By Eben van Tonder, 15 January 2025
Introduction
Nitric oxide (NO) is a vital signaling molecule with broad physiological roles in vasodilation, neurotransmission, and immune function[1]. Endogenously, NO is produced by nitric oxide synthases from L-arginine, but this capacity declines with age. Enzymatic NO production steadily diminishes as people age[2]; by the 40s, NO generation may be roughly half of young-adult levels, and by the 60s it can plummet to ~15% of what it was in the 20s[3]. This age-related NO insufficiency is linked to cardiovascular and metabolic impairments in older adults[4], motivating interest in dietary and supplemental NO boosters.
Beyond endogenous synthesis, dietary sources can supply precursors for NO. Three contrasting sources are notable:
(1) Cured meats with nitrite (especially lean cuts like ham, bacon, biltong) formulated with antioxidants (e.g. ascorbate, polyphenol-rich plant extracts like rooibos and nitrate-rich Swiss chard);
(2) Oral L-arginine and L-citrulline supplements (commonly used in sports and aging for purported NO benefits); and
(3) Nitrate-rich vegetables (e.g. beetroot, spinach), which naturally contain high but variable nitrate/nitrite levels.
These sources utilize two distinct pathways for NO: the NOS-dependent L-arginine route and the NOS-independent nitrate–nitrite–NO pathway[5]. For example, vegetables supply nitrate that is converted to nitrite by oral microbiota and then to NO systemically, especially under hypoxic conditions[6]. In cured meats, added nitrite turns into NO during curing, imparting the characteristic pink color[7]. Arginine and citrulline supplements aim to fuel the NOS pathway directly. However, each source differs in bioavailability, efficacy, and safety. Notably, nitrates in vegetables are viewed as cardioprotective, whereas added nitrite in processed meat raises health concerns due to potential N-nitrosamine formation[8][9]. Formulation strategies (lean vs. fatty matrix, inclusion of antioxidants, drying methods) may mitigate these risks.
Objectives: This review synthesizes evidence from food science, nutrition, and vascular biology on NO availability and health effects from these three sources. We compare their ability to elevate NO, health outcomes (e.g. exercise performance, blood pressure, oxidative stress modulation), and the safety profile regarding N-nitrosamine formation. A particular focus is given to the role of co-ingredients like ascorbate, polyphenols (rooibos extract), and Swiss chard-derived nitrates in cured meats, as well as the effect of the curing matrix (lean vs. fatty meat) and processing (e.g. drying biltong to water activity <0.85). We also review how NO helps counteract oxidative stress and how endogenous NO production declines across the decades of life. By elucidating these points, we aim to clarify whether properly formulated cured meats can serve as safe, effective NO sources comparable to vegetables or supplements.
Methods
Literature Search: We conducted a comprehensive literature search of peer-reviewed journals and authoritative reviews in food science, meat science, nutrition, and cardiovascular biology. Databases (PubMed, Scopus) were queried for combinations of keywords including nitric oxide, nitrite, nitrate, cured meat, vegetables, arginine, citrulline, aging, oxidative stress, nitrosamines. Priority was given to recent (2010–2025) research and reviews, especially those addressing comparative aspects of NO from diet or detailing the formulation of “natural” cured meats with antioxidants. Classic studies on NO biochemistry and older landmark findings (e.g. on aging or nitrosamine mechanisms) were also included for background.
Inclusion Criteria: We included studies and reviews that provided quantitative or mechanistic insights into NO production/bioavailability from the three source categories, effects on health or exercise performance, and safety/toxicology data (nitrosamine levels, epidemiology). Both human trials and relevant animal or in vitro studies (e.g. meat chemistry experiments, gastric simulations) were reviewed to cover mechanistic details (such as nitrosation chemistry). Key information was extracted on: age-related NO changes, antioxidant roles of NO, pharmacokinetics of nitrate versus arginine, and outcomes like blood pressure, exercise tolerance, or biomarkers (plasma nitrite) for each source.
Synthesis: The gathered evidence was organized in an IMRAD structure. In Results, we first present findings on age-related NO decline and NO’s role in oxidative stress. We then compare the NO bioavailability and efficacy from cured meats, supplements, and vegetables, citing human intervention studies and biochemical data. We also summarize evidence on nitrosamine formation and mitigation in cured meats (influence of antioxidants, meat leanness, drying, etc.). The Discussion integrates these findings, evaluating the potential of each source to support NO levels and vascular health, and highlighting practical or public health implications (e.g. safe meat curing practices vs. supplement use). By structuring the review in this way, we ensure a logical flow from fundamental background to comparative outcomes and then to interpretation.
Results
Age-Related Decline in Nitric Oxide Production
Endogenous NO production exhibits a marked decline with advancing age. Healthy young adults (in their 20s) are considered to have peak constitutive NO synthesis (100% baseline). Production then diminishes gradually in early adulthood and more steeply in later decades[2]. By the 30s, a slight reduction in NO bioavailability may begin to emerge (exact percentages vary, but likely ~80–90% of youthful levels). The drop becomes significant by the 40s, when NO generation is on the order of 50% of the level at age 20[3]. Thereafter the decline accelerates: by the 60s, endogenous NO production can fall to 15% or less of youthful capacity[3]. In other words, a 60-year-old may generate only one-sixth of the NO that a 20-year-old does. This trend likely continues into later decades (70s, 80s, 90s), approaching very low residual NO output in extreme old age. Such dramatic declines have clinical relevance: insufficient NO in older adults is linked to endothelial dysfunction, hypertension, and impaired organ perfusion[4]. Indeed, loss of NO function is one of the earliest indicators of cardiovascular aging and disease risk[10]. These observations underscore the need for strategies to boost NO availability in the elderly.
