitsamt) in Berlin, where he worked at the centre of late 19th century food chemistry, public health and food regulation. According to family records, he was born on 27 August 1849 in Ratzebuhr, in the district of Neustettin in Pomerania, to Samuel G. Polenski and Rosina Schultz. He married a woman named Möller and lived in Berlin until his death in 1911 (Ancestry, family records for Eduard Polenske). He published under the name Polenske, which is the spelling used throughout this article, while his father’s name is recorded as Polenski.
The Imperial Health Office
The Imperial Health Office was founded in Berlin in 1876 to serve both the medical and the veterinary sectors of the German Empire. At first it was a division of the Reich Chancellery, and from 1879 it fell under the Reich Office of the Interior. In the same year the Food Law (Nahrungsmittelgesetz) was passed, which governed the trade in food, luxury foods and commodities. The office was given the task of supporting its enforcement. Its laboratories carried out chemical and bacteriological analyses and set scientific standards for food. In 1900 the newly formed Reich Health Council (Reichsgesundheitsrat) began to support its work, and the office became a national authority (Hüntelmann 2008).
In 1891 Polenske held the post of technical assistant (Technischer Hülfsarbeiter) in the chemical laboratory of the office, under its director, Professor Eugen Sell. He worked among leading chemists, veterinarians and public health officials, and together they laid the scientific foundation of modern food regulation in Germany.
Work on preservatives
Polenske worked extensively on food preservatives and their safety, and during the 1880s he became known for his critical tests of the chemical preservatives sold for meat. In 1890 the Wichita Daily Eagle of Wichita, Kansas reported on a convention of chemists at Speyer in Bavaria on 10 September 1888. The chemists debated agents such as boric acid and concluded that boric acid as a food preservative was to be “regarded with caution”. The report notes that Polenske examined ten “commercial preservatives intended for meat”. Between them they contained sulphurous acid or sulphites, borax, boric acid, alum, arsenious oxide, salicylic acid, free phosphoric acid, glycerine, boroglycerine, niter and common salt (The Wichita Daily Eagle 1890). Many of these caused public health concern at the time, and the niter was saltpetre.
The 1891 paper
In 1891 Polenske published the work that made his name a permanent part of the history of meat science. It is titled “Ueber den Verlust, welchen das Rindfleisch an Nährwerth durch das Pökeln erleidet, sowie über die Veränderungen salpeterhaltiger Pökellaken” (On the loss of nutritional value which beef suffers through curing, and on the changes in curing brines containing saltpetre). It appeared in Arbeiten aus dem Kaiserlichen Gesundheitsamte, Volume 7, pages 471 to 474. Polenske reported nitrite in curing brines and in cured meat to which only nitrate, in the form of saltpetre, had been added, and he wrote that microorganisms probably caused its formation. I know of no earlier published scientific investigation that reports such a finding, and the meat science literature cites his paper as the starting point.
This work places Polenske among the founders of modern meat curing science. Later researchers established that nitrite, and not nitrate, is the active curing agent. It acts through the formation of nitric oxide, which gives cured meat its colour and helps to preserve it. That later work began from Polenske’s measurements. Once curers understood how nitrite formed and could add it directly, curing times fell from weeks to days, and by the early 20th century the production of bacon, hams and other cured meats had changed completely.
Access to the paper
For decades the paper was held by only a handful of university libraries worldwide. A copy existed on Google Books, but the public could not view it. I regard it as one of the most important papers in the history of food science. Several years ago I petitioned Google to release it, and I set out its historical and scientific value. Google granted my request, and the paper is now freely available to scholars and to the meat industry.
Chemistry, microbiology and nutrition
In this paper Polenske brought together chemistry, microbiology and nutrition at a time when these disciplines were only beginning to work together for public health and industry. He set out to measure how much food value cured beef lost. In the course of that work he recorded how saltpetre changed in the brine, he proposed a microbial cause for the change, and he drew attention to its importance for hygiene.
Polenske continued his investigations into meat curing after his 1891 publication. He published “Ueber das Pökeln von Fleisch in salpeterhaltigen Laken” (On the curing of meat in brines containing saltpetre) in Volume 9 of Arbeiten aus dem Kaiserlichen Gesundheitsamte, pages 126 to 135. The contents of Volume 9 are dated 1894 (Kaiserliches Gesundheitsamt 1894), whereas some bibliographic records give 1893.