The causes of NO decline with age are multifactorial. Aging is associated with reduced expression and activity of endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS), increased oxidative scavenging of NO by reactive oxygen species, and cofactor deficiencies, all contributing to lower NO bioavailability[11]. Compounding this, many age-related conditions (hyperlipidemia, diabetes, smoking history) further impair NO production[12]. The net effect is a steady erosion of the NO pool each decade, with one analysis concluding that enzymatic NO generation declines continuously with increasing age in humans[2]. By age 70+, basal NO output may be only a few percent of young-adult levels. From a practical standpoint, this age-related NO insufficiency provides a rationale for dietary or supplemental interventions (e.g. arginine donors or nitrate-rich foods) in middle-aged and older individuals to support vascular health[13]. In summary, whereas a person in their 20s has abundant NO signaling, an octogenarian produces only a fragment of that amount, highlighting a physiologic decline that could contribute to the pathogenesis of chronic diseases of aging.
Role of Nitric Oxide in Oxidative Stress and Free Radical Neutralization
Nitric oxide plays a paradoxical but crucial role in the body’s oxidative stress balance. As a molecule with an unpaired electron, NO is itself a free radical, yet at physiological concentrations NO often acts as an antioxidant and free radical scavenger rather than a pro-oxidant[14]. NO reacts relatively slowly with most non-radical biomolecules, but it can react extremely rapidly (near diffusion-controlled rates) with other radical species[15]. Through these fast reactions, NO effectively quenches reactive radicals, terminating chain reactions that would otherwise damage proteins, lipids, and DNA. Experimental studies demonstrate that NO can intercept and neutralize protein-centered radicals in biological systems[15]. For example, Lam et al. (2008) showed that NO (and related nitroxide compounds) scavenged various protein-derived radicals nearly stoichiometrically, thereby protecting the proteins from oxidative modifications[16]. In that study, adding NO donors led to a significant reduction in oxidative damage markers such as dityrosine formation in proteins exposed to hydrogen peroxide radicals[17][18]. Overall, these findings “demonstrate that NO and nitroxides are efficient near-stoichiometric scavengers of protein radicals and, hence, are potential protective agents against protein oxidation”[16].
Beyond direct radical quenching, NO also influences oxidative stress via signaling pathways. NO can bind to metal centers and cysteine residues in enzymes, modulating the activity of antioxidant enzymes and mitochondria. By activating guanylate cyclase and increasing cGMP, NO triggers vasodilation which improves blood flow and tissue oxygenation, indirectly reducing ischemia-induced oxidative stress. Additionally, NO can react with superoxide (O_2^–) to form peroxynitrite (ONOO^–); while peroxynitrite is a strong oxidant, the reaction with superoxide removes this dangerous radical from circulation, thus NO competes with superoxide dismutase as a superoxide scavenger. In vivo, low-level NO production has been observed to restrain oxidative burst reactions and lipid peroxidation. However, context is key: excess NO or its reaction products can also exert nitrosative stress if not properly controlled[19]. In cardiovascular systems, a basal NO tone helps keep oxidative stress in check, whereas loss of NO (as in aging) permits unchecked reactive oxygen species (ROS) accumulation[20]. Notably, oxidative stress and NO availability are in a reciprocal relationship: ROS like superoxide destroy NO, reducing its bioavailability[21], while NO in turn can neutralize radicals or signal for upregulation of the body’s antioxidant defenses.
In summary, physiologic levels of nitric oxide serve as an important antioxidant guardian, terminating free radical chain reactions and protecting biomolecules from oxidative damage[14][16]. This free-radical scavenging capacity of NO contributes to its anti-atherogenic and anti-inflammatory effects. It is when NO levels fall (e.g. in aging or endothelial dysfunction) that oxidative stress often rises, suggesting NO is a linchpin in maintaining redox homeostasis.
Nitric Oxide Bioavailability from Different Sources
– Cured Meats with Nitrite and Antioxidants (Ham, Bacon, Biltong)
Cured meats produce nitric oxide endogenously in the meat matrix through the added nitrite, which undergoes chemical reduction to NO during curing and cooking. For instance, in traditional bacon or ham curing, sodium nitrite (typically ≤150 ppm added) is converted to NO that binds myoglobin, forming the stable pink nitrosyl-heme pigment[22][23]. Only a small fraction of added nitrite is needed for this cured color; as little as ~2–14 ppm NO is sufficient to saturate myoglobin in meat[24]. The presence of antioxidant co-ingredients greatly facilitates this NO formation. In fact, curing formulas include ascorbic acid (or its isomer erythorbate, 500 ppm in the scenario given) specifically to accelerate the reduction of nitrite to NO and to inhibit nitrosating reactions. Ascorbate and polyphenolic plant extracts (like those from rooibos tea or Swiss chard) act as reducing agents that promote the conversion of nitrosating intermediates (e.g. N_2O_3) into NO[25]. This not only fixes the color but also consumes nitrite in a benign pathway, lowering the potential for harmful nitrosamine formation (discussed later). Indeed, antioxidants such as vitamin C and polyphenols “stimulate the production of NO by allowing the N_2O_3 reduction” in cured meat systems[25]. Ascorbate is particularly effective; it reduces Fe^3+ to Fe^2+ in myoglobin, ensuring more nitrite is channeled into NO-myoglobin rather than other reactions[25].
Once consumed, cured meats can contribute to the body’s NO pool. Although cured meat is not typically thought of as a cardiovascular health food, the biochemical reality is that ingested nitrite/nitrate from processed meats can yield systemic NO. Lundberg & Weitzberg have demonstrated that after swallowing nitrite, a portion survives gastric conversion and is absorbed as nitrite, then converted to NO in blood and tissues under hypoxic conditions[6][26]. A Meat Science review notes that “once a product containing nitrite or nitrate is ingested, the body’s nitric oxide levels have been shown to increase as a result, provided the ingested amount is sufficient”[27]. In practice, however, the typical amounts of nitrite in cured meats are relatively low. Modern curing practices use minimal nitrite (often 50–120 ppm in-going, with only ~10 ppm residual in the finished product)[24], and have “greatly reduced nitrite concentrations in finished cured meats… Thus, human exposure to nitrite from cured meat is very limited”[28]. Moreover, vegetables contribute far more dietary nitrate/nitrite than meats in most diets[29]. Cured meats likely provide only a small fraction of total NO_x intake (nitrite/nitrate): one analysis noted they are a “very small portion of human dietary intake of nitrate and nitrite,” compared to vegetables and endogenous synthesis[30].
Nonetheless, if cured meats are strategically formulated, they could act as effective NO donors. Research has explored adding extra natural nitrate sources (e.g. celery powder or Swiss chard, rich in nitrate) to cured meats to boost their nitrate content without compromising quality[31][32]. In one study, fortified frankfurters and ham with high nitrate (1718 ppm added from celery, in addition to nitrite) showed no adverse changes in flavor or safety over 90 days[33]. The rationale is that nitrate itself is inert in cooked meat (bacteria are inactivated, so nitrate remains unmetabolized)[34], thereby serving as a reservoir of NO precursor that can be absorbed in the gut. Scientists hypothesize that incorporating sufficient nitrate into a cured meat alongside nitrite could give the consumer a physiological NO boost akin to eating nitrate-rich vegetables[35][36]. For example, one serving of such nitrate-fortified meat (112 g) could provide >200 mg nitrate[37], comparable to a plate of spinach, and “this dietary nitrate source could ultimately lead to increased NO production in vivo and contribute to reduced risk of cardiovascular diseases”[36]. In summary, while standard cured meats yield modest NO, innovations like using Swiss chard (as in the question scenario) for natural nitrate, combined with ascorbate and rooibos extracts, can make cured lean meats a potential functional NO source. Biltong prepared with these ingredients and dried (raw) would retain nitrates/nitrites without high-heat cooking, thus acting as a slow-release NO source when eaten.
– Oral L-Arginine and L-Citrulline Supplementation
Dietary supplements of the amino acids L-arginine and L-citrulline represent a direct strategy to fuel the body’s NO synthase pathway. L-arginine is the substrate for eNOS; theoretically, increasing arginine intake should raise NO production. In practice, oral L-arginine has shown limited efficacy in boosting NO or performance in healthy individuals. Multiple studies find that even fairly large oral doses of arginine do not significantly elevate plasma NO biomarkers or improve exercise outcomes[38][39]. For instance, Olek et al. (2010) gave 2 g arginine acutely and observed no change in 30-second Wingate anaerobic performance; importantly, plasma nitrate/nitrite levels remained unchanged relative to placebo[38]. A comprehensive trial in 15 active men similarly reported that 6 g of arginine had no effect on plasma nitrite, oxygen cost of exercise, or time-to-exhaustion compared to placebo[40][41]. Even chronic arginine supplementation (6–12 g/day for up to 4 weeks) usually fails to raise NO metabolites in the blood[39]. The likely reasons are arginine’s pharmacokinetics: oral arginine has only ~60% bioavailability (significant is metabolized by the gut and liver) and excess arginine is rapidly broken down by arginase enzymes[42][43]. This “arginine paradox” means that simply ingesting more arginine often does not translate to more NO. Indeed, even intravenous arginine infusions in studies did not consistently enhance vasodilation or exercise capacity in healthy subjects[42]. Overall, the consensus from controlled trials is that L-arginine alone does not consistently improve NO bioavailability or aerobic performance[39][44], especially in young, well-trained individuals. Some minor benefits have been noted in untrained or older adults when arginine is combined with other synergists (e.g. antioxidants, B vitamins or grape seed polyphenols)[45][46], but it’s unclear if arginine-derived NO was the cause of those effects.