Below are the cover of the original journal, the title page and the first page of the actual article.



Introduction to the Work: Über den Verlust, welchen das Rindfleisch an Nährwerth durch das Pökeln erleidet, sowie über die Veränderungen Salpeter-haltiger Pökellaken (On the loss of nutritional value in beef due to curing, and on the changes in saltpetre-containing curing brines)
The Paper of 1891
The paper appeared under the heading “Mittheilungen aus dem chemischen Laboratorium des Kaiserlichen Gesundheitsamtes” (Communications from the chemical laboratory of the Imperial Health Office). It covers four pages, and its experiment, analyses and conclusions are set out below.
The experiment
Polenske wanted to know how a curing brine affected the food value of beef when the meat stayed in it for different lengths of time. He filled three vessels, each with a piece of beef and a brine made in the proportion of 6 kg water, 1.5 kg common salt, 15 g potassium nitrate and 120 g sugar. The vessels held 965 g, 1 035 g and 1 050 g of raw beef with 1 941 g, 1 659 g and 1 643 g of brine. He opened them after 3 weeks, 3 months and 6 months. He could measure food value reliably only by the nitrogen substance (Stickstoffsubstanz) and the phosphoric acid (Phosphorsäure). He was unable to measure the potassium salts exactly, and he explained why later in the paper (Polenske 1891, 471).
Observations
The first brine was still light red, almost clear and easy to filter, whereas the second and third brines were yellower, cloudy and harder to filter, with more sediment. As the meat aged, its colour became steadily paler. By smell, Polenske judged that even the meat in the last vessel had not putrefied (Polenske 1891, 471 to 472).
Including fat and bone, the meat gained 9.4 percent, about 13 percent and about 8.6 percent in weight, because meat juice and brine passed into each other. Polenske explained the differences by the proportions of muscle, fat and bone in the three pieces. The muscle meat contained between 11 and 12 percent sodium chloride, and it reached almost this level after only 3 weeks. The sediment of the brines consisted mainly of coagulated protein (Polenske 1891, 472).
The brine drew about 8, 10 and 14 percent of the nitrogen substance out of the meat, and between about 35 and 54 percent of its phosphoric acid. Polenske wrote that these findings confirmed the known fact that cured meat is inferior (Minderwerthigkeit des Pökelfleisches). Besides taking up curing salt, the meat lost its nourishing substances in such unequal proportions that its character as a food changed substantially. He added that in practice meat often lay in less brine for shorter periods, but a series of butchers’ brines still contained large amounts of nitrogen substance and phosphoric acid (Polenske 1891, 472 to 473).
The decomposition of saltpetre
Polenske wanted to measure the potassium salts that the brine had drawn from the meat. For this he needed to know how much potassium nitrate remained in the brine, and he therefore had to measure its nitric acid. The attempt failed. He repeated the test at intervals of several days, and each time the brine gave less nitric oxide gas. He concluded that the nitric acid was gradually breaking down, and he confirmed this when he found nitrous acid and ammonia in the brine (Polenske 1891, 473).
Polenske’s speculation
He then wrote the sentence for which the paper is known. In the original German of 1891 it reads:
“Die wohl durch Mikroorganismen herbeigeführte Reduktion der Salpetersäure zu salpetriger Säure und Ammoniak gab Veranlassung, zu erforschen, bis zu welchem Grade Letztere sich in den Pökellaken anzuhäufen vermögen. Zumal die gleichen Zersetzungsprodukte auch in dem Pökelfleische gefunden wurden, durfte dieser Gegenstand, die scharfe Verurtheilung des, diese Substanzen enthaltenden Trinkwassers ins Auge fassend, vom hygienischen Standpunkte aus betrachtet, beachtenswerth erscheinen” (Polenske 1891, 473).
In English: “The reduction of nitric acid to nitrous acid and ammonia, probably brought about by microorganisms, gave occasion to investigate to what degree the latter can accumulate in curing brines. Since the same decomposition products were also found in the cured meat, and bearing in mind the sharp condemnation of drinking water containing these substances, this subject seemed worthy of attention from the hygienic standpoint” (Polenske 1891, 473, translated by Eben van Tonder).