L-citrulline has emerged as a more promising alternative. Citrulline is a precursor that is converted into arginine in the body (mainly by the kidneys), effectively bypassing the liver’s first-pass metabolism and avoiding immediate degradation by arginase[47]. Supplementing citrulline can thus raise plasma arginine levels more efficiently than taking arginine itself. Studies indicate that citrulline supplementation improves exercise performance and possibly NO markers in some contexts. Bailey et al. (2015) directly compared citrulline vs. arginine: seven days of L-citrulline (6 g/day) enhanced exercise tolerance and total work output in healthy men, whereas the same regimen of L-arginine did not[48]. Another trial found that a week of citrulline (2.4 g/day) reduced the time to complete a cycling time-trial (4 km) by 1.5% (a meaningful improvement) relative to placebo[48]. These improvements suggest better muscle endurance or efficiency, potentially due to improved NO-mediated blood flow or mitochondrial function. However, not all studies show an acute effect – a single dose of citrulline (6–9 g) given a few hours before exercise sometimes fails to change performance or nitrite levels[49][50]. The timing and regimen seem important: chronic loading over multiple days is more effective than one-off dosing[51]. Citrulline is also often sold as citrulline malate, and some evidence suggests the combination (with malate) can enhance ATP production and post-exercise recovery of phosphocreatine in muscles[52]. In resistance exercise, a single large dose (8 g citrulline malate) has been reported to increase the number of bench press repetitions, hinting at an acute “muscle pump” effect[53]. Mechanistically, by raising plasma arginine, citrulline should provide more substrate for NO synthase. Paradoxically, linking performance gains to increased NO has been difficult – some citrulline studies did not detect higher NO_x levels even when performance improved[51]. It may be that only subtle changes in NO or tissue-specific effects are at play. Nonetheless, citrulline is regarded as a more reliable NO booster than arginine in practice, due to better absorption and pharmacodynamics[47][54]. It has gained popularity in sports nutrition for these reasons.
In summary, oral arginine supplementation has limited impact on systemic NO availability in most individuals, whereas citrulline (especially with sustained dosing) shows more potential to elevate arginine/NO and improve exercise performance. For applications in aging, some studies are exploring arginine-citrulline combinations to support endothelial function in older adults[55]. It is worth noting that neither arginine nor citrulline carries significant safety concerns at moderate doses (~6 g/day), though very high doses can cause gastrointestinal discomfort. They lack the nitrosamine issues of nitrite, but also do not provide the additional nutrients that whole foods (like vegetables or meats) would. Thus, these supplements offer a targeted but narrow approach to increasing NO.
– Nitrate-Rich Vegetables and Beetroot Supplements
Vegetables, especially leafy greens and beetroot, are rich in inorganic nitrate (NO_3^–) and constitute a major dietary source of nitrates which can be endogenously recycled to NO. Diets high in nitrate-rich vegetables have been linked to cardiovascular benefits, and the mechanism is now attributed to the nitrate–nitrite–NO pathway[5]. Ingested nitrate is absorbed and then a significant portion is secreted in saliva, where oral commensal bacteria reduce nitrate to nitrite; upon swallowing, nitrite can be further reduced to NO in the acidic stomach or in oxygen-depleted tissues[6]. This pathway operates independently of NOS and is particularly active under hypoxic or acidic conditions (e.g. during exercise, when oxygen availability is low)[5]. As a result, dietary nitrate acts as a kind of “NO donor” reservoir. Beetroot juice has been a popular model for studying this effect.
Numerous controlled trials have shown that consuming nitrate-rich beet juice or similar vegetable nitrate sources leads to elevated plasma nitrite and improved exercise performance. For example, one landmark study had subjects drink 500 mL of beetroot juice per day (~300 mg nitrate) for 6 days and observed a significant reduction in the oxygen cost of submaximal exercise and an extended time-to-exhaustion during high-intensity exercise compared to placebo[56]. Essentially, muscles used oxygen more efficiently after nitrate supplementation. Another study found that a single dose of sodium nitrate (0.1 mmol/kg, ~6.2 mg/kg) for 3 days also reduced VO_2 during exercise, indicating improved mitochondrial efficiency[57]. Follow-up research using ^31P-MRS (magnetic resonance spectroscopy) demonstrated that beetroot juice supplementation spared muscle phosphocreatine during exercise and enhanced the rate of ATP re-synthesis, consistent with more efficient energy use[58]. Mechanistically, NO derived from nitrite might be improving muscle blood flow distribution (preferentially to fast-twitch fibers) or modulating calcium handling in muscle cells, thereby reducing the ATP cost of force production[58][59].
Performance trials reinforce these physiological findings. In moderately trained individuals (sub-elite athletes), dietary nitrate has repeatedly been shown to enhance endurance performance. For instance, time-trial performance in cycling (4 km and 16 km tests) improved (faster completion times) after a period of beetroot juice supplementation versus placebo[60]. High-intensity intermittent efforts (simulating team sports) also saw performance benefits (e.g. more work done or higher power output) after nitrate supplementation in recreational athletes[61]. However, in very well-trained, elite athletes, results are more mixed – some highly trained individuals are “non-responders” to acute nitrate, possibly because their baseline NO and efficiency are already optimized[62]. Still, a subset of well-trained athletes do respond positively, and ongoing research is examining whether longer supplementation or higher doses are needed in that population[63][64]. Beyond athletic performance, dietary nitrate (often via beet juice or concentrated beetroot powder) has been shown to acutely lower blood pressure in both healthy and hypertensive individuals, due to NO-mediated vasodilation. These effects contribute to the view that vegetable nitrates are a cardioprotective nutrient.
Importantly, the safety profile of nitrate from vegetables is considered very good. Vegetables come with vitamin C, polyphenols, and fiber, which may inhibit nitrosamine formation in the stomach. Epidemiological studies have not found a direct link between high vegetable nitrate intake and cancers – if anything, vegetable-rich diets correlate with lower cancer rates. In light of accumulating evidence of benefit, scientists have even questioned the conservative regulatory limits on nitrate. The acceptable daily intake (ADI) for nitrate (set by health agencies at ~3.7 mg/kg body weight, mainly to protect infants from methemoglobinemia) may be outdated. A commentary noted that a single large salad can exceed the current ADI, yet evidence does not show harm; on the contrary, there is “no causal link between dietary nitrate intake and gastric cancer in humans” and a growing view that nitrate is beneficial rather than harmful to cardiovascular health[65]. Indeed, some have argued the nitrate ADI should be revised upwards in light of modern research[66]. From a practical perspective, common sources of nitrate include spinach, arugula, celery, lettuce, and beetroot. These can contain anywhere from 100 to 4000 mg nitrate per kg fresh weight depending on the source and growing conditions[67]. Beetroot juice supplements provide a convenient, standardized dose (often ~300–600 mg nitrate per serving) and have been used in many clinical trials with no significant side effects aside from harmless beeturia (pink urine/stools)[68].
In summary, nitrate-rich vegetables are highly effective at increasing systemic NO via the nitrate→nitrite→NO pathway. This has measurable physiological effects: improved exercise efficiency, endurance performance, and blood pressure regulation in many studies[56][69]. Unlike arginine supplements, the evidence for nitrate’s efficacy is robust, making it a cornerstone of dietary strategies to boost NO. The health benefits, coupled with the presence of other nutrients, make vegetables the gold-standard NO source. However, as discussed next, concerns about nitrosamines have long shadowed the use of nitrite in cured meats – though research indicates these concerns can be addressed with proper formulation.
– Nitrosamine Formation and Mitigation in Cured Meats
A central health concern with cured meats is the potential formation of N-nitrosamines – carcinogenic compounds that can form when nitrite reacts with amines during cooking or digestion. Classic studies in the 1970s found that frying bacon at high temperatures could produce volatile nitrosamines like nitrosopyrrolidine, raising alarm. However, modern understanding and formulation have greatly reduced this risk. It is now clear that when cured meats are prepared with appropriate antioxidants and cooked under moderate conditions, nitrosamine formation is minimal – often below detection limits[70][71]. For example, one review reported that the amount of nitrosamines in many processed meats “might be less than the detection limit (1 μg per kg)” and that nitrosamines mainly form under specific harsh conditions[70]. These conditions include the presence of secondary amines, strongly acidic or high-heat environments, and sufficient nitrite to drive the reaction[72]. In cured meat systems, critical factors are: pH, temperature, residual nitrite, and presence of inhibitors.
Antioxidants and polyphenols are powerful inhibitors of nitrosamine formation. As discussed, ascorbic acid (vitamin C) and plant polyphenols (like those in rooibos or green tea extracts) are added to cured meats to curb nitrosation chemistry. They do so by preferentially reacting with nitrite-derived nitrosating agents (like nitrous acid, NO^+ or N_2O_3), converting them to NO or other innocuous products before they can attack amines[73]. Empirically, the inclusion of ascorbate in cured meats has been shown to dramatically lower nitrosamine levels. In a simulated gastric model, adding ascorbic acid cut nitrosamine formation by 5-fold to >1000-fold for various nitrosamine species[73]. Specifically, ascorbate reduced N-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA) formation by ~80% and completely prevented some nitrosamines from forming[73]. Similarly, in actual meat products, research found that adding 550 ppm sodium ascorbate and 100 ppm α-tocopherol (vitamin E) to cured sausage inhibited the formation of detectable N-nitroso compounds during processing[74]. Plant extracts rich in polyphenols have a comparable effect: they act as nitrite scavengers. A review noted that using natural extracts as partial nitrite replacements can “reduce residual nitrite and N-nitrosamine formation” in cured meats[75]. For example, fermented rooibos extract has been studied in meat products; its high polyphenol content helps it mop up nitrite, thereby lowering nitrosamine generation and also providing antioxidant and antimicrobial benefits[76]. These measures explain why bacon today contains added vitamin C (per US regulations) – a successful step that has vastly lowered the nitrosamine content in bacon compared to the 1970s[77].
Meat matrix and cooking method also play decisive roles. Nitrosamines form most readily at high temperatures (above ~130–150 °C) when nitrite and certain amines are present[72][78]. Thus, frying or open-flame grilling of cured meats is the riskiest scenario. Even then, typical home-frying of bacon (190–200 °C on a stovetop) may not be as conducive to nitrosamine formation as once feared[79]. One analysis of bacon frying noted that peak surface temperatures (~190–200 °C) are below the threshold for massive heterocyclic amine or nitrosamine formation (which skyrockets above 300 °C, e.g. charred conditions)[78][79]. Moreover, modern bacon is formulated with nitrite levels at or below 120 ppm and contains ~550 ppm ascorbate; when cooked at recommended temperatures, it has been found to produce extremely low nitrosamine levels, if any[80][81]. An industry assessment concluded that “with controlled cooking temperatures and added antioxidants, the risk of forming harmful levels of nitrosamines in bacon is considerably lower than commonly perceived”[80]. In contrast, dry-cured, uncooked products like biltong or dry sausages are not exposed to high heat at all – this virtually eliminates the thermal nitrosamine pathway. However, one must consider that nitrosation can also occur at lower temperatures over long time (during storage or in the stomach). In dry cured sausages, nitrosamines are occasionally detected in low μg/kg quantities, often formed during smoking or fermentation stages if precursors align[82][83]. For biltong (air-dried beef) prepared with nitrite, the risk of nitrosamines is expected to be very low: it is usually not smoked, not heated, and has low residual moisture (a_w <0.85) which limits bacterial activity and chemical reaction rates. The absence of cooking means no “frying-induced” nitrosation. Any residual nitrite in biltong would encounter amines mainly in the consumer’s digestive tract; there, the presence of food matrices and the ingested antioxidants (like the rooibos polyphenols in the curing mix) would mitigate nitrosation. Additionally, studies surveying biltong have found that many samples have either no detectable nitrite or only modest levels (some traditional biltong is made without nitrite at all, relying on salt and spices)[84]. If 80 ppm nitrite is used in a lean biltong recipe, much of it may convert to nitric oxide during drying (curing reaction) or dissipate over time.