This is everything the paper says about the cause. Polenske attributes the reduction to microorganisms in a single subordinate clause, and he qualifies it with “wohl”, meaning probably. He therefore put his speculation in writing, in the paper itself. He proposed the microbial mechanism without isolating the bacteria or testing their role, and he based it on the microbiology of his day. Modern research has confirmed it. Gøtterup and colleagues measured nitrate reductase activity in staphylococci isolated from fermented sausages, bacon brine or cured meat products. In a model system with myoglobin, only strains having nitrate reductase activity generated MbFeIINO in assays containing nitrate as the sole nitrosylating agent (Gøtterup and colleagues 2007). In fermented sausages, the rate of MbFeIINO formation in sausages with added nitrate depended on the specific Staphylococcus strain (Gøtterup and colleagues 2008). Title of article : +2
Polenske treated the products as a question of hygiene. In the 1890s, chemists took nitrite and ammonia in drinking water as signs of contamination, and the public worried about them so much that even the weekly newspapers reported on it. When Polenske found the same substances in cured meat, he therefore raised a question of food safety. The Imperial Health Office and later regulators continued to treat nitrite in meat as such a question.
Further analyses
Polenske found that the ammonia and nitrous acid in the brines rose with age, but that their sum stayed far below what theory predicted. He explained this by the fact that freshly made brines, which were neutral, gradually became alkaline because of free ammonia, which slowly escaped (Polenske 1891, 473).
He extended the analysis to brines from Berlin butcher shops. One brine had been in contact with its first batch of meat for 3 days. Two had held a second and a last batch of meat, and another had lain on a ham for 5 months, and he analysed the muscle and fat of that ham as well. He also analysed American corned beef of the Lion Brand from Chicago, which still contained 0.26 g of saltpetre per 100 g. Nitrous acid was present in every sample, and ammonia in most. The butchers’ brines told him that the change he had found in his own vessels also took place in the daily practice of the Berlin meat trade (Polenske 1891, 473 to 474).
He then tested his methods by adding known amounts of meat extract and of saltpetre to the brines. He recovered all of the added nitrogen, whereas the nitric acid always came out 2 to 3 percent too low. He measured nitrogen by the method of Kjeldahl and nitric acid by the method of Schulze and Tiemann. Before measuring the nitrogen, he destroyed the nitric acid with ferrous sulphate and hydrochloric acid, as Warrington had described. He measured nitrous acid by its colour reaction with metaphenylenediamine, because zinc iodide starch gave misleading violet tones. He measured ammonia by distilling the brine with sodium carbonate, and he found only ammonia in the distillate and no amines. A cold method after Schlösing gave the same figures (Polenske 1891, 474).
Polenske and Meat Science
Before 1891 saltpetre was regarded as the curing agent, and curers assumed that the nitrate they added acted on the meat. Polenske’s paper began to change this understanding, and later work in Würzburg and Oxford took it further.
The first report of nitrite in curing brine
Polenske found that saltpetre does not remain nitrate in the brine and the meat. It turns into another nitrogen compound, nitrous acid, together with ammonia, and Polenske attributed the change to microorganisms. In 1899 Lehmann and Kisskalt showed that nitrite produces the red colour of cured meat, and from then on the importance of Polenske’s finding was plain. Nitrate was not itself the curing agent, because bacteria made the curing agent from it. Once curers understood this, they could cure with nitrite directly.
Polenske’s 1891 paper is among the earliest published works in the meat literature to report nitrite in curing brine and cured meat made with nitrate alone, and to attribute its formation to microorganisms. Later authors in meat science cite him as the source of this finding. The American Meat Science Association’s fact sheet on alternative curing notes that it is not clear from published literature when meat processors discovered that in fact nitrite, and not nitrate was responsible for successful meat curing. It then credits Polenske, writing that experiments in the late 1800s demonstrated that nitrate in the cure was converted to nitrite by nitrate-reducing bacteria, since nitrite was found in cured meat and in the curing pickle when only nitrate was initially added to the cure solution (Polenske, 1891). The same fact sheet states that in a separate experiment, Lehman (1899) and Kisskalt (1899) both concluded that the typical color of cured meats was attributed to nitrite and not nitrate. The reviews of curing history by Binkerd and Kolari (1975), Pegg and Shahidi (2000) and Honikel (2007) also begin the scientific account of nitrite in curing with Polenske. meatscience
Nitrification and denitrification before 1891
Polenske’s speculation followed from research that was well established by 1891. In 1877 Jean Jacques Théophile Schloesing (1824 to 1919) and Charles Achille Müntz (1846 to 1917) showed that living organisms form nitrate in soil and sewage, a process called nitrification. In the early 1880s Ulysse Gayon and Gabriel Dupetit introduced the term denitrification, and in 1886 they isolated two strains of denitrifying bacteria in pure culture (Payne 1986). Like the researchers on nitrification, they worked for agriculture.