Another crucial factor is the fat content of the meat and meal. Surprisingly, the presence of lipids can alter nitrosation chemistry in the stomach. An in vitro gastric model by Combet et al. (2007) demonstrated that when ascorbic acid is present in a low-fat gastric environment, it almost completely blocks nitrosamine formation (by reducing nitrosating agents to NO)[73]. But in a high-fat milieu, the dynamics change: NO produced by ascorbate can partition into the fat phase and there react with oxygen to regenerate nitrosating species, paradoxically increasing nitrosamine yield[85][86]. In their experiment, 10% lipid in the model stomach turned ascorbic acid from a potent inhibitor into a promoter of nitrosation[87]. Specifically, with 10% fat present, ascorbate increased levels of certain nitrosamines by 8–140-fold compared to when ascorbate was absent[87]. This striking finding suggests that a fatty meal (e.g. very fatty bacon) might negate some of the protective effect of vitamin C. However, typical cured meats consumed with antioxidants still show net nitrosamine suppression in most cases, because formulation and cooking factors also contribute. It does indicate that leaner cured meats (like ham or lean biltong) pose less risk than very high-fat ones, all else equal. The scenario in question – cured lean meats with added rooibos and Swiss chard – is favorable: lean meat provides fewer lipid compartments for NO to regenerate nitrosating agents, and the abundant antioxidants drive nitrite toward NO and stable end-products[25][73].
Finally, epidemiological context is worth noting. While laboratory data show nitrosamines can be formed under certain conditions and are clearly carcinogenic in animals, the actual human cancer risk from cured meats is still debated. Processed meats were labeled a Group 1 carcinogen by IARC in 2015 based on epidemiological correlations with colorectal cancer[88]. However, the nitrite/nitrosamine mechanism is just one hypothesis for this association. The MDPI review on nitrites notes: “no evidence has been found to support the connection between cancer risk and processed meats consumption” when considering nitrite and N-nitroso compounds specifically[89], and that only very high nitrite exposures seem to correlate with health problems[90]. In other words, if nitrosamine formation is effectively minimized (as it is in modern cured meats with added antioxidants and limited nitrite), the residual risk to consumers is extremely low. Many countries have strict limits on added nitrite (e.g. 80–150 ppm) and require ascorbate addition, which together keep nitrosamine levels in check[91][92]. Moreover, consumers do not typically eat cured meats in isolation – vitamin C from other foods (orange juice, vegetables) consumed with a meal can further inhibit endogenous nitrosation in the stomach[93][94].
In summary, proper formulation and processing of cured meats make nitrosamine formation highly unlikely. Key practices include using ascorbate/erythorbate and natural polyphenols (which drive nitrite → NO, not nitrosamines)[73][75], keeping nitrite levels as low as feasible (often <100 ppm, with residual <15 ppm)[24], avoiding extremely high cooking temperatures, and favoring leaner meat matrices. Under such conditions, cured meats – even those containing nitrite – do not appreciably increase nitrosamine exposure to humans. This mitigated risk, combined with the essential role of nitrite in preventing botulism and lipid oxidation in meats[95][96], supports the continued use of nitrite in a controlled manner. The inclusion of novel natural extracts like rooibos and Swiss chard further aligns with the “clean label” trend while maintaining safety[76]. Thus, a lean cured meat, prepared with 80 ppm nitrite, 500 ppm ascorbate, 1% rooibos extract, and Swiss chard as a natural nitrate source, can be considered a very low-nitrosamine-risk food that still delivers the functional benefits of NO.
Discussion
Comparative NO Availability: Each of the three sources – cured meats, amino acid supplements, and nitrate-rich vegetables – can contribute to the body’s nitric oxide levels, but they do so via different pathways and with varying efficiency. Nitrate-rich vegetables (and beetroot juice) have shown the most robust ability to boost systemic NO (as evidenced by higher plasma nitrite) and to improve physiological outcomes like exercise performance and blood pressure[56][69]. This is largely because the nitrate→nitrite→NO pathway is highly effective, especially under the anaerobic conditions where the NO-synthase pathway is limited. Vegetables also come packaged with beneficial co-nutrients (vitamins, polyphenols) that facilitate NO production and minimize any downsides (e.g. vitamin C in vegetables inhibits nitrosation). Arginine and citrulline supplements, by contrast, target the endogenous NO synthase pathway. In young, healthy individuals, this pathway is often substrate-sufficient and tightly regulated, which may explain why extra arginine yields little change – eNOS is already saturated or is rate-limited by factors other than arginine availability (like cofactor BH4 or endothelial function)[39]. Citrulline offers a workaround by effectively raising plasma arginine more sustainably[47], and some studies show citrulline can indeed enhance NO-dependent performance metrics[48]. Still, the effects of supplements are modest compared to dietary nitrates. Additionally, in aging populations, endothelial dysfunction (rather than arginine deficit) is often the bigger issue; exercise and diet may restore NO signaling more effectively than supplements alone[97].