Polenske cites Schlösing and Warrington for his methods of analysis, and both men had worked on nitrification in soil. He knew their field, and he applied its findings to the curing brine. In this way a chemist who set out to measure the food value of beef identified the microbial step on which nitrate curing depends.
The researchers who followed
After Polenske’s paper, German researchers studied curing brines for three decades, and Polenske himself returned to the subject in Volume 9 of the office’s journal. F. Nothwang published studies on curing in the Archiv für Hygiene, which later researchers on cured meat cite as Archiv für Hygiene 1893, 16, 122 and 18, 80. Nothwang’s explanation for the loss of saltpetre in cured meat is still to be checked against his text. springer
In 1899 Karl Bernhard Lehmann at the Institute of Hygiene in Würzburg showed that nitrite, and not nitrate, produces the red colour of cured meat. His assistant Karl Kisskalt confirmed this. He also found that meat left in saltpetre for several days before cooking turned the same colour, as the reduction of nitrate proposed by Polenske would lead one to expect (Lehmann 1899, Kisskalt 1899). Later authors cite Kißkalt in Archiv für Hygiene 1899, 35, 11. In 1901 John Scott Haldane in Oxford identified the pigment as a compound of nitric oxide and haemoglobin (Haldane 1901). springer
The Imperial Health Office itself continued the work Polenske began. In 1919 Friedrich Auerbach and Gustav Riess published a method for measuring small amounts of nitrite, especially in cured meat, in the office’s own journal (Auerbach and Riess 1919). In the decades that followed, the meat industry learned to add nitrite to curing brines directly, and nitrite curing salt replaced saltpetre.
The modern understanding
Two findings of recent research complete the account. Ammonia formed from meat proteins is not oxidised to nitrite in salted meat, because salt strongly inhibits the bacteria that oxidise ammonia (Moussa and colleagues 2006). The nitrite in Polenske’s brines therefore came from the reduction of nitrate, as he proposed. Nitrite then forms nitric oxide by chemical reactions in the meat, and nitric oxide binds to myoglobin to give the cured colour (Honikel 2008).
Conclusion
Polenske’s 1891 investigation occupies an important position in the scientific history of meat curing. His detection of nitrous acid in curing brines prepared with saltpetre, and his suggestion that microorganisms probably caused the reduction of nitrate, provided an early published account of a chemical transformation fundamental to nitrate curing.
His observations preceded the investigations of Lehmann and Kisskalt in 1899, which established the importance of nitrite in producing the characteristic colour of cured meat, and Haldane’s investigation in 1901 into the chemistry of the red pigment. Polenske did not establish the complete mechanism of meat curing. However, his work documented an essential chemical change and recognised its possible microbiological origin.
His contribution therefore deserves recognition as an important early step in the development of modern meat curing science. Although further investigation of nineteenth century chemical, veterinary and food hygiene literature may reveal earlier observations, his 1891 publication remains an established reference in the scientific history of nitrate and nitrite curing.
References
American Meat Science Association. Alternative Curing. Pork Information Gateway fact sheet. https://meatscience.org/docs/default-source/publications-resources/updated-resources/alternative-curing.pdf
Ancestry. Family records for Eduard Polenske (birth, parents, marriage and death).
Auerbach, F. and Riess, G. (1919). Über die Bestimmung kleiner Mengen salpetrigsaurer Salze, besonders im Pökelfleisch. Arbeiten aus dem Reichsgesundheitsamte, 51, 532.