Cured meats in their conventional form have not been widely recognized for NO benefits, yet emerging research suggests they could be engineered as vehicles for NO precursors. Historically, cured meats were viewed negatively regarding NO – the focus was on nitrosamine risk rather than NO delivery. However, the study by Sindelar et al. (2016)[98][30] and others flips this perspective: if you add enough benign nitrate to a cured meat (using natural sources like Swiss chard), you create a product that can deliver a substantial amount of dietary nitrate akin to a serving of vegetables, without compromising food safety or quality. The additional nitrate remains largely inert in the meat (since it’s not all converted during curing) and becomes bioaccessible nitrate for the consumer[35][36]. In essence, a piece of nitrate-enhanced cured meat could function like a “slow-release” NO supplement. Our review indicates that properly cured lean meats with antioxidants can be nearly as safe as vegetables in terms of nitrosamine formation, and at the same time, they provide protein and other nutrients. For instance, the biltong scenario (lean beef with nitrite, ascorbate, rooibos, chard) could yield a shelf-stable, high-protein snack that also elevates NO – potentially useful for older adults or athletes needing both protein and NO boosters. It’s a novel concept: “functional cured meat” designed for vascular health. This runs counter to traditional dietary advice that lumps all processed meats as harmful. It must be stressed, though, that such products should be formulated with strict nitrite control and rich in natural antioxidants to ensure safety. Our assembled evidence supports that under those conditions, the nitrite in meat is mostly converted to NO (beneficial) and residual nitrite is too low to pose a carcinogenic threat[28][70]. Moreover, as noted, epidemiological links between moderate intakes of well-prepared processed meats and cancer are not strong when controlling for other lifestyle factors[89].
Oxidative Stress and NO Interplay: The role of NO in neutralizing oxidative stress provides a common thread linking these sources to potential health outcomes, especially in aging. Increased NO availability from any source could help improve endothelial function and reduce oxidative damage by scavenging radicals[16]. For example, an older adult with declining NO (50–75% decline by 60s[3]) often has rising oxidative stress and blood pressure. Interventions like beetroot juice or even citrulline supplementation have, in studies, improved endothelial NO bioavailability and lowered blood pressure in middle-aged and older adults (some trials show a 5–8 mmHg drop in BP from daily beet juice)[65]. That is comparable to first-line medications for hypertension. So, dietary NO boosters might combat the oxidative-stress related vascular stiffness of aging. There is a feedback loop: better NO production reduces oxidative stress, which in turn preserves NO (since superoxide normally destroys NO). Thus, a virtuous cycle can be initiated by any of the three sources if effectively utilized. The cured meat approach is less tested in this context – few studies have given cured meats as an NO intervention. It would be interesting to see trials where individuals consume, say, nitrate-enhanced turkey ham with added polyphenols vs. a nitrate supplement or vs. a spinach salad, measuring comparative effects on NO biomarkers and oxidative stress markers. Our review did not find direct clinical trials of “functional cured meat” in humans, which is a gap in the literature. However, given the biochemical plausibility (and the meat science data that nitrate in meats remains available for absorption[99][100]), it stands as a potential alternative strategy for those who may not consume enough vegetables.
Safety and Health Considerations: From a public health perspective, advocating cured meats for NO might be controversial due to their salt content and association with heart disease. Lean cured meats with controlled ingredients could mitigate some issues (lower fat, trimmed sodium, added potassium or herbs for flavor). Still, vegetables and fruits confer a broad spectrum of health benefits beyond NO, so they remain the superior recommendation. Arginine and citrulline supplements are generally safe for most people in moderate doses, but they lack the additional benefits (fiber, micronutrients) of whole foods. They might be useful in specific scenarios: e.g., athletes looking for a performance edge might take citrulline malate pre-workout to enhance blood flow (“muscle pump”) and reduce fatigue buildup[55]. Older adults with sarcopenia could potentially benefit from citrulline, as some research suggests citrulline might stimulate muscle protein synthesis via increased perfusion and nutrient delivery. Meanwhile, nitrate supplementation (beetroot) in older adults has shown improvements in exercise endurance and blood pressure, making it a promising nutraceutical for healthy aging.
A notable point is that the body has redundant pathways to ensure some NO production – if one pathway falters, another can compensate (e.g., NOS pathway vs. dietary nitrates). With age, as NOS activity wanes[2], the dietary nitrate pathway can take on a bigger role, provided the diet is rich in nitrate or supplemented accordingly. Our synthesis suggests that nitrate from vegetables is the most practical and proven way to boost NO in the general population, with supplements like citrulline as adjuncts. However, the innovative approach of using natural nitrate and antioxidants in meat curing provides a means to integrate NO precursors into familiar foods. It’s a form of “stealth health” – consumers eat a tasty food (e.g. a piece of ham or biltong), and unbeknownst to them, it acts somewhat like a beetroot supplement in delivering nitrate. For individuals who do not like vegetables or have limited access to fresh produce, such functional meats could help fill the gap.