Binkerd, E. F. and Kolari, O. E. (1975). The history and use of nitrate and nitrite in the curing of meat. Food and Cosmetics Toxicology, 13(6), 655 to 661. https://doi.org/10.1016/0015-6264(75)90157-1
Gøtterup, J., Olsen, K., Knøchel, S., Tjener, K., Stahnke, L. H. and Møller, J. K. S. (2007). Relationship between nitrate/nitrite reductase activities in meat associated staphylococci and nitrosylmyoglobin formation in a cured meat model system. International Journal of Food Microbiology, 120, 303 to 310.
Gøtterup, J., Olsen, K., Knøchel, S., Tjener, K., Stahnke, L. H. and Møller, J. K. S. (2008). Colour formation in fermented sausages by meat associated staphylococci with different nitrite and nitrate reductase activities. Meat Science, 78(4), 492 to 501. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.meatsci.2007.07.023
Haldane, J. S. (1901). The red colour of salted meat. Journal of Hygiene, 1(1), 115 to 122.
Honikel, K. O. (2007). Principles of curing. In F. Toldrá (ed.), Handbook of Fermented Meat and Poultry, 17 to 30. Ames. Blackwell.
Honikel, K. O. (2008). The use and control of nitrate and nitrite for the processing of meat products. Meat Science, 78, 68 to 76.
Hüntelmann, A. C. (2008). Hygiene im Namen des Staates. Das Reichsgesundheitsamt 1876 bis 1933. Göttingen. Wallstein.
Kaiserliches Gesundheitsamt (1894). Inhaltsverzeichnis, Arbeiten aus dem Kaiserlichen Gesundheitsamte, Band 9. Robert Koch Institut, edoc. https://edoc.rki.de/bitstream/handle/176904/6399/Inhaltsverzeichnis_Kaiserlichen%20Gesundheitsamte%20Band%209.pdf?isAllowed=y&sequence=3
Kisskalt, K. (1899). Archiv für Hygiene, 35, 11 (title still to be checked).
Lehmann, K. B. (1899). Sitzungsberichte der Physikalisch-Medicinischen Gesellschaft zu Würzburg (title and pages still to be checked).
Moussa, M. S., Sumanasekera, D. U., Ibrahim, S. H., Lubberding, H. J., Hooijmans, C. M., Gijzen, H. J. and van Loosdrecht, M. C. M. (2006). Long term effects of salt on activity, population structure and floc characteristics in enriched bacterial cultures of nitrifiers. Water Research, 40, 1377 to 1388.
Nothwang, F. (1893). Archiv für Hygiene, 16, 122, and 18, 80 (titles still to be checked).
Payne, W. J. (1986). Centenary of the isolation of denitrifying bacteria. ASM News, 52, 627 to 629.
Pegg, R. B. and Shahidi, F. (2000). Nitrite Curing of Meat. The N Nitrosamine Problem and Nitrite Alternatives. Trumbull. Food and Nutrition Press.
Polenske, E. (1891). Ueber den Verlust, welchen das Rindfleisch an Nährwerth durch das Pökeln erleidet, sowie über die Veränderungen salpeterhaltiger Pökellaken. Arbeiten aus dem Kaiserlichen Gesundheitsamte, 7, 471 to 474.
Polenske, E. (1894). Ueber das Pökeln von Fleisch in salpeterhaltigen Laken. Arbeiten aus dem Kaiserlichen Gesundheitsamte, 9, 126 to 135.
The Wichita Daily Eagle (Wichita, Kansas), 3 September 1890, page 5.
Changes from v8, following the review:
- Title. I used the reviewer’s title. If you prefer the shorter one, it is easy to put back.
- Priority claims. These are now qualified: “I know of no earlier”, “among the earliest”, and “he applied its findings” instead of “he was the first to apply”. The conclusion uses your text word for word.
- Ras 2017. Replaced by Gøtterup and colleagues (2007, 2008). They measured nitrate reductase in staphylococci, including strains isolated from bacon brine, and they reported that only strains with this activity formed the cured pigment from nitrate. The text now also says that Polenske proposed the mechanism without isolating the bacteria.
- The second paper. It now has pages 126 to 135. The year stays 1894 according to the RKI contents, with a note that some records give 1893. I could not open the RKI PDF from here. If the title page of Volume 9 says 1893, change both the text and the reference.
- Biography. It is now attributed to the Ancestry family records. The Google petition remains your own first person account.
- Still open. The titles and pages for Lehmann, Kisskalt and Nothwang are still marked to be checked.
Sources:
Polenske 1891, pages 471 to 474