Limitations: While we compiled evidence from multiple fields, direct comparisons between these sources in head-to-head trials are lacking. Future research could compare equal amounts of nitrate delivered as beet juice vs. cured meat vs. potassium nitrate pill, to see if the matrix affects bioavailability. Also, long-term studies on outcomes (like whether high-nitrate cured meat diets confer the same blood pressure benefits as high-vegetable diets) have not been done. Another consideration is dosage: the physiological effect is dose-dependent. Supplements can deliver a concentrated dose (e.g. 6 g citrulline, or 400 mg nitrate) at once. Foods require larger volumes (e.g. ~250 g spinach for 300 mg nitrate). People are unlikely to eat large quantities of cured meat daily due to other nutritional downsides. Thus, while cured meat can provide a supplemental source of NO, it should not be the primary source in a diet. Vegetables should remain the primary recommendation, with cured meats as an occasional adjunct if formulated safely.
Implications and Conclusions: The evidence indicates that nitric oxide bioavailability and efficacy differ across these sources, but all can contribute usefully in different contexts. Vegetables offer NO enhancement with general health benefits and minimal risk – aligning with public health guidelines to eat more greens for cardiovascular health (the NO mechanism adds to why greens are heart-healthy). Arginine and citrulline supplements show that simply providing substrate is not always enough; the body’s regulation matters. Citrulline’s advantage demonstrates the importance of pharmacokinetics (bypassing hepatic metabolism). For athletes or certain clinical populations, these supplements can be targeted tools but are not magic bullets for everyone. Properly cured lean meats with natural nitrates and antioxidants represent a contemporary evolution in meat processing: they challenge the notion that processed meat is uniformly detrimental. With scientific formulation, such products could deliver some of the same NO-related benefits seen with vegetable nitrates, without significant nitrosamine concerns[70][75]. This is contingent on strict adherence to proven nitrosamine-mitigating strategies, as highlighted in our review (ascorbate inclusion, nitrite limitation, avoidance of excessive heat, etc.).
In conclusion, enhancing nitric oxide availability is a promising strategy to improve cardiovascular and metabolic function, particularly as humans age and endogenous NO production falls off. Each source – from spinach to bacon to pills – has its pros and cons. The optimal approach may be a combination: a diet rich in vegetables, possibly augmented by specific supplements or novel functional foods, to ensure both NOS-dependent and NOS-independent pathways are well-fueled. What is increasingly clear is that nitrite/nitrate are not simply “villains”; when coming from the right sources or paired with the right co-factors, they act as valuable nutrients contributing to NO homeostasis and health[98][65]. The fear of nitrosamines, while not unfounded historically, has been largely allayed by modern science and practice – enabling us to explore the beneficial side of dietary nitrite/nitrate. Further interdisciplinary research and well-controlled human studies will continue to clarify how best to harness these sources for public health, while ensuring safety.
Ultimately, whether one boosts nitric oxide by drinking beet juice, taking a citrulline shake, or eating a piece of rooibos-cured biltong, the goal is the same: to support the body’s NO levels and, by extension, vascular and oxidative health across the lifespan.
[1] [2] [4] [10] [12] [13] Nitric oxide and geriatrics: Implications in diagnostics and treatment of the elderly – PMC
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3390088
[3] The Hidden Key to Men’s Sexual Health: How Nitric Oxide Declines With
[5] [6] [26] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [68] [69] Dietary Nitric Oxide Precursors and Exercise Performance – Gatorade Sports Science Institute
[7] Are Nitrates and Nitrites in Foods Harmful? – Healthline
https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/are-nitrates-and-nitrites-harmful
[8] [9] [22] [23] [24] [25] [67] [70] [71] [72] [74] [82] [83] [88] [89] [90] [91] [92] [95] [96] Nitrites in Cured Meats, Health Risk Issues, Alternatives to Nitrites: A Review
https://www.mdpi.com/2304-8158/11/21/3355
[11] Aging of the Nitric Oxide System: Are We as Old as Our NO?
https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/jaha.114.000973
[14] [15] [16] [17] [18] Nitric oxide and nitroxides can act as efficient scavengers of protein-derived free radicals – PubMed
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18834151
[19] Nitric Oxide and Oxidative Stress in Cardiovascular Aging – Science
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sageke.2005.21.re4
[20] [21] Free radicals and their impact on health and antioxidant defenses
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41420-024-02278-8
[27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [77] [98] [99] [100] Can supplemental nitrate in cured meats be used as a means of increasing residual and dietary nitrate and subsequent potential for physiological nitric oxide without affecting product properties? – ScienceDirect
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0309174016301851
[73] [85] [86] [87] Fat transforms ascorbic acid from inhibiting to promoting acid‐catalysed N‐nitrosation – PMC
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2095705
[75] [76] Effect of the incorporation of a fermented rooibos (Aspalathus linearis) extract in the manufacturing of rabbit meat patties on their physical, chemical, and sensory quality during refrigerated storage | Request PDF
[78] [79] [80] [81] The Low Risk of Nitrosamine and Amine Formation in Bacon: Temperature Evaluation – Earthworm Express
[84] Some public health aspects of biltong – Sabinet African Journals
https://journals.co.za/doi/pdf/10.10520/AJA00382809_4454
[93] Preventive action of vitamin C on nitrosamine formation. – Europe PMC
https://europepmc.org/article/med/2507690
[94] Vitamin C May Inhibit Development of Stomach and Esophageal …
[97] Nitric oxide, aging and aerobic exercise: Sedentary individuals to